Mystery Box Challenge: This Mystery Box contains a cast-iron pan, a wooden spoon, and a paring knife, and the contestants must use only these tools to make their dish in 60 minutes, with Gordon cooking alongside them. The top three dishes belong to Tanorria, Brandi, and David, and Brandi's dish wins the challenge, granting her immunity. Challenge Winner/Immune: Brandi Mudd. Elimination Challenge: The remaining contestants must recreate a picnic basket of various foods. This challenge will be a tag team challenge, and Brandi will select the teams. She pairs Shaun with Nathan, David with Katie, and Dan with Tanorria. David and Katie had the best basket, making them team captains in the next challenge. Nathan and Shaun's basket is deemed the worst. Winners: David Williams and Katie Dixon. Bottom two: Nathan Barnhouse and Shaun O'Neale. Nathan is eliminated. Eliminated: Nathan Barnhouse.