Melody Makers: Should've Been There (2016) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
WEEKLY HISTORY OF ROCK N' ROLL
kirbylee70-599-52617927 January 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Times have changed and not always for the better. The corporate world has swallowed up the business of journalism and rock n' roll to the point both have become products rather than reflections of the world we live in. Rock/pop songs are composed using formulas and computer algorithms rather than the essence of the composer behind them. Magazines have fallen by the wayside thanks to the internet taking over and providing information at break neck speed. But that wasn't always the way it was.

In the sixties the English magazine Melody Maker was the premiere magazine for all thing rock. Started decades before as a trade magazine with a focus on providing musicians a place to look through for gigs, the magazine changed course in the sixties the same way music changed. Suddenly classical music wasn't the big seller and the Beatles were. Melody Maker followed suit.

The documentary here focuses mainly on photographer Barrie Wentzell whose images graced the cover of the magazine for years. At the same time it also interviews and discusses the history of the magazine with numerous writers and editors who worked there as well. What it provides is a history of rock n' roll that few with the exception of insider are permitted to see. These people would travel with the bands, see their successes, their excesses and their decline as the business changed.

The film is filled with the images of front covers and photographs taken by Wentzell, many historic images that are still used to this day when talking about people like Elton John, the Who and Jimi Hendrix. They captured those people and more during their performances, in their homes and backstage as well. Those glimpses are amazing to see.

But times changed, music changed, the public changed and so did the bands. With the popularity of the magazine and music as well London's gossip rags found them the perfect targets to focus on. As they did damage to the bands they also damaged the trust found between the bands and the press that had been there for them before. One example of that trust is when a journalists is privy to the death of Brian Jones of the Rolling Stones and at the request of Keith Richards holds on to the story rather than rush to the printer. There was that bond that the gossip mags destroyed.

The movie notes the rise and fall of the magazine which folded in 2000, absorbed by New Musical Express. That magazine ceased printed publication in 2018. But in its heyday Melody Maker was THE magazine to read, perhaps even more so than Rolling Stone magazine. This film chronicles that rise and fall through the words and images of those who were there. It's a fitting tribute to not just the magazine but the music of the time as well.

If you love rock n' roll then you'll want to add this film to your collection. Not only will you be watching history you'll also be allowed to glimpse some of the many thousands of pictures that filled their pages. And while doing so you'll recall those great moments in music and my guess is head to the shelf to find one or two of those performers that are kept there and give them a listen to once again.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"It's been the backbone of the British music industry forever." - Features Writer and Reviewer, Christopher Welch
classicsoncall27 February 2020
Well, maybe not forever, as the magazine ceased publication in 2000, a victim of changing times in popular music culture. But from it's first issue in 1926, Melody Maker magazine became a staple read for dance band musicians until it found a much wider audience with the success of rock music in the Sixties. Told primarily via the recollections of MM staffers and a handful of musicians, this documentary offers a huge array of photos taken by staff photographer Barrie Wentzel, with commentary by Wentzel, features writer Christopher Welch, and news editor Christopher Charlesworth. From the music industry side, Ian Anderson of Jethro Tull and Eric Burdon of The Animals offer their perspective on the era that brought the magazine to prominence, and how it became the bible for performers of the era. In many cases, the magazine brought together individuals who might not have been aware of each other via the back page advertisements. If you were looking for a job, or wanting to book a gig, Melody Maker was the place to advertise your services, and it's fair to say a considerable number of bands might not have existed without the help of those ads. The DVD cover for the picture here on the IMDb title page has the sub-title 'Should've Been There', however if you're looking for it today, the copy I picked up at my local library looked the same, but had as it's sub - 'The Bible of Rock n' Roll'. You couldn't really go wrong in either case, as the film does a credible job of highlighting the history of one of music fandom's venerable trade papers.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Wow!
leavymusic-221 July 2020
Amazing collection of the papers history with its peek in the 60's and 70's. I remember buying it in the 80's, most important paper for a musician like myself, the adds were the place to go to if you were a looking to join a band. The gigs list from Hammersmith odeon to famous Marquee club in wardour st, still popular in 80's that had made many bands famous in the 60's and 70's. The story' of this music newspaper in fast passed clips and interviews and story's of when music was king in England.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great interviews and candid recollections from legends now and then
dannymccaffrey17 October 2021
This would easier the best collection of candid recollections from our favourite artists. The ability of MM editors is testament to their authority in recognising lasting talent. More more more.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed