Plot

Harry travels to the Ute Reservation to help Asta's grandmother and learns what it means to belong.

The police take their search for the severed foot owner's to the lake shore, while Harry receives an invitation from Ben to come to supper - and calm down Max. Meanwhile, Max and Sahar come up with a plan to break into Harry's cabin, and Dan finds out about the child Asta gave up when she became pregnant as a teenager.,—Gislef

Harry dreams of living a normal life in Patience, until he receives the device from his spaceship and it destroys every human being.

Going outside, Harry finds Mike, Liv, and the rest of the police still searching the nearby lake. Liv tells Harry that they switched their search to the shore based on the currents, and Mike can feel it in his balls. Henry inadvertently makes a joke about Mike's balls.

Later in town, Harry goes to the diner to eat and think about humans need companionship to eat. Ben joins Harry and tells him that they're getting closer to finding a town doctor. He invites Harry over to dinner with him and his wife Kate, hoping that it will their son Max a chance to see Harry in a more comfortable setting like their home. Ben takes Harry's silence as an answer and leaves.

Nearby, Asta is at a table, and D'Arcy sees her with a bottle of pills and sits down. Asta says that the she got the bottle at the party and they're dated after Sam died. She figures someone at the party is connected to Sam's stolen prescription pad. D'Arcy figures that it was obviously Jay, but Asta doesn't believe it. They argue about who was stupider when they did stupid things when they were 17, and Harry comes over asks Asta to come with him to the dinner date, so that he can sit alone while Asta talks to them.

Asta says that it's weird and she's busy, and D'Arcy kicks Asta until she suggests D'Arcy might go with Harry. She tells him that she'd be glad to go, and Harry accepts.

Later, Asta finds Jay sleeping in the break room. She wakes the teenager up and talks about the dumb things she did when she was a teenager. Asta finally tells Jay about the missing pad, and Harry comes in and asks what's going on. Jay tells him that Asta thinks she stole the pad, and even Harry figures it's obvious that Jay stole it. When Jay out, Harry pockets the food Asta bought Jay and leaves.

Later, Max returns home. Kate and Ben tell him that Harry is coming over to dinner. Before they say anything, he figures they're getting a divorce. His parents assure him they're not, and that Harry is coming to dinner. Max panics, wishes they were just getting a divorce, and goes up to his room.

In his room, Max packs to run away and calls Sahar on a walkie-talkie. She answers and Max says that he'll be dead soon. Sahar figures they can use the visit and her plan to break into Harry's cabin.

That night, Harry and D'Arcy arrive. Max is waiting and greets Harry cordially enough. As he hugs Harry, he secretly steals Harry's truck key.

Kate is surprised and apparently thrilled to see D'Arcy there. D'Arcy hugs Harry and says that he's very into he.

Sahar is outside, and Max calls her on the radio and tells her that he has the keys. Sahar checks Harry' truck and accidentally honks the horn, then finds the cabin's door keys. She rides off, and Max goes to the dining room. Harry wonders what Max is up to, and Ben asks about Harry's background. He claims that he's from New York City, and recites the opening dialogue from the show he's watched, 'Law & Order' and "Sex and the City'.

D'Arcy tells Max that she's know Ben since they were younger than Max when they met. The two of them laugh over elementary school memories, and D'Arcy says that Ben was her first kiss. Kate has never heard the story, and D'Arcy jokingly points outs that they never broke up. Ben jokingly says that he's been cheating on D'Arcy with Kate, and Kate goes to the kitchen to get more salad. Meanwhile, Harry glares at Max and Max smiles innocently.

Sahar goes to a nearby store where Mike and Liv are buying "evidence bags". Mike is buying Hot Wheels cars, and Mike insists that he's keeping some kid from buying it, chasing it out into traffic, and getting killed. Sahar tells Liv that she's buying tampons, and looks at the long line to the key-making machine at the counter.

Ben joins Kate in the kitchen and tells her that dinner is a success. Kate thinks it's weird Ben never told him that he never made out with D'Arcy. Ben says that it was no big deal. D'Arcy comes in to get some wine, and Ben hugs Kate. After D'Arcy mentions talks about how they used to sit on the coach when they were in 10th grade, she grabs the wine and leaves.

Since they're alone, Harry asks Max why the boy is being so nice to him. Max says that Harry didn't mean it, and Harry insists that he did.

Sahar finally gets to the counter.

Max goes to the door but doesn't see Sahar outside. Ben calls him back for dessert, and D'Arcy discovers the wine is gone. Max says that Harry and D'Arcy can't leave, and he wants to show them his solar system. He shows it to everyone, and Harry laughs hysterically when he says that he made a joke earlier about Mike's balls. Max stalls for time until Sahar gets back, offering to read his book report.

Sahar finally gets the key copied and rides back to the house.

D'Arcy dozes off from boredom while Max reads his book report, and Kate thanks Harry for coming. She's not so enthused about D'Arcy coming back. As they go out, Max grabs Harry's leg and begs him not to go. Kate pries her son away, and D'Arcy hugs her "sisterwed" goodbye. Kate and Ben go back in the house, and Max peers out the window looking for Sahar. In the truck, Harry considers if Max really likes him. He finds his house keys where he hid them, and drives off.

Sahar comes out of hiding and holds up the duplicate keys so Max can see them.

Harry drives D'Arcy home and she asks if he's going to kiss her. The alien figures he can do it. He ends up licking her face, and D'Arcy says it's not the worst kiss she's had. As she goes, Harry wonders why his penis is having rigor mortis.

