Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
13 Reasons Why: Tape 5, Side A (2017)
Season 1, Episode 9
9/10
Clay's motivations - story within the story
10 April 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Sort of review and reply to Harhaluulo54 at the same time...

Indeed, someone hid drugs in Clay's backpack and yes, he is not blaming anyone (although one might argue, he does, but does not let anybody see it). At first I thought the same: He is acting out of character. But after thinking again I realize: That is exactly the kind of behavior you would expect from Clay.

Two reasons: First, he may be many things but stupid is not one of them. He knew he was framed and he is pretty sure by whom. (Or at least he could pin it down to 2-3 people.) But what good would it do? He is still unsure how to solve the whole Hannah-situation, but in his head (wild guessing) he is forming a kind of plan, as we see when he visits Justin. And blaming all the ones guilty of driving Hannah to her suicide would interfere with his plan.

Second and far more important: Maybe he does not care at all, because his focus is all about Hannah. He lost himself in his struggle or coping with Hannah's story. In a sort of unhealthy way that may even seem romantic, disregarding everything but Hannah. He is a complicated character, a complicated boy, who is over-challenged (right word?) and not able to cope with his situation in a healthy, sensible way. Instead he goes all-in, throwing every emotion he feels into his understanding of Hannah's tapes.

So on a second or even third level of the story, we have a young man, doing what he thinks is right, albeit not knowing that this may be just a wrong turn. But hey, he _is_ a young man and young people have the right to make bad decisions for the right reasons. (Indeed we all do some times, I guess.) And that's why this episode is getting my 9 of 10 stars.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Stargate SG-1: Bad Guys (2007)
Season 10, Episode 16
9/10
Well, well... quite a nice episode.
25 October 2010
It does not belong to any story line and reminded me of the first Stargate SG-1 seasons, when plots were a bit more innocent, without leaving the viewer with a heavy heart.

SG-1 has bad luck and ends up within an alien museum of a species, that has not had any contact to an outer world civilization before. One bad thing leads to another, and our heroes are unwillingly forced to take some hostages, after the museum is sealed off, trying to find a way home. Unfortunately people think SG-1 is not from another planet, but rebels from their own world. What leads to a lot of humor, filling the whole episode.

Still sticking in my mind: Daniel's communication with the police man, he tries to convince, he is a rebel^^. But there are a lot of funny scenes, and because this one is a stand-alone episode almost everything fits as it should.

The missing star goes to some alien people, confirming some clichés, which are not necessary at all, making themselves a bit contrived.

But, nevertheless I really enjoyed this episode. As 9 stars show.
26 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed