- Natasha: [in Sarah's gallery] We'll take anything you've painted. Money's no object.
- Elise: Really? Since when?
- Natasha: Elise, I make six figures drinking blood on the Net.
- Elise: Yeah, I know you do. I wish you didn't.
- Natasha: Why? It's not cheating.
- Elise: Maybe not to you it isn't.
- Sarah Bennett: You know what? I'm just gonna leave you alone.
- Sarah Bennett: [Cam is carving a jack-o-lantern] Oh, come on. It's smiling. It's wrong.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: No, it's not. It...
- Sarah Bennett: Look at it.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: Yeah, okay.
- Sarah Bennett: Mm-hmm.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: Yeah, it's a smile.
- Sarah Bennett: Mm-hmm.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: A ridiculous smile.
- Sarah Bennett: [laughing] Well, it's not very scary.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: I bet you never thought this was possible. Having fun? In Waterbury?
- Sarah Bennett: Yeah, I guess I didn't.
- Dylan Bennett: [Sarah reads a newspaper article he wrote] Tennyson wrote, "'Tis better to have loved and lost than to never have loved at all." But guess what? Lord Tennyson had no idea what he was talking about. Waterbury has faced many losses this year, but for me, my own personal loss has been my wife. I didn't lose her to the Executioner, however. I lost her to myself. The greatest sin, the cardinal sin...
- P.C. Sharma: [cut to the police station] "... is pride. It's been the downfall of many a man and woman, and now it's my own personal undoing." Wow. God. If Sarah doesn't take him back, I will.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: [taking the paper away] Don't you have any actual work to do?
- Sgt. Cam Henry: Now, why don't you tell me why we found a box full of evidence in your house?
- Dylan Bennett: What the hell are you talking about?
- Sgt. Cam Henry: [showing him a picture] Do you deny that this is your box? Hmm? Or is it Sarah's?
- Dylan Bennett: Okay, I need to talk to my lawyer.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: No. You need to tell me why you kept a box full of god damn souvenirs from the murder scenes.
- [showing him another picture]
- Sgt. Cam Henry: Brenda Merritt's fingernails. Tell me, Dylan, did you... did you pull those out with pliers?
- Dylan Bennett: No, Cam, listen to me. I didn't do anything to anybody, Cam. You have the wrong guy.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: What about my wife's hair, huh?
- Dylan Bennett: Okay, I need to see my lawyer. Now!
- Sgt. Cam Henry: Yeah. Maybe I'll do that. Tomorrow. You better get used to that chair, 'cause you're gonna be there all night.
- Young Cam: Where am I?
- Suzy Henry: You're sleepwalking. And you want to know why? Because you were playing your god damn video games right before bed again and I told you not to. If you would just fricking listen to me, we wouldn't have to go through this every fricking night. Oh, come on. You pissed yourself? You are too old for this. What is wrong with you?
- Young Cam: I'm sorry, mom. I didn't mean to.
- Suzy Henry: Well, you did, Cam. You did. And now I'm gonna have to change all your sheets and wash them, and your PJs, too. And I'm gonna be lucky if I get two hours of god damn sleep because you are such a little baby! I ought to make you wear diapers. Would you like that? Would you like that? Wearing diapers to bed? That's what I ought to do. I'm going to make you wear diapers to bed and to school, in front of all your friends to teach you a lesson because you are such a little baby!
- Sarah Bennett: We're gonna be okay, right?
- Dylan Bennett: Better than okay. Now find me some music. Something suitable for...
- Sarah Bennett: Driving off into the sunset? I'll see what I can do.
- Dylan Bennett: [turning on the radio, they hear an evangelist preaching] We need a new car. Preferably with Bluetooth.
- Sarah Bennett: [changing stations] Yeah, you know what? New country it is.
- Robin Turner: I haven't seen this much black nail polish since I worked the makeup counter in the '90s.
- Sarah Bennett: I know. Can you believe this?
- Robin Turner: And what is this, exactly?
