"Genius" Einstein: Chapter Eight (TV Episode 2017) Poster

(TV Series)

(2017)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A Wrenching Decision for the Einsteins to Leave Germany
lavatch19 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The focus of this episode is on the year 1932, when Albert and Elsa Einstein make the decision to leave Germany for America. But the film also traces the decade of the 1920s in America in an era that saw the rise of J. Edgar Hoover as head of the FBI.

The framing device for the episode in a sustained interview of the Einsteins by American Consul General Raymond Geist in Berlin. At the behest of Hoover, Geist grills Einstein on possible ties to the Communist Party. Some of the witty answers of Albert (and Elsa!) are the highlight of the program.

Historically, the episode covers the Zionist movement and the attempt on the part of Chaim Weizmann to recruit Einstein in the efforts to begin a Zionist state in Palestine. During the interview, the Palmer raids are mentioned, and there is brief flashback to the time Einstein visited America in 1921. In a moving scene, a child personally donates a nickel to the Zionist cause after his father was arrested and deported during the Hoover crackdown on immigrants. During a lecture in New York, Einstein charms the audience by informing them that "most of my professors thought I would grow up not to accomplish much of anything." He also goes off the script prepared by Weizmann by proclaiming that "assimilation" is not necessarily the best recourse for human independence and freedom of thought.

While sailing to Japan in 1922 via the Arabian Sea, Einstein learns that he is the recipient of the Nobel Prize in spite of the efforts of the anti-Semite Dr. Philip Lenard. For the award, Einstein was acknowledged for his breakthrough work on the photoelectric effect, which, ironically, was based on the findings Lenard!

In the scientific component of the episode, Einstein is depicted in conversation with Dr. Nils Bohr, who visits Berlin. To Bohr, Einstein asserts that "I will not turn off my brain simply because you've decided a matter is settled." Another one of Einstein's beautifully turned phrases is "I do not believe God plays dice with the universe." In a brief scene in Zurich in 1932, Einstein visits young Eduard, who has just made the attempt on his life. Einstein apologizes to the lad for his negligence and then plays the violin to soothe "Teddy.

The most dramatic scene in the episode is the moment when Hoover denies the Einsteins' applications for visas to America. But Elsa moves into action by approaching a reporter friend to place an article in the New York Times, describing how the Einsteins were harassed by the American authorities. With the outrage of Congress, Hoover backs down and grants the visas, if only Einstein will sign a declaration that he has never been a member of the Communist Party. He refuses. But the kind Geist grants the visas anyway, after which Einstein signs the waver so that Geist will not lose his job.

In a caption at the close of the program, it is revealed that Raymond Geist had issued life-saving visas for more than 50,000 Jews. At one point, Einstein told Geist that the "myth" of America does not fit the "reality." But Geist's selfless action challenges Einstein's assertion.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
****
edwagreen14 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
An absolute marvelous episode. With the noose tightening among the Jews of Germany, Einstein and Elsa attempt to leave but are faced with being prevented from doing so by J. Edgar Hoover, who has an official interrogate Einstein regarding his political affiliations and possible attempts to blackmail him for his womanizing tendencies.

Geist, who interrogates Einstein, is a by-the-book Embassy official who eventually begins to sympathize with Albert's plight.

We see Einstein holding fast to his beliefs and a country that protested when he was denied entry at first. We see Geist ready to sacrifice his position only for Albert to finally acquiesce and sign the required document.

We see Einstein's sympathies with Zionism as early as the 1920s.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Lots of dramatic fiction
langston-9273019 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This episode deals with the Einteins' attempt to get visas for the United States in late 1932. This incident is well documented in the correspondence of George S. Messersmith, housed at the University of Delaware. Knowing those descriptions of what was going on between the Albert Einstein and his wife, and the staff at the American Consulate General in Berlin, and how much was changed "for dramatic effect" makes me question the entire series.

They made J. Edgar Hoover the villain extraordinaire, but he is never mentioned in Messersmith's correspondence. The issue was that the Woman Patriot Corporation had questioned Einstein's legal right to a visa based upon the provisions in Section 3 of the Act of February 5, 1917, the Act of October 16, 1918, amended June 5, 1920. These were all laws designed to expel and prevent immigration by anarchists, communists and others. As far as I have been able to find, J. Edgar Hoover had absolutely nothing to do with the Einstein situation. It was a cheap shot to include him, and purely for dramatic effect.

And Raymond Geist was presented as the Consul General, which he most certainly was not. He didn't hold that position until the late 1930s. In 1932, the position was held by George S. Messersmith. Geist did conduct the interviews under Messersmith's aegis.

If you are doing something historical, at least get your facts straight. I resent these overly-dramatized "fake" histories. The real thing is far more interesting.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed