Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
While it is not what I expected, it was what I needed
19 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The third special of this spin off from the animated series My Little Pony, is not exactly what I expected it to be. I hoped for more interaction between Susnet and her former mentor as well as a more intriguing sub plot regarding her and her dilemmas between the human world and the pony one. That is what everyone's expected, but it is not what we received.

Instead we had Sunset having no dilemmas regarding her home, but having anxiety for not knowing when the unpredictable magic could appear, as well as more interaction between Sunset and Starlight with more protagonism for the latter. At first I wasn't too happy with this, but after a second watch I saw how brilliant ALL the conversations Sunset had with Starlight really turned to be.

However there was one minor issue, and this was the lack of build up from the last two specials for the magic that would end up being used in this special, making all the dilemma of Sunset rather come from nowhere.

The overall message and connection that Sunset and Starlight create is both unexpected and delightful. The main plot of the story, feels a little overused, but I loved how the characters acknowledge this in order to prove their point and forgive Juniper Montage for the "attrocities" that she has done.

While I do believe there was a little potential loss in this premise, the way they gave a new spin to Sunsets characters by using the character interactions with Starlight, is more than enough for me to recommend this special to every fan of the show.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A stunning work of Art
19 June 2017
I am a big fan of animation, from Anime to Disney, DreamWorks, even French animation; but very few times I have seen an outstanding, gorgeous work of art like "THE RED TURTLE"

To begin with, the film has a beautiful 2D animation, which is perfect to show the amplitude of the ocean, and the comparison between the human bodies and those created by nature. The sea, the island, the animals, everything in this movie is animated in an incredible way which makes you feel trapped by this world that looks like a painting in constant motion. Unlike other films, in THE RED TURTLE the approach is rarely only in its characters, but in the environment and how the protagonists unfold in a world as big and unknown as the ocean and the island.

Many movies, specially animated ones, don't take too many risks, and nowadays with the computer animation, I feel like the style that each artist could give to their movies, is slowly disappearing, but this movie proved me wrong. Besides, this movie does nothing else than adding limitations: no dialogue; no facial expressions; not even detailed or "interesting" environments. But all this factors are not really necessary in this 80 minutes long movie, which focuses on the journey that the main character faces while exploring all the stages of life.

The most incredible thing about this movie is that it is completely mute; therefore it only uses the music and animation to tell the story. It is very easy to explain what happens, but cinema is an audiovisual medium, and this film shows the true scope of the animation, and how it can combine the music, the images and the corporal movements of the characters to transmit the messages and emotions. Without the protagonists saying a word, one can feel the desperation, frustration, doubt, intrigue, happiness and madness that they experience.

The story in this movie is very simple, but this is not necessarily a bad thing, because its objective is to use all the elements I mentioned before and use the simple storytelling and characters in their advantage so that they can make the audience experience a different emotion and messages. The main focus of THE RED TURTLE is on the meaning of life, acting like a mirror to our own, therefore, it is the audience the one that creates the complex story by relating the multiple variations and allegories to their own experiences, and this is what will make the story vary from person to person.

Apart from the obvious moral of "man vs. nature" this film exploits other messages, such as "the beauty in the unexpected" and "the circle of life", explained, surprisingly, better than in THE LION KING, with the turtle representing the life of a person.

Even the secondary characters, who serve as comic relief like the crabs, are very entertaining and fun without the need to go to the absurd, making the audience laugh with simple movements and few scenes, turning each appearance in camera into a luxury for the viewer.

In my opinion, due to a beautiful combination of music, animation, plot and message, THE RED TURTLE is the best animated film of 2016.

In conclusion, if you are going to watch this movie, don't try to understand it, because it doesn't have a "logical" story, since it uses a different storytelling technique making you experience different feelings and situations, while exploring the true meaning of life and death. So just seat down and enjoy the ride.
29 out of 47 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed