"Homeland" The Smile (TV Episode 2012) Poster

(TV Series)

(2012)

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Homeland (Channel 4) - Review
mail-479-2411238 October 2012
World politics is these days mostly represented by a single flag: The Stars & Stripes. The Americans wave it proudly while the rest of the world soak it in petrol and set it on fire.

Last night's Homeland kicked off with that very image, as anti-American feeling ran high on the streets of the Middle East – immediately grounding the second series of this acclaimed blockbuster firmly in reality. There's been a noticeable dearth of good new drama on TV recently, so what a relief to see this series back on our screens.

Read daily TV reviews at mouthbox.co.uk

Homeland is the best drama on TV by a country mile. The characters are believable. The storyline is topical and relevant. The performances are outstanding, throughout the cast.

This series is good for many reasons, but mainly because it is scary. Homeland connects to us on a very deep level – using that part of our brain that fires up just before we go to sleep and keeps us awake through the night with dark fears and complex anxieties.

The recap of series one turns out to be almost as long as episode one of series two. When the backstory finally grinds to a halt we discover Carrie (Claire Danes) recovering from her bipolar meltdown by doing a little light gardening and cooking dinner for the family.

She also appears to be working as a supply teacher and is snowed under by a great big pile of extremely boring marking. When you've worked in the field for the CIA it's hard to immerse yourself in a task which mostly involves using a red Biro to draw circles around spelling mistakes.

Lucky for Carrie there's a girl in Beirut who has information about an imminent attack on America, and she refuses to give it to anyone but her. So it looks like the marking is going to have to wait.

Carrie pops a mouthful of anti-depressants, dyes her hair a fetching new shade, and takes on a brand new identity. Soon she is in Beirut, where men sit in parked cars looking through huge pairs of binoculars and no-one takes a blind bit of notice.

Carrie quickly returns to her favourite pastime – that of running around in crowded markets being pursued by beefy foreign agents. She has to do this, because, as every good promo director knows, it's those shots that make the best series trailers.

Brody (Damian Lewis) is now a congressman and his office is a busy place. In his first meeting of the day he is offered the job of vice president of the United States. In the second meeting he's asked to betray his country by passing on crucial security information. All of this before he's had his first cup of coffee.

Soon we find Brody rifling though a safe and copying top secret documents – not by photographing them, for some reason, but by very slowly and meticulously writing out what he sees in long hand in a little notebook.

I am puzzled by this. Surely even in the nineteen-sixties spies had cameras for copying documents? So why this weirdly retro step? Surely he could have done it way quicker with an iPad? Or have the White House got something against Apple? While all this is going on Brody's daughter (Morgan Saylor) is at the school debating society and accidentally blurts out that her congressman father is a practising Muslim. Strangely, no-one at the school seems particularly bothered about this revelation.

Even Brody himself tells his daughter not to worry about it. But the guano really hits the fan when Brody's wife Jessica (Morena Baccarin) finds out. She dashes out into the garage, grabs a copy of the Qur'an, and throws it roughly onto the dusty floor. Careful Jess, Fatwas have been issued for less.

The paths of Carrie and Brody have yet to cross, and it will no doubt be that rekindling of fierce sexual chemistry which will take the tension and suspense to the next level during the coming weeks. I, for one, cannot wait.
14 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A fine opening to the second season
Tweekums8 October 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Season two opens some time after the conclusion of the first series; Brody is now a congressman and is being sounded out to run for the vice-presidency, Carrie is teaching and Saul Berenson is working at the US embassy in Beirut. In the aftermath of Israeli attacks against nuclear installations in Iran anti western feeling are running high so when an informant, the wife of a Hezbollah chief, contacts the Embassy Saul takes it seriously… there is a problem though; she will only talk to her old handler; Carrie. Carrie is not keen to get involved but eventually she is talked into it and heads to Beirut. Brody meanwhile is contacted by somebody working for Abu Nazir and instructed to steal some codes from CIA Director David Estes; it won't be too easy as the safe is in his office in Langley. He has problems at home too when his wife learns of his conversion to Islam.

