Children of Giant (2015) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Fine 2015 PBS Production
adamshl18 April 2015
Sixty years after the initial release of George Stevens' Giant, this documentary reveals the inner workings of the creation of the original novel, screenplay and filmization. A small Texas town (Marfa) was used for the production, with a full array of Hollywood cast and crew to engage in this on-location work for 45 days in 1955.

I was surprised to learn of the hostility Edna Ferber faced from local Texans over her revealing novel; likewise, the sensitive line Stevens drew in fashioning his film. With Studio Head Jack Warner himself trying to pressure the director to remove some key elements in the film, it is to Stevens credit that he held on to his vision and respectfully refused.

Also to Stevens' credit is his studio contract: he would work for free for the three years of film preparation, then be given a financial percentage of the film and full control. It was an offer Warner Bros. couldn't refuse and an ingenious stroke of good fortune for Stevens.

One surprising revelation of the documentary is that the school administration and teachers attempted to make Latino school children speak only English, going so far as to have a mock funeral wherein all Spanish texts were literally buried in the ground behind the schoolhouse. Likewise the segregated cemetery for Latinos which existed in 1955 still exists in 2015--with a barbed wire fence separating the other side reserved for Anglos.

No wonder the oil-rich Texan barons were roiled with both Ferber and Stevens for exposing their clandestine social culture for the world to see. Yet Stevens was careful not to incur a defamation law suit of characters still living when the film was released by maintaining it to be a work of fiction. Yet worldwide audiences recognized the social truths being exposed in this daring production.

The 86-minute documentary is both interesting and informative throughout, and is rich in candid film shots by cast and crew along with actual excerpts from the finished film. This is a worthwhile documentary of a still highly relevant social drama.
14 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wonderful Documentary
gacks_200019 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I was born in El Paso Texas 1958 a year before Giant was released. I did not see Giant till about aged 13. Having grown up a Hispanic female in Texas I was always aware of the prejudice that existed around me but I didn't really sink in till I saw Giant. Giant had a very positive effect on me and my future success in life. The Children of Giant is one of the best documentaries I've seen in years. Great interviews, great screen footage. A good history lesson that is well rounded giving information about the Edna Ferber, the Hollywood crew, the citizens of Marfa Texas and impact the Giant had on not only the United States but the movie going world at the time. I really enjoyed it and recommend both Giant and The Children of Giant.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent documentary
Bernie444423 October 2023
We see many aspects and different views of the making of the George Stevens' summer of 1955 Hollywood film, "Giant" Based on Edna Ferber's 447-page novel.

Lots of pictures, behind the scenes, presenters, interviews, etc.

Running almost throughout the complete documentary is how the city of Marfa treated/treats Mexican Americans; Mexican Americans mostly tell this. Could be because of funding in part by Latino Public Broadcasting (LPB).

Running almost throughout the complete documentary pushed the subject of feminism. They quote a lot of the movie and point out that this is what feminism is.

This shows a good list of stars and the last movie of James Dean due to an auto accident. Elsa Cardenas gets to come back after 50 years to see where she played Juana.

The Texas landscape is also a player in the movie. Tony Cany from Marfa got paid 25 cents apiece to collect tumbleweed for the dust storm scenes. "Tumbling along with the tumbling tumbleweed."

A plus in this documentary is that you can use the pause button and the book titles behind the presenters are readable and not fuzzy. What did the presenters read? Now we know. One exception is J. E. Smyth, author of "Edna Ferber's Hollywood" which is still too fuzzy to read.

The program moves so fast and has so many things to say that you will have to watch it again after digesting the first viewing.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed