Hi Disney,
pretty please have a look for a barn, a BIG barn, ney an enormous barn!
Now find the biggest and baddest shotgun you can get. Never mind a 12 guage, get a Goose gun (8 guage)
Point shotgun at barn and pull trigger.
Trust me, like this movie, you will miss.
The main problem you have is that there is a definite target audience for this film and that comprises the millions of people like me who have avidly read all the books.
Unfortunately, this film bears little resemblance to the first, presumably, two or three books in the series it tries and fails to cover.
Who stole Artemis' Mother?
Why did Butlers Sister Juliet turn into his Niece?
Why did Julius Root turn into Judy Dench (Love her to bits but really)?
Why in Gods name is Mulch Diggums suddenly 5 or 6 feet tall? Carrot Ironfoundson on Discworld is at least a human brought up by Drarves.
Seriously Disney, you had a great chance to kick off a potential franchise but have so messed up the storyline that I am doubtful that it will happen.
I think you were unbelievably lucky theat Eoin Colfer sold the film rights BEFORE the first book came out because I doubt very much he would have signed it off if he new what an utter hatchet job you were intending.
I gave it a 4 rating only because as a stand alone movie it wasn't bad but that was allowing my imagination to wipe out my knowledge of the books.
34 out of 68 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends