Dawn's first day at Brighton Conservatory takes a very unexpected turn. Keith is forced to choose between the success of his new play and his best friend. Clive is just, well, Clive.
Dawn is left in charge of Peter Pan while Ryan ditches teaching to vacation. She and Garrett start to fall for each other - according to Garrett. Ivy and Jay's relationship begins to crumble.
Keith grows manic trying to perfect his adaptation of Peter Pan with Vera, isolating Nora. Ryan exhibits suspicious behavior during off-hours at the theatre. Keith and Ryan face off.
On closing night of Peter Pan, Ryan and Jay try to makeover their personalities. Keith wants to finally reconcile with Nora, but Vera may stand in their way.