The next day, Dan comes into the clinic and tells Asta that her grandmother called. Dan asks if they can take her a steroid shot for her back, and wants Asta to go instead of Harry. Harry doesn't want to go, and Asta doesn't want either of them to go. She leaves, and Dan glares at Harry.

At the sheriff's office, Mike and Liv go over everything they've dredged from the lake. Liv points out the doorknob that the alien Harry ripped from the real Harry's door, but Mike doesn't think it's important and thinks it came from a sunken houseboat.

Dan drives Harry and Asta to the reservation, and Harry is surprised to learn that humans can be with each other and not talk. He's happy, and says that he has to pee. Dan stops at a gas station. David and Lisa are in a RV there, and Dave points out that Lisa killed the cowboy they were questioning. Lisa points out that the authorities ruled it a simple robbery, and reminds David that their orders are to deliver an alien to the General without anyone knowing about it.

David isn't convinced, and Lisa admits that things are going to get messy. She says that she's eliminating anything that gets in the way of their mission, and that could include David if he doesn't stop whining. David storms out and goes to the restroom, where Harry is reliving himself. Harry asks David if he shivers when he pees, and David admits that sometimes he does. Once Harry leaves, David wonders what the conversation was about.

Dan continue driving to the Ute Reservation, and Kayla greets Asta and Dan, and Harry when he comes over. Kayla introduces her husband Shane, and the guests greet Harry as well. Harry realizes that it's company that brings humans together, not food, and thinks the human feeling to belong feels good to him.

Harry, Dan, and Asta go to Asta's grandmother Ruth's bedroom. Asta introduces Harry and he prepares the steroid shot.

Max and Sahar are riding their bikes down the highway, and Mike comes up behind them in his jeep, turns on his lights, and tells them to pull over. The kids do so, and Mike tells them that they turned without their hand signals. Sahar claims that they saw Bigfoot, and Mike is happy that they're outside instead of staring at a TV. He tells them to go and be safe, gets in his jeep, and drives off.

Liv goes to the bar and D'Arcy serves her a drink. The deputy questions if she deserves to exist, and talks about how everyone was in the bar cheering D'Arcy on when she was in the Olympics. Liv assures D'Arcy that she put Patience on the map, and she just needs one person cheering for her when Mike makes her feel dumb. D'Arcy tells Liv that she's the best cop she's ever seen, and should stand up to Mike.

Harry gives Ruth the steroid injection, and she tells Harry that she can tell he's there to do good things. When Ruth sees Asta with her nephew, she says that Asta should have a child of her own. Harry mentions that Jay is Asta's daughter, much to Dan's surprise. Asta breaks into tears and runs out.

Kayla follows Asta as she goes to her old childhood lean-to, and tells her sister that Asta gave up her kid, never told Dan, and Jay has spent her time wondering who she is. Asta's sister tells her that her secret is going to hurt a lot of people when it comes out, and Asta tells Kayla that she was too young to take care of Jay when she had her. Kayla says that she admired Asta making a difficult decision, holds her, and says that Asta did what a mother does by putting Jay's needs ahead of her own.

The local kids are playing basketball, and Harry joins them. The ball lands near him, and he tosses it back to them, putting it through the hoop. They applaud and Harry plays with them. He's not very good.

Max and Sahar get to Harry's cabin and use the duplicate key to get in. After giving Sahar a tin-foil hat to wear, he puts on one of his own, and they search the place.

Asta finds Dan, and he asks her how she couldn't tell him that Jay was his granddaughter. She says that Dan wanted him out as soon as he learned she was pregnant. Dan tells her that no one ever told her to go, and he hated the way Jimmy treated Asta. Asta says that it wasn't any of Dan's business, and he insists that it was. He says that her family would have been there, especially for him, and Asta tells him that he raised one child that wasn't his own and didn't want him to have to raise another. When his daughter asks, Dan assures her that they'll always be okay, and they hug.

At the cabin, Max and Sahar go down to the basement and find the ship wreckage that Harry has recovered. Sahar tries to open the locked freezer, and Max finds the apple hovering over the tellurium. He calls Sahar over, and when she touches the apple the backlash knocks both kids unconscious.

The basketball game goes into the night, and Harry manages to make a shot... for the other team. Tired, Harry bows out and wonders if he's going to die from overheating. He collapses in a nearby field and looks up at the sky, and sees his home planet's sun 46 light years away. Harry feels closer to it, and Asta comes over and Harry says that the basketball players are incredible specimens.

Asta lies down next to Harry and tells him what Dan says about the Big Dipper. Harry apologizes for telling her secret about Jay, and Asta tells him that he did them a favor. He says that he misses home and has a wife there, but she died do he took a job that brought him to Patience. Harry tells Asta that he wants to go home, and says that it's sad... now.

Later, Dan drives back to Patient with Harry and Asta. Harry figures that humans feel better when they know they're not alone. Asta turns on the radio, and she and Dan sing along together to it. Harry wonders what's going on and finally joins in.

At the sheriff's station, Liv tries to show Mike the doorknob again but he ignores her and leaves. She puts an evidence tag on it.

Harry returns to the cabin and finds Max's and Sahar's bikes parked inside to keep them out of sight from the outside. He closes the back door and locks it, and calls to the children. Harry goes downstairs and finds Max and Sahar unconscious on the floor, and the apple still floating above the Tellurium. He regretfully confirms that they're still alive, puts them into duffle bags, and carries them out, and finds a woman he hasn't seen standing in the kitchen.

When Harry asks how she got in, the woman says that she has the key and she's still the real Harry's wife. Harry drops the bags and stares at the woman in shock.