Change Your Image
ekolodny-4
Reviews
Nightmare Alley (1947)
Great premise, terrible execution
Setting a noir film in a carnival sideshow was brilliant. What happened to the plot is a mystery to me. I can usually overlook minor plot holes and suspend my disbelief for the sake of entertainment, but the gaps in this film are so large that the movie ends up limping along to a predictable, clichéd ending. I never understood the whole carnival wedding between Stan and Molly - they were caught speaking to one another and thus were forced to be married? I didn't understand Lilith's motivation - why would a psychologist want to torment her patients? I didn't understand why Zeena let Stan run off with her act - wouldn't she be angry that her valuable code is being used with such success? I'd be interested to read the original novel by William Greshem to see if these problems are better fleshed out. It just seemed like the filmmakers got so carried away with the carnival atmosphere (which was fantastic, by the way, and justifies my rating of a 6) that they forgot the plot.
Troop 1500 (2005)
Forgotten victims
This is a wonderful film documenting the effect on girls with mothers in prison. The film is not an educational video and documentaries do not have to be entirely objective. In order to make a really moving documentary, the filmmakers necessarily have to get close to their subjects. These filmmakers did just that, spending months with the girls in Troop 1500 before even turning on a camera. The film follows the lives of seven girls, most in their pre-teens, and their incarcerated mothers. Troop 1500 is a Girl Scout troop in Austin, Texas that offers support to these girls and moms. The film is honest about why the moms are in prison (contrary to the previous review) and the failures of the program, as well as the successes. It is refreshing to see inmates portrayed as more than just one-dimensional bad people; this film shows the effects of incarceration on the children of prisoners.
In addition to just being a really interesting topic, the film is engrossing and entertaining. I thought the soundtrack was great. It's not supposed to be a depressing movie. It's about hope and love and life, and the tone is appropriately serious yet not melodramatic. I had the fortune of seeing this film in a class at UTexas Law School and had a Q&A with two of the social workers involved with the troop. They are very inspiring women who really care about these girls and their relationships with their moms, and have had some great success stories from the program.