It is of course impossible to judge a series by its opening episode but things certainly got off to a good start here. We were quickly shown where each of the key characters are now before their lives are uprooted once again; with two characters being pushed to do something they'd rather not. Brody clearly hoped that his involvement with Abu Nazir was over but clearly it will never be; Damian Lewis does a great job in this role; it would be hard to guess that he was English rather than American if you didn't know already. Claire Danes also does a fine job as Carrie; she plays her just manic enough to look disturbed without thinking the character is insane… although the smile she gave as the escaped her pursuer in Beirut had a hint of madness it was so gleeful. A series is obviously more than just its stars and all the supporting actors do a fine job too keeping things believable when they could so easily seem far fetched.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
More Pep for Homeland
xcitenlady21 October 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I think this is one of the best TV/Cable Series ever. I was hooked from the very beginning as the terrorist angles incite fear and excitement at the same time. Season 1 left me wanting more and not wanting it to end. I think Claire Danes and Damien Lewis are superb in their acting skills. He being British; has an American accent down pat. She plays a mentally disturbed neurotic excellent too and proves there is a thin line between genius and insanity.

Mandy Pantokin is also very good too. Personally I think he is the traitor/terrorist teaming with Brody or if not Danes who may have been coaxed in it in a mentally induced episode during her time with the CIA.

Morena Bac (sp) is the only actress that I think needs improvement, her acting is not the best and sometimes she appears to say her lines like a high school drama play. She is very stiff in her approach. I don't feel the chemistry between she and Brody as husband and wife. I think after the dust all settles, Homeland may possibly remain at the top but it will have to continue to tweak its story line to not lose its audience in the intricacies of the more well developed characters in Danes and Lewis every week.
1 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
What a nice,exiting premiere
sam_death1 October 2012
I'm not going to spoil anything because i think its not a nice work to explain the story in a review especially for a TV series like Homeland.First season had exiting and surprising moments but i'm sure that this season is going to rock ,"The Smile" is one of the best premiere of this year and month TV Shows ,its exiting and at the end you can't hold your self until the next week like me (:d).The directing and script writing is nice and this show has a potential to have at least 5 or 6 seasons.Next episodes are going to be epic and more exiting than this nice,well directed episode .Don't lose this show whoever you are !
11 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A great start to the season. I'm call this episode "Pulled Back In; Betrayals because that title sums up the themes of the episode.
talksallabout-426-5363457 October 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Episode 1 of Season 2 of Showtime's "Homeland" is named "The Smile." After being fired from the CIA, Carrie is now living the quiet life of a "country mouse", her bi-polar disorder being held in balance by the drug, lithium. (We get a hint that her dosage may be to high—a foreshadowing of future trouble for Carrie as a consequence of an overdose of lithium.) At the beginning of the episode, Carrie is reluctantly pulled back into the spy game, and returns to Beirut to meet with a female asset with valuable information about a terrorist plot, but who will only speak with her. A reluctant return, but it doesn't take long for the adrenaline rush from a cat-and-mouse game with a terrorist sent to disrupt (at the very least) her mission to change her reluctance to eagerness. The CIA "mouse" (Carrie) defeats her terrorist "cat", and as the episode ends, she breaks into a broad ear-to-ear smile. (This is the "Cheshire-cat" moment of the episode, or perhaps I should call it "happy-as-a-cat-in-cream" moment. Carrie's back in the game and loving it.

I'm renaming the episode "Pulled Back In: Betrayals" because that title does a good job of enumerating the themes in this episode.

Carrie is pulled back into the spy game, but by allowing herself to be drawn back into the action when her sanity and mental stability is still quite fragile, she betrays herself. Her duty to herself is to avoid stress and get well. Self-betrayals are the worst—aren't they? Nicholas Brody, former marine, current congressman and possible V.P. pick, current terrorist mole, and Carrie's nemesis in Season 1, is enjoying his new-found fame and good fortune. You know who is enjoying it even more--Brody's wife Jessica (played by Morena Baccarin). She is thrilled to be hob-nobbing with other political wives and basking in the reflected glory of her husband. But a number of betrayals are about to upset her happy little apple cart.

