Recurring guest characters include nerdy Felton Fanboy ("Pop-Culture Fanatic"), horror host Svengoolie ("Master of Terrormonies"), and injury-prone delivery man Slipped Disc Jockey ("Can't Ride a Horse").
Goldie Fisher visits the show from the International Date Line, then uses her handy transporter app to time-travel back to 1959, where she reports back to Bill and Toony about vintage trends like hula hoops and Barbie dolls.
Bill points out that all of the featured cartoons from 1959 are Warner Bros. shorts from the Looney Tunes or Merrie Melodies series, since by that year production had ceased on theatrical Popeye cartoons (by Famous Studios for Paramount Pictures) and Tom and Jerry cartoons (by MGM's animation house).
All five featured cartoons had appeared in previous episodes of the show: Wild and Woolly Hare (1959) was in Of Course You Realize This Means War (2021); A Mutt in a Rut (1959) was in Super Second Stringer Day (2021); Mouse-Placed Kitten (1959) was in Toons & Temptations (2021); Wild About Hurry (1959) was in Tyler (2021); and Hare-Abian Nights (1959) was in Bugs' Birthday (2021).
MeTV horror host Svengoolie makes a brief appearance, saying that he's invited pop-culture fanatic Felton Fanboy to his show's set, since the two have similar tastes in movies. Felton Fanboy's list of top films from the year 1959 include low-budget horror and sci-fi flicks like The Giant Gila Monster (1959), The Giant Behemoth (1959), Attack of the Giant Leeches (1959), The Killer Shrews (1959), and The Wasp Woman (1959).