Before I start, this contains minor spoilers (at least, as much as it's possible to spoil the "plot" of a musical documentary!)
Also, I should point out that I'd avoided all mention of the movie, and almost all of the clips, so didn't know what to expect. I had low expectations, but it was slightly better than I thought. The cinema was under a third full (mind you, they had it on every half-hour in most of the screens). I'll break this review down into sections as per the track order:
Wanna Be Startin' Somethin': The first thing I noticed was that the sound quality was actually pretty good. Even though the Staples is known for having crap sound, and even though my cinema didn't have SDDS (meaning that we had to settle for the inferior Dolby version). I thought the drums were nice, and the instrument separation was good. It also struck me that, although I don't see much dancing in general, there were several moves here that I'd never seen by MJ or anybody else.
Jam: Seemed to be sung live was well. I'm not sure what sources they cobbled the sound together from, but they had a fairly complete vocal track, apart from the lines that simply weren't sung.
They Don't Care About Us: Definitely mimed, and a similar medley to what had been used in previous tours. The special effects during this segment were nothing short of jaw-dropping - they have to be seen to be believed.
Human Nature: Nice song (in fact the one all the girls were singing as they left the cinema). By this point the changes of aspect ratio and overall size were starting to annoy me.
Smooth Criminal: There was a nice bit of insight into the video sequences. Overall quite good, although I'm not sure how it all would have fitted together as a live show.
Way You Make Me Feel: slightly long and drawn out, but otherwise good. Reminded me a bit of the Madison Square Garden 30th anniversary show.
Shake Your Body (Down To The Ground)/I Want You Back/I'll Be There: This whole J5 sequence was OK, but it always sounds tired. He's been doing the same medley with the same ad-libs for over 20 years now.
I Just Can't Stop Loving You: Fairly good. By this point, I had stopped trying to remember which songs were sung live and which were mimed. It looked like there was more chemistry with this singer than with Sheryl Crow or any other previous co-singer.
Thriller: I really enjoyed this bit, especially with all the 3D stuff. Too bad Threatened wasn't played for longer.
Beat It: This was OK, but was an example of the flow being interrupted just to fit in some crane footage they wanted to use. However, it was interesting to see the girl dancers.
Black Or White: Fairly good. Slightly different from the album version, and a good insight into how the performance would have worked with two lead guitarists.
Earth Song: Extremely powerful. I liked the symphonic introduction, and the jungle footage in the background had a good effect.
Billie Jean: unless I blinked and missed it, there was no moonwalk... It also seemed a bit half-hearted, but let's remember that this is all rehearsal footage.
Man In The Mirror: Not much to say about this one. Some parts of the song were missed out, but otherwise good, if a little bit straightforward.
This Is It/Heal The World: I sat through the whole credits, and read as much as possible (couldn't believe how many logos there were!). Whatever you do, don't leave at this point, or you'll miss some good moments. Bsides, it's disrespectful to leave during the credits to any movie.
There were also sections on Bad and Who Is it and In The Closet. And there are some great bits on pole dancing and acrobatics- I enjoyed the funny part where she was teaching them how to grab their crotch!
To sum up, I liked it. I'm not sure I'll see it at the cinema again, especially as nobody wants to go with me, but it's worth seeing once. I'd probably get the DVD (or Blu-ray, if it's the same price) - what I'd like is a seamless branching option where you can cut the dialogue and listen to it as an album (that's what the soundtrack CD should have been).
Overall, they showed restraint and good taste, for the most part. It had quite a good feel-good factor, maybe even for non-fans (of which there weren't any in this cinema, except maybe one or two guys who were probably dragged by their girlfriends). Maybe the environmental stuff near the end was laid on a bit thick.
For those of you who think that a review just boils down to a number - If this were anybody else, I'd give it 50%. However, because it's Jackson, I have to give it 60%. However, this assumes that it's judged as a standalone movie. IF they had been in a position to release a full live concert performance Blu-ray of the finished show, then this would have made an EXCELLENT bit of bonus material. I guess that's how I see it. It's something that should have been supplementary to a tour.
Also, I should point out that I'd avoided all mention of the movie, and almost all of the clips, so didn't know what to expect. I had low expectations, but it was slightly better than I thought. The cinema was under a third full (mind you, they had it on every half-hour in most of the screens). I'll break this review down into sections as per the track order:
Wanna Be Startin' Somethin': The first thing I noticed was that the sound quality was actually pretty good. Even though the Staples is known for having crap sound, and even though my cinema didn't have SDDS (meaning that we had to settle for the inferior Dolby version). I thought the drums were nice, and the instrument separation was good. It also struck me that, although I don't see much dancing in general, there were several moves here that I'd never seen by MJ or anybody else.
Jam: Seemed to be sung live was well. I'm not sure what sources they cobbled the sound together from, but they had a fairly complete vocal track, apart from the lines that simply weren't sung.
They Don't Care About Us: Definitely mimed, and a similar medley to what had been used in previous tours. The special effects during this segment were nothing short of jaw-dropping - they have to be seen to be believed.
Human Nature: Nice song (in fact the one all the girls were singing as they left the cinema). By this point the changes of aspect ratio and overall size were starting to annoy me.
Smooth Criminal: There was a nice bit of insight into the video sequences. Overall quite good, although I'm not sure how it all would have fitted together as a live show.
Way You Make Me Feel: slightly long and drawn out, but otherwise good. Reminded me a bit of the Madison Square Garden 30th anniversary show.
Shake Your Body (Down To The Ground)/I Want You Back/I'll Be There: This whole J5 sequence was OK, but it always sounds tired. He's been doing the same medley with the same ad-libs for over 20 years now.
I Just Can't Stop Loving You: Fairly good. By this point, I had stopped trying to remember which songs were sung live and which were mimed. It looked like there was more chemistry with this singer than with Sheryl Crow or any other previous co-singer.
Thriller: I really enjoyed this bit, especially with all the 3D stuff. Too bad Threatened wasn't played for longer.
Beat It: This was OK, but was an example of the flow being interrupted just to fit in some crane footage they wanted to use. However, it was interesting to see the girl dancers.
Black Or White: Fairly good. Slightly different from the album version, and a good insight into how the performance would have worked with two lead guitarists.
Earth Song: Extremely powerful. I liked the symphonic introduction, and the jungle footage in the background had a good effect.
Billie Jean: unless I blinked and missed it, there was no moonwalk... It also seemed a bit half-hearted, but let's remember that this is all rehearsal footage.
Man In The Mirror: Not much to say about this one. Some parts of the song were missed out, but otherwise good, if a little bit straightforward.
This Is It/Heal The World: I sat through the whole credits, and read as much as possible (couldn't believe how many logos there were!). Whatever you do, don't leave at this point, or you'll miss some good moments. Bsides, it's disrespectful to leave during the credits to any movie.
There were also sections on Bad and Who Is it and In The Closet. And there are some great bits on pole dancing and acrobatics- I enjoyed the funny part where she was teaching them how to grab their crotch!
To sum up, I liked it. I'm not sure I'll see it at the cinema again, especially as nobody wants to go with me, but it's worth seeing once. I'd probably get the DVD (or Blu-ray, if it's the same price) - what I'd like is a seamless branching option where you can cut the dialogue and listen to it as an album (that's what the soundtrack CD should have been).
Overall, they showed restraint and good taste, for the most part. It had quite a good feel-good factor, maybe even for non-fans (of which there weren't any in this cinema, except maybe one or two guys who were probably dragged by their girlfriends). Maybe the environmental stuff near the end was laid on a bit thick.
For those of you who think that a review just boils down to a number - If this were anybody else, I'd give it 50%. However, because it's Jackson, I have to give it 60%. However, this assumes that it's judged as a standalone movie. IF they had been in a position to release a full live concert performance Blu-ray of the finished show, then this would have made an EXCELLENT bit of bonus material. I guess that's how I see it. It's something that should have been supplementary to a tour.
Tell Your Friends