"The Vietnam War" Things Fall Apart (January-June 1968) (TV Episode 2017) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
"My job was to get shot at..., I got shot at a lot." - Helicopter Crew Chief Ron Ferrizzi
classicsoncall4 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Watching this episode reminds one just how devastating 1968 was for America, a pivotal year for the country that saw the assassinations of Martin Luther King and Robert F. Kennedy, a growing anti-war protest movement, and riots at the Democratic National Convention. It's a wonder sometimes how we fumbled our way through it all.

I was staggered by a number I heard expressed in this episode. Throughout the duration of the Vietnam War, over thirty six million sorties were flown by U.S. forces over the country!! They were used not only to pour lethal fire on the enemy, but also to drop propaganda leaflets, move military supplies, and remove wounded from the battlefield. It's impossible really to comprehend that that kind of activity was occurring in the skies over Vietnam.

The beginning of 1968 found Communist Party First Secretary Le Duan of North Vietnam laying the groundwork for a major offensive in the South. Eighty four thousand North Vietnamese regulars and Viet Cong were primed to attack thirty six provincial capitals and dozens of American and ARVN military bases. Six of the largest South Vietnamese cities were also targeted, including Saigon, Danang, and Hue. The 'Tet Offensive' was designed to break the back of South Vietnamese morale and bolster Communist resolve in defeating their opponents.

Militarily, the Tet Offensive wound up a huge defeat for the North Vietnamese, as fifty eight thousand of those eighty four thousand would wind up killed, wounded or captured. The reality of Tet however, contradicted everything the American public had been told about the progress of the war in the preceding months. Instead of the enemy having been weakened in the past, it proved how resilient the Communists were in replacing their dead with new conscripts to carry on the war with vicious ferocity. In effect, the Tet Offensive broke the will of the U.S. to continue the war.

Out of this episode comes one of the enduring images of the war that TV viewers in America were shocked to witness. When a Viet Cong civilian was captured and marched through the streets of Saigon, South Vietnamese police chief Nguyen Ngoc Loan took his revenge and shot the man in the head with cameras rolling. Just like the sight of a Buddhist monk setting himself on fire, this image created a lasting impression in the minds of Americans that things were going so badly that the war had to come to an end. Still, it would take many more years.

Following Tet, President Lyndon Johnson replaced William Westmoreland as head of U.S. forces in Vietnam with General Creighton Abrams. Seeing the challenge to his administration from members of his own Democratic Party, Johnson made a stunning announcement to the American people - he would not run for re-election as President. I recall it as a bold announcement at the time, but you couldn't second guess his decision. Johnson knew that his chances of reelection were slim, and as we'll see in the following episode, the raucous Democratic National Convention held later in the year was upstaged by clashes between protesters and police in Chicago.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Why use God save the queen in your documentary?
A very short review from my side, more some sort of comment. I think this was yet another great episode of the documentary which shows a lot of the real emotions, pride and humiliation, from both sides. Absolutely great editing with every section ending with an image or statement that gives you something to think about. And a really good chronological buildup of events to show the viewer what was going on and what was the decision making at that time. There's only one thing I really don't understand, and I would like to ask Ken Burns personally. Why did you use an acoustic piano version of "God save the queen" ( the English national anthem) in this episode (and an earlier episode also but I can't recall which one.). The music is especially striking since it is in the scene in which Captain (army surgeon) Hal Kushner tell about the "celebtration" of the fourth of july in a POW camp. It's kind of odd to choose that music, isn't it?

I'm not an native English speaker (I'm dutch) so please excuse me for my language errors.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Tet and Beyond
Hitchcoc29 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
With all the death going on in Southeast Asia, the usual hawks who had no skin in the game kept up their war rattle. This episode brings the war to its peak. The Tet offensive was a dramatic effort by the North to put an end to this war. With their cannon-fodder mentality, it was determined and accepted that they would attack major cities all over, Saigon being the centerpiece. Once again, Westmoreland made tactical errors and these brave kids paid the price. Huge number of the North Vietnamese were killed. The American troops and the ARVIN suffered huge casualties as well, but not nearly so many. So in Westmoreland's mind, this was a victory. However, as the deaths reached 28,000 young soldiers, back home the anti-war movement was heating up. These were people's children, not statistics. Johnson kept trying to spin things, to make it look good, but with that many flag draped caskets, there was no more hiding. What was interesting to me was how many Viet Kong were already living and interacting with the populace of South Vietnam before this campaign began. Also, we are made aware that the Civil Rights movement was in full gear and Lyndon Johnson had to deal with that. I remember like yesterday the deaths of Martin Luther King, Bobby Kennedy, and the announcement that Johnson would not seek another term. Our world was in shambles and there was more horror to come.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Things Fall Apart (January-July 1968)
Prismark1023 October 2017
In 1968 America is heading for disturbance at home. There is civil rights disobedience, the tensions of the war is causing a ripple effect domestically. There seems to be lurch towards violence internationally with student protests around the world. The period of this episode sees the assassination of Martin Luther King and Robert Kennedy.

As for Vietnam, the Vietcong launch a tactical offensive during the lunar new year celebrations. An attack on Saigon and other regional cities. It ultimately failed but as newscaster Walter Cronkite observed there would be no victory or defeat for America, just a brutal stalemate.

LBJ weary of spinning the news media decided not to seek re- election. The American soldiers were frustrated and fatigued, we see one of them being interviewed and how resentful he was when a female journalist asked him how he felt.

The episode does not shy away from asking the former Vietcong about their own humiliation, the atrocities committed on innocent villagers as mass graves were uncovered.
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed