Reviews

3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
2/10
Sound quality so poor it is unwatchable
9 May 2022
The sound quality on this is so poor that it is completely unwatchable. The background "music" is not background, and drowns out everything else. I'm disappointed, because I really wanted to watch this.
1 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The R.I.P. Files (2012– )
2/10
The sound effects are awful
30 June 2019
The number and volume of sound effects is overwhelming throughout the show, and often overwhelms the dialogue &/or narration. The editing is also poorly done, with very little relation from scene to scene. Overall, very poor. Very, very poor.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Not as Good as I would have hoped
7 August 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Let me preface this by saying that David Tennant's portrayal of Aiden was masterful and, while I feel Emily Watson was poorly cast here, her effort as Freya was very well done, as well.

However -- either the writing was weak, or this was a 6 hour miniseries cut down to three. So much is missing. So much is there and makes you ask yourself, why?

The son... what role does he play? Having a child with challenges like this, there was so much character development, for the child as well as for his parents, that could have gone on around this story arc that... didn't. The daughter? Other than the fact of the existence of children in the home (and the nanny being a presence), there is little development here.

Many of the plot lines simply... end... without any closure. What happened with the nanny? What happened with the son's challenges at school and elsewhere? What was the purpose of Aiden's father's death?

I feel that this could have been so much better, had only they taken the time to tell the story in more depth, or not left so many arcs hanging. How do you go from "I'll take the children away so you can move out," in one scene, to arrival at #10 as an obviously estranged but "united front in front of the cameras" power couple in the next?

As I said, the story, while brilliantly acted, was choppy; either poorly written, or half of it is still laying on the editing room floor.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed