Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Astrakan (2022)
10/10
An assured new voice in realist cinema
13 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Working in a mode greatly influenced by the Dardennes brothers, Depesseville makes a dazzling debut as a filmmaker, amazingly rich in style and tone.

Newcomer Mirko Giannini is stunning throughout this troubling tale as a vexed enigmatic boy stranded in rural France while in the care of a greedily irresponsible couple augmenting their income from their duties as his foster parents. Little more than children themselves, they govern him with casual brutality and a self-serving dismissiveness.

He finds his only solace through a new relationship with a local girl his own age who exhibits a carnal yen for him that he accepts with much exuberance. But the initially rewarding relationship leads him to an ultimate betrayal by her with the sadistic local bully who is his nemesis.

Depesseville's outward pessimism alternates with a dazzlingly dreamy visual style that makes for something much deeper here than the typical miserabilist cinema of a Lynne Ramsay or Ken Loach. Hopefully there will be much more of this moody raging genius at work in this brave new director's future.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tommy Guns (2022)
1/10
Overburdened to the point of incoherence
10 April 2023
A meandering repetitious film, devoid of characterization, rhythm, or honest political insight.

All those echoes of Jacques Tourneur, Pedro Costa or Miguel Gomes only betray the essences of what these film masters achieved in their vibrant and haunting critiques of colonialism. Conceicao tries too hard to emulate their styles and tempos, but he simply lacks the know-how and intellectual foundation to pull it off.

And just as sadly, the director fails to approach the eloquence of the zombie genre "master classes" achieved by true pop iconoclasts like Romero or Jarmusch.

Conceicao may be somewhat well-grounded in the history of his homeland, but he doesn't seem to comprehend the positive value of the terms "offhanded" and "entertaining". But credit is still due to Anabela Moreira as "Apolonia" for a valiant effort in what is otherwise a desert of film performance..
4 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed