To paraphrase one of Patsy Parisi's more famous lines from the series: The Many Saints of Newark IS cinematic....and that's where it's going to disappoint fans.
The film is well shot and directed, the cast does a good job of playing young versions of the series' main cast, and there is saga-like ambition in the use of the Newark race riots to backdrop the action, but The Many Saints of Newark ends up feeling grim and somber, lacking much of the series' dark humor and use of everyday banality as a relatable plot device.
We don't gain insights into why Dickie Moltisanti was such a legendary figure, nor do we come to really understand his influence on young Tony Soprano. Mostly we're just shown that Dickie and Tony's relationship would be the model for Tony and Christopher's.
A storyline focusing on black gangs organizing to take control of the numbers action in their communities, and away from the Italian mob, would make more sense if this had been a two-part opener for a new series. But in the context of a one-off movie it doesn't payoff in any meaningful way other than as an historical insight into what was going on in the Newark underworld at that time (and maybe, obliquely, to the Willie Overalls plot point in the series).
Similarly, and again in a callback to Patsy Parisi, this movie uses the Sopranos' technique of having one actor play a set of twins. In this case though, this subplot also doesn't seem to make much sense. Perhaps the jailhouse discussions between Dickie and Sally were meant to serve the same purpose as Tony's conversations with Dr. Melfi: a Greek Chorus into the protagonist's thought process, but except for one key bit of advice Sally gives at the end, it also seems like a lot of build up for no significant payoff.
There are vignettes meant to indicate Tony's ultimate evolution into a crime boss but nothing really convincing. Perhaps the producers didn't want to be too on-the-nose with young Tony, but an onscreen depiction of something like the robbery of Feech LaManna's card game probably would have made more sense to audiences than the few petty crimes we do see.
Ultimately this would have been a great opener for a new TV series- one that I would definitely want to watch- but as a movie it felt rushed and disjointed, without sufficient time to explore some potentially intriguing characters and themes. It was cinematic in its style and tone but ultimately too thin in its substance to stand alone as an attempt to contextualize the groundbreaking Sopranos series.
The film is well shot and directed, the cast does a good job of playing young versions of the series' main cast, and there is saga-like ambition in the use of the Newark race riots to backdrop the action, but The Many Saints of Newark ends up feeling grim and somber, lacking much of the series' dark humor and use of everyday banality as a relatable plot device.
We don't gain insights into why Dickie Moltisanti was such a legendary figure, nor do we come to really understand his influence on young Tony Soprano. Mostly we're just shown that Dickie and Tony's relationship would be the model for Tony and Christopher's.
A storyline focusing on black gangs organizing to take control of the numbers action in their communities, and away from the Italian mob, would make more sense if this had been a two-part opener for a new series. But in the context of a one-off movie it doesn't payoff in any meaningful way other than as an historical insight into what was going on in the Newark underworld at that time (and maybe, obliquely, to the Willie Overalls plot point in the series).
Similarly, and again in a callback to Patsy Parisi, this movie uses the Sopranos' technique of having one actor play a set of twins. In this case though, this subplot also doesn't seem to make much sense. Perhaps the jailhouse discussions between Dickie and Sally were meant to serve the same purpose as Tony's conversations with Dr. Melfi: a Greek Chorus into the protagonist's thought process, but except for one key bit of advice Sally gives at the end, it also seems like a lot of build up for no significant payoff.
There are vignettes meant to indicate Tony's ultimate evolution into a crime boss but nothing really convincing. Perhaps the producers didn't want to be too on-the-nose with young Tony, but an onscreen depiction of something like the robbery of Feech LaManna's card game probably would have made more sense to audiences than the few petty crimes we do see.
Ultimately this would have been a great opener for a new TV series- one that I would definitely want to watch- but as a movie it felt rushed and disjointed, without sufficient time to explore some potentially intriguing characters and themes. It was cinematic in its style and tone but ultimately too thin in its substance to stand alone as an attempt to contextualize the groundbreaking Sopranos series.
Tell Your Friends