San Bernardino, CA, 1964: A late night grocery-run turns to tragedy when husband and wife Cork (39) and Lucille Millers (35) car swerves into an embankment and bursts into flames. Lucille barely makes it out of the car alive, and Cork, fast asleep from sleeping pills, burns to death in the car. At first all the evidence adds up to a terrible accident and then it doesnt. Half the clues support Lucilles version of events, but the other half seem to suggest something far more sinister: that she staged the whole thing. Investigators wonder, could Lucille have wanted Cork out of the picture? Add life insurance payouts and an affair, and investigators see plenty of motive. But are they seeing guilt where there is none?