Wicked Attractions looks at the case of bodybuilder Craig Titus and fitness model Kelly Ryan who are responsible for the murder of their assistant Melissa James.
Wicked Attraction looks at the case of Carolyn King and Bradley Martin who kill a Pennsylvania florist and later kidnap and murder a woman in North Dakota.
Wicked Attraction examines the case of Nicole Kasinskas who kills her mother Jeanne Dominico when she refuses to let her move in with her boyfriend Billy Sullivan.
Wicked Attraction examines the case of the "Children of Thunder" Justin and Glenn Helzer who murder five people in Northern California in order to raise money for their battle with Satan.
Wicked Attraction examines the case of ex-con Darnell Smith and his girlfriend and former prison guard Tina Leja who murder and dismember a man in Wisconsin.