I am not a classic purist, as I can appreciate someone giving a new take on a classic story. There have been a few horror remakes in recent years that have done the original justice while at the same time updating it for the times. This is not one of those remakes.
There could be spoilers here if you don't want to know Zombie's story additions to the original:
There is very little merit in Zombie's version of "Halloween" that wasn't already put in place in 1978. While the film does add the grittiness and brutality of today's films, none of its new aspects bring anything of merit to the table. The first forty five minutes of the film are dedicated to a story of origin that doesn't work in any capacity whatsoever; even Carpenter himself deleted his background sequences for the original film with good reason...explanation takes away the mystique of Myers. Not only that, Zombie's background fails miserably with the extremely tired and cliché "bad childhood" story. There is no defining moment for the young Myers, nor is there any catastrophic event to set it him off...the least he could've done in the waste of almost an hour is make it interesting.
The cast is fun, though not fully impressive. It's great to see some old faces of the horror genre stuck everywhere throughout the film, but it is to the point of distraction. Some of the actors do a good job in their cardboard cut-out roles (Malcolm McDowell is quite good in the beginning sequences, but a little campy in the second half). Others don't do so well; Sheri Moon is particularly dreadful to watch, as always. Daeg Faerch (young Myers) does a good job in his role despite the material, and gives a good, creepy performance. It was interesting to see Danielle Harris from the earlier Halloween sequels in a new role.
I'm sure this will be a good film for Zombie as he makes his way through learning film-making, and this will certainly have a good audience. "House of 1000 Corpses" was a miserably horrible film, but his followup "Devil's Rejects" really surprised me. It's a shame he couldn't keep the upward momentum. He's getting the look down, the editing, action sequences and general skills, but he is severely lacking in the storytelling and dialogue department, and he needs to learn to let go of sequences that simply don't work...or hire a good editor next time.
4 out of 8 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends