Plot

Mr. Puzzles challenges the captive heroine Jennifer to his diabolical puzzles which could end very badly for her - with whales.

Mr. Puzzles holds Jennifer captive in an abandoned Rust Factory, dangling her over a series of chair saws. He subjects her to various puzzles of which each have a consequence when she fails them. For her first puzzle, she has to tell Mr. Puzzle which house turns into hostel on a fully moon or Mr. Puzzles will kill her co-worker who is bound to a chair nearby. When Jennifer fails the first puzzle, her co-worker is killed by a canon which fires sharp rollerblades at him. A drunken detective falls from the ceiling to rescue Jennifer but is too drunk to save her. He stumbles onto on a trap and a whale lands on him from the ceiling. Mr. Puzzles tells Jennifer that she is in her desperate situation because she ran over various horror icons (in pun and homage) with her car last summer. Mr. Puzzles begins to lower Jennifer into the chair saws. She delays her death by challenging Mr. Puzzles to her own challenge. Before she can offer her puzzle, they are interrupted by the drunken detective and the whale, who is actually an underwater cop. The whale cop shoots Mr. Puzzles. Jennifer is rescued, only to discover that Mr. Puzzles has another puzzle from beyond the grave. The Rust Factory goes dark. When the lights turn back on, the drunken detective and Jennifer are tied to giant bowling pins. As a huge bowling knife rolls toward them, they are once again saved by hundreds of whales that plunge from the ceiling. Finally feeling safe, Jennifer sits to send a text from her phone, not realizing that she has sat in a chair saw. The chair saw starts up and the film ends with Jennifer 'screaming the scream of many sequels.'