When the Nostalgia Critic admits he's not too crazy about Mad Max: Fury Road, he's captured by a crazed pre-post-Apocalyptic army lead by Impractical Joe. The Critic escapes with the help of Curiosa, a bad-ass heroine who among many really liked the new Mad Max, and is as surprised as everyone else when the Critic admits to liking Thunderdome the best. So throughout their journey, being endlessly hounded by weird-ass guitar guys, exploding henchmen, sexist nerds and Tom Hardy fangirls, the Critic tries his negative feelings on the new film, until he makes a startling correlation between Fury Road and a famous duo known for chasing each other across a desert.