This is only part of my review of this episode of Homeland. I put the rest online at Premium Cable Reviews.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Homeland The Smile
dalydj-918-25517530 September 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Last season Brody almost blew up but thinks he can find a different way of leading the country and also Carrie got shock treatment but before she could she remembered some important information that could have proved her theory. Six months later and Carrie does not work for CIA anymore. Her family is worried about her and she jut has to take her medication and everything in the past should be gone. Saul is in the war country looking at people at people who may be assets. When Saul goes out in a car they can see that they are being followed. So Saul gets out of a car to get away from these people who were following him, he then goes into the middle of town to talk to the women who wanted to talk to him. Brody is in office, the vice president comes to see him asking him to be his running mate for the next election. Carrie is a teacher know but then the CIA finds her and comes to want to talk to her. Jessica does not like her daughter but we know her husband does and so he asks her to go light on her. Saul calls for Carrie and tells her to talk to David who wants her to come back even though she has put it all behind her and just wants her normal life back. The CIA need her help as they know she knows so much even the person who comes to talk. Fatima refuses to speak to anybody other then Carrie so she is asked to go to Beirut, her sister is not OK with it but her father tell her to go on this mission. Abu Nazir sends a woman to talk to Brody about what he is doing. He is told to choose which side he is on, she then leaves as he sits thinking about what has just happened. Dana is then in a church meeting the next day and out of no where she says that her father is a Muslim. Carrie is in Beirut wearing a disguise a of brown wig and contact lenses to blend into the people in the country. Brody is at the agency to be prepped for the nomination, then David is asked to leave the room which causes Brody to look around a bit, through files and everything. As David talks to Nazir's informant Brody copy's down some important information. Carrie gets through easily and gets to her room where we see she was sweeting a lot because she was nervous. She meets with Saul in the square even though people are watching. Someone goes after Carrie and she runs because she knows how to get away. Then when he gets to her she knocks the gun away and gets away which brings joy to her as she feels she is back in the game. Back in the states Brody gets rid of his Muslim belongings by putting them in the ground. Dana then comes out to help him get rid of it. Nice return with for the six time Emmy winning show. Danes and Lewis are always the best.

EPISODE GRADE: A- (MVP: Claire Danes)
1 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A great season opening to a great show
AndrewCJordan10 February 2024
Homeland (Season 2, Episode 1)

A few months ago, I got the first season of Homeland on DVD and I was very impressed. This quickly became one of the best TV shows I have ever seen. I liked how suspenseful the show was and I also considered this show to be very thought-provoking as well. So, when I saw the second season on DVD at the thrift store, I knew I had to give this season a shot. In this episode, you see Nicholas Brody, a suspected sleeper agent for the terrorist group Al Qaeda, be asked to be the running mate for the Vice President's presidential campaign. Seeing Timothee Chalamet in this episode (approximately five years before he became an overnight star) was nice as well.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Same cliches
lluca-4774822 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Same dated cliche as in any other movie or show on a similar subject. An excellent show at the top of deja-vu mediocrity range. Captivating to watch. However it leaves me with nothing memorable.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
What arrives slowly and leaves very fast?
theovosse19 November 2015
Warning: Spoilers
I liked the first season. It might have been a bit over the top, but it had good points, a good plot, and the final episode was very well done. The ending caught me by surprise.

Perhaps that made me expect too much of the season 2, but boy, was I disappointed. It starts well, but quickly starts using all spy movie clichés that fit in 20 minutes. And why is a female reporter who must be known to be related to The Bad Guy allowed to just waltz in and make someone do things they don't want to by just saying a few words? I'll never know, because that was the moment the credibility was lost, and I have no interest in resuming watching.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed