Joey Graceffa invites all his friends to his new estate. He has some sleep paralysis from not being able to invite others. All the other people arrive. Eva Gutowski and Shane Dawson go and sneak off to look around. They see the maid dragging a body to a room, before being escorted back downstairs. The others ask where they were. They say they just needed to use the bathroom. The others are skeptical, but they continue with their dinner. They all have a small drink, before Shane finds out he's been poisoned. The group starts to find clues to find the antidote. The antidote is discovered to be dispersed between three bottles and they have a total of fifteen minutes to unlock all of the antidotes to save Shane. There are three puzzles and they are all spread out. Joey, Eva and GloZell Green find a key within a painting and unlock the first. The other two groups with the other two puzzles fail the time, ending with Shane's final death. Joey looks through Shane's pockets and finds a letter handwritten by Shane. They find out there is a dark magic throughout the house and the Society Against Evil put their symbol around the house for the clues. They find out one of them has to die in the end, but really, multiple people have to die for each challenge in order to have a couple people advance out of the house. They find out they have to gather artifacts. The episode ends with them trying to escape but the car they took blows up before they can get to it. So they had no escape out of the certain timeframe. They now consider trying to get the artifacts to escape the estate.
