- Mayor Jack Fife: I waited 31 years to sit across from you and look you in the eye. Please tell me where you buried my son.
- Sam Gillis: I wish I could give you peace... but I didn't touch him. I swear on my life.
- Sheriff Frank Briggs, Sr.: Just the lady I was hoping to see. The workers found Penny's ashes beneath that tree and word is you put them there. Small town.
- Bridget Jensen: Where I come from, that's called hearsay.
- Sheriff Frank Briggs, Sr.: Well, here in Washington State, we call that improper disposal of remains. And it's a misdemeanor.
- Hilde Lisko: I found no info on Richie's mom. Except for she divorced Mayor Fife.
- Matt Lisko: Well, let's see. After the funeral, she... well, she became a shut-in. And a few months after that, she left, and then the mayor remarried, like, a year later.
- Hilde Lisko: Sounds suspicious.
- Matt Lisko: What? Her leaving or him remarrying?
- Hilde Lisko: Both.
- Bridget Jensen: So, Ethan? Is he the same guy that ditched you in the woods that one time?
- Izzy Lisko: Yes, but we're good now. And I really, really, really don't wanna talk about it.
- Fernando: So, you wanna talk about Richie Fife?
- Hilde Lisko: How'd you know Sam didn't kidnap him?
- Fernando: Richie told me so.
- Matt Lisko: When?
- Fernando: I asked his spirit. Hey, you don't have to take my word for it. You can ask him yourself.
- Hilde Lisko: Dad, is he crazy?
- Lt. Frank Briggs, Jr.: Sam, I'm sorry for what I said in court that day. I believe you had nothing to do with Richie.
- Sam Gillis: Pity you weren't on the jury.