- Sarah Bennett: Happy Halloween?
- Sgt. Cam Henry: I know we both lost people we love this summer. But Waterbury, it had a problem. Lots of problems. Lots of secrets. And, um...
- Sarah Bennett: What?
- Sgt. Cam Henry: The Executioner... he kind of cleaned up this town, in his own sick way.
- Sarah Bennett: Yeah, but murdering eight people?
- Sgt. Cam Henry: Yeah, I'm not condoning his actions. I'm just saying that... I don't... I don't know what I'm saying. Forget it. Sorry.
- Sarah Bennett: Yeah... what you're saying... I think you're right. There's a lot of darkness in this town, and it's not just the Executioner.
- Dylan Bennett: Sarah, you are the single most important thing to me in the world.
- Sarah Bennett: You only came to that conclusion after everything had gone to hell.
- Dylan Bennett: That's not true.
- Sarah Bennett: It's too little too late.
- [opening the gallery door]
- Sarah Bennett: Now, please. I'd like you to leave.
- Sarah Bennett: What are you doing here?
- Dylan Bennett: What am I... I've been calling for days. You're not answering your phone.
- Sarah Bennett: 'Cause I don't wanna talk to you.
- Dylan Bennett: It's your birthday, babe.
- Sarah Bennett: Yeah. Best present you can give me is just to leave me alone.
- Sarah Bennett: Okay, no. You can't look at me like that. You're gonna make me cry, and I hate crying.
- Robin Turner: [holding his arms out, she moves to hug him] Careful.
- Sarah Bennett: Okay, sorry.
- Robin Turner: You stay out of trouble, okay? Don't move into any cursed homes, and don't befriend anyone with the last name Henry, Dahmer, or Bundy.
- Sarah Bennett: Deal. I'm gonna miss you, Robin.
- Robin Turner: No, you're not. I'm gonna be crashing on your couch every other weekend.
- Sarah Bennett: Right.
- Robin Turner: You take care of her.
- Dylan Bennett: Don't worry about that. You just worry about selling this house.
- Robin Turner: [giving Sarah a party invitation] I wasn't going to throw one this year, but...
- Sarah Bennett: You're doing it for Justin.
- Robin Turner: Yeah. Yeah. Halloween was like Christmas and Eid and a drag show all rolled up into one for him. So it sort of felt wrong not celebrating it, you know? Anyhoo, um... seeing as how I forgot my garlic and holy water, I should make like Dracula and fly, but I will see you at the Eh Frame tomorrow night.
- Sarah Bennett: No.
- Robin Turner: Yes, Sarah.
- Sarah Bennett: No, you know, I just wanna stay in bed and eat my weight in candy.
- Robin Turner: Babe, it's your birthday.
- Sarah Bennett: Exactly.
- Robin Turner: I'm not giving up on you. You will be doing the Monster Mash with me tomorrow night.
- Sarah Bennett: Yeah, you know what? Just dream big.
- Sarah Bennett: [after Sarah finds a box of trophies from the Executioner's victims] You're gonna be okay.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: It's like he wanted me to find them. To punish me. Or maybe he wanted to be caught. I don't understand.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: Sarah. There's no telling what goes on in the mind of a criminal.
- Sarah Bennett: I just want to close my eyes and never open them.
- Sgt. Cam Henry: You go ahead. I'm here. I'm here and I'm not going anywhere.
- Sarah Bennett: How are you feeling?
- Robin Turner: Uh, I look like Frankenstein with my shirt off, but... I'll live.
- Dylan Bennett: He framed me.
- Sarah Bennett: He's trying to. We've got hard evidence.
- Dylan Bennett: No. Sarah, we have a painting. We-we have a theory. We don't have near enough proof to give...
- Sarah Bennett: Well, then I'll find the proof.
- Dylan Bennett: No, Sarah. Find a lawyer. They'll find someone who outranks Cam, and we'll handle it then.
- Sarah Bennett: By the time that happens, you'll be found hanging in your cell.