Allison continues to try to cause trouble for Reena and wants Justin to accept that Ashley isn't coming back. Hunt tells Judith that he's meeting with his Monsignor, but Vicky thinks it's a good idea if they no longer see one another. Gregory apologizes to Paige for calling her a drunk. TJ admits to Paige the truth about Gregory's paternity and makes her understand that although he loves her, he wants to be a father to his son. Mark and Ruby discuss their relationship. As the storm clouds break in the sky, Justin, Gregory, and TJ all see the first star and wish upon it for Ashley's safe return. Reena is moved by the sweet moment the three men share. The Monsignor advises Hunt he needs to go away on retreat and reflect upon his feelings for Vicky. After Reena tells him that she knows about his college affair with Ashley and her pregnancy, TJ accuses Reena of stealing Gregory's birth certificate from his safe. Allison pushes Justin to give up hope of finding Ashley alive.
—Skip Eastport