Plot

When Regina goes missing, Emma immediately suspects Tamara. Meanwhile, flashbacks show what happened to Baelfire after leaving the Enchanted Forest.

When Regina goes missing, Emma immediately suspects Tamara. After Bae leaves the magical world, he lands in London, England and stumbles upon the Darling house where he meets Wendy and her brothers. Meanwhile, Gold shows Lacey his magical powers.—Nadia Nassar

Moments after Baelfire falls through the portal, he lands in some woodland area. He walks onto a road and is almost run over by a horse drawn carriage. Camera pans and we see Big Ben. Baelfire has landed in Victorian England. Now we flash forward to 6 months later and Bae picks up a half eaten pear from the trash. He looks like kid straight out of a Charles Dickens book. He notices the window of the big house in front of him is open and sneaks in. He sees three loaves bread on the table and starts to tear into the bread like he has not eaten in days. In between bites, he stuffs pieces into his coat pocket. Suddenly a huge dog starts to bark at home and the young girl leaving at the house discovers him. He apologizes and wants to leave as quickly as possible. The girl notices that he is poor and hungry. She offers in the other two loaves to him telling him that she did not want him to starve. She asks him his name and he replies, "Bae". She seems bewildered by the strange name but replies that she is Wendy Darling.

Neal wakes up in StoryBrooke to see that Tamara is dressing to go out on a run. She says that she is training for some marathon which is suppose to happen in a few weeks. He wants her to come back to bed but she laughs it off and leaves.

Mr. Gold is holding his foot over Mr. Whales face telling him to lick his boots because he stared at Lacey the wrong way. Lacey seems to like his evil Mr. Gold. Neal comes up from behind and grabs Mr. Gold. Mr. Whales walks away from the Rabbit Hole. Neal tells Mr. Gold that he had thought he had changed. It took him so long to find him and after he has, he does not even care to meet Tamara. Mr. Gold tells him that the relationship will not last since he is still holding the torch for Emma. Neal tells him that he is wrong. Mr. Gold counters that he is still in StoryBrooke from some reason. Neal says that the only reason he is still there is because of Henry. Not him.

Emma and David burst into Regina's office with guns drawn. They kind of figure that she was the one who burned down the bean stalks. After making sure that no one is there, they yell out that the coast is clear. Mary Margaret and Henry enter. Henry asks them if they are going to hurt Regina when they find her. Emma says that they only want the beans back. They see the bean stack growing but all of the beans have been harvested. Emma notices that someone used an override code to disable the alarm at 6:30 that morning. Now they think something has happened to Regina since Regina would not need an override code to disable her own alarm. Henry says many times that maybe something bad happened to her and that they have to find her. After some discussion, they conclude that only Mr. Gold could over power Regina. Emma disagrees since so much evidence is left behind. Mr. Gold would burned the bean stalk growing in Regina's office. Emma thinks that Tamara had something to do with it. Mary Margaret warns Emma about going down that road again. They split up with Emma going to visit Tamara/Neal's apartment while David/Mary Margaret go and visit Mr. Gold.

Greg and Tamara meet at the StoryBrooke Cannery where they have Regina strapped down. We see that Tamara has stolen two magic beans from Regina's office. We also see the jewel which is the fail safe. They talk about how the 'Home Office' is going to have a field day with all of the data they are sending them. Hook is with Regina in another room and she tells him that what they are offering is not worth it. Hooks states that they are going to help kill Rumplestiltskin, so it is worth it. Greg comes into the room and starts to attach electrodes to Regina's head, legs and arms. He starts to connect wires from some kind of machine to the electrodes. Hook leaves the room saying that he is only interested in killing Rumplestiltskin, not torturing the Queen. Greg asks her again about the whereabouts of his dad. When Regina does not answer, he turns on the machine.

Back at the Darling home, Wendy is sneaking left over food to Bae. He is hiding in some compartment in the wall. He asks her if this is really ok and if her parents will find out. Wendy says that her parents are grown ups and they can only see things if it is right in front of them. Both of her parents suddenly walk into the room and her dad demands to know how long Bae has been hiding in their house. Wendy tells them that she has been hiding him for a few weeks now and that she was the one who let him into their house. Her dad asks him where his parents are. He responds that his mom died and then hesitates before telling them that his dad has also died. He prepares to leave when the mother suddenly says that he can stay since he is an orphan. The dad is very surprised...

Emma barges into Neal and Tamara's room. Tamara is out for her run so she is not present. Emma tells Neal that Regina has disappeared and she suspects that Tamara is behind it. Neal tells her that Tamara is out jogging in the woods. She searches the closet and notices some beach sand on the floor. Emma thinks that Tamara is lying and if she can lie about something so small, why can't she lie about something other things. Neal does not believe her and says that maybe she also runs at the beach..

The Darling children are gathered around the window excited about something. Wendy wakes up Bae and say that they are waiting for 'The Shadow' to appear. He asks her what is this 'Shadow' all about. Wendy tells him that around the time Bae came to live in their house, a Shadow appeared at the window. It does not have a body and it can do magic. She tells him that it can travel between worlds. Upon hearing about magic, Bae tells them that they have to stay away from the Shadow. Magic always comes with a price. John tells him that it is because he is a not a believer in magic. Bae tells them that he does believe in magic because he has seen it. He came from a world full of magic. Wendy looks fascinated saying that it must be wonderful to live in such world. Bae disagrees and tells that magic destroyed his family. He makes them promise that they will never speak with the Shadow ever again.

Mary Margaret and David go to Mr. Gold's shop where he is there with Lacey. David reminds him that he owes him a favor so he has to help them find Regina. He reluctantly agrees and asks Lacey to wait in the next room. He takes out a little bottle containing Regina's tear. He asks Mary Margaret for a tear so he can mix them together. She thinks of something sad and he collects the tear. The mixtures glows a little bit and he tells her that when she drops the mixture into her own eyes, she will be able to find Regina. After they leave, Lacey reenters the room saying that she heard everything. She asks him if he can really do magic. He answers yes and tells her to pour herself another drink.

Back at their apartment, David tells Mary Margaret that she does not have to do this. They can find another way. Mary Margaret disagrees and tells him that she has to do this in hopes of adding some light back into her heart which has darkened after killing Cora. David drops the tears into her eyes and she screams since Regina is currently being shocked by the electroshock machine.

Bae awakens later on in the night to see the Shadow holding Wendy's hand. She says that the Shadow is going to take her to Neverland. It is place where there are no grown ups and children will never grow old. It is a land full of magic but different then the one Bae comes from. Bae tries to keep Wendy in the room but the Shadow soon takes and flies away.

Emma and Neal are walking along the beach looking for Tamara. Neal still does not believe her and says that her emotions are cloudy her judgement. Emma becomes defensive and says that this is not about trying to break up him and Tamara. Just as she says this, Tamara comes jogging up behind them. She tells him that she jogs from the woods to the beach. Emma tells Tamara that Regina has gone missing. She seems genuinely concerned and tells her that she is willing to do anything to help. She continues on her jog. Before Emma leaves the beach, Neal tells her that he wanted to go to jail for her. He regrets letting August talk him into leaving her. He was afraid that she would never forgive for that because he has not forgiven himself. He apologizes to Emma for everything that he has ever done to her.

Tamara goes back to the cannery and tells Greg that Neal and Emma don't suspect anything. Gregs says that Regina is not cooperating and turns on the machine again to shock Regina. She tells that they are fools for trying to steal magic. Tamara informs her that they are not trying to steal magic, they are trying to destroy magic. It is considered to be 'unholy' in this world. Regina asks them if they really think that the two of them can achieve this. Greg tells her that they are not alone. There is some huge organization whose sole purpose is to the destroy magic. When he left StoryBrooke as child saying this and that about Magic, most people thought he was crazy, but others did not. They found him. He tells her that they have done it before. StoryBrooke is not the first time Magic has crossed over. He turns on the machine again.

Mary Margaret is still experiencing the torturing through Regina. When it finally stops for a little while, David asks her if she could see anything. Any little detail can help them find her. She says that all she can feel was the pain and could not concentrate on anything else. She remembers feeling strapped down by both her arms and legs. She felt completely helpless. She could also smell sardines. David calls Emma and tells her that Regina is trapped somewhere that smells like sardines. Emma and Neal just happen to be walking around the docks and sees the StoryBrooke Cannery. Emma immediately jumps to the conclusion that Tamara is holding Regina there.

Wendy walks about Bae up the morning after she was taken by the Shadow. She asks him how long she has been gone. He tells her that she was only gone for the night. She concludes that time must work different in Neverland. It is an island full of mermaids, fairies and does not have any grown ups to tell the children what to do. But at night, the children start to miss their parents and they cry. The Shadow will not let them leave. The reason it is called Neverland is that once you step foot there, you are never allowed to leave. Bae asks who Wendy managed to escape. Turns out that the Shadow did not want her. He wants a boy and he is coming back tonight to take one of Wendy's brothers instead. Bae promises them that he will protect them. He is not going to let the Shadow take any of them.

Mr. Gold finishes telling Lacey about all that he can do. She seems really impressed and likes what she sees. She asks him if he can do anything. He replies yes and conjures up a diamond necklace. He tells her that he is immortal. She asks him if he can keep her young for all time. But being immortal does not mean that you can't be killed. He mentions a prophecy that says someone will be his undoing. Lacey asks why he does not kill this person first. Mr. Gold responds that something is standing in his way. Lacey counters that she thought he was someone who did not let anything stand in his way. Mr. Gold agrees and they kiss..

Emma and Neal sneak into the Cannery looking for Regina. She asks him if he will have her back if they find out that Tamara is indeed involved. He agrees. They hear something and she almost shoots David and Mary Margaret. David gives Emma a walkie-talkie and they split up to look for Regina. Tamara and Greg sees everyone on their security monitors. Tamara says that it is time to go. Greg can't leave yet since he is so close to finding his father. He storms into the room and zaps her again. She still refuses to talk. He turns it to full blast. Regina says that she will tell him where his father is. She tells him that she killed him right after Greg left the town. He does not believe her. She tells him that she buried him at their old campsite. She told him because she wanted to see the look on his face. He turns on the machine as Regina screams.

After Wendy's mom wishes them good night, they start to prepare themselves for the Shadow's arrival. They light a bunch of candles, put jacks by the window sill and they arm themselves with pots and pans. Very Disney lost boys kind of style. The Shadow appears and all of the candles turn out. Bae tells everyone go hide in the crawl space that Bae was hiding in before. Michael (youngest son) did not listen and is standing in the middle of the room with the Shadow. The huge dog is barking. Bae runs out and offers himself instead of Michael. The Shadow takes his hand and starts to fly out of the window. Wendy grabs on not wanting to let go. Bae thanks Wendy for letting him be a part of her family. The Shadow takes Bae outside and flies toward the second star to the right. They disappear.

Greg continues to torture Regina and tells her that this is the end for her. She will never be able to hurt anyone ever again. David suddenly rushes in and shoots up the electroshock machine. Greg makes a run for it and David tries to chase after him. Mary Margaret stops him saying that Regina is near death. David thinks that they should bring her to Mother Superior( the blue fairy ) as quickly as possible. David tells Emma via walkie-talkie that Greg was the one who kidnapped Regina. Neal says that he was right about Tamara not being a part of all of this. Tamara comes out knocks Emma out with a crowbar and takes her gun. She tells him that she and Greg have been working together all along. Neal asks here what she is doing. She tells him that Magic does not belong here and he should understand that. He asks her how long. From the beginning when she spilled the coffee on herself. A few more moments pass with Tamara telling Neal that she never loved him and that her job is more important then him. Neal tries to leave to warn the others and Tamara shoots him. Before she can shoot him again, Emma wakes up and then begin to fight. They beat each other up and right when Emma is about to get the gun back, Tamara throws a magic bean to open a portal right in front of Emma. Emma grabs onto a railing on the wall but Neal is being sucked into the portal. Emma grabs his hand. Neal tells her to let go. Henry can't lose the both of them. He does not want Henry to grow up like they did as orphans. They tell each other that they love each other and Neal slips away into the portal. Tamara is already gone by the time the portal closes.

Greg is digging in the woods telling himself that Regina did not tell the truth. His shovel hits something and he finds his dad's shirt. He starts to dig with his hands and finds a skull. Regina was telling the truth. She killed his father.

Mother Superior is healing Regina with her blue wand in Emma's apartment. The cuff disappears and she says that Regina's magic will heal her in time. Emma comes back and tells everyone that Tamara killed Neal.

Back in Neverland, the Shadow is flying across the ocean holding Bae. He is trying to escape and lights a lighter causing the shadow to let him go. He falls into the ocean. The Shadow flies around but cannot find the body. We see Bae's body in the ocean and suddenly a rope in thrown. He is pulled onto a ship where we see Captain Hook.