"Stargate: Atlantis" Midway (TV Episode 2008) Poster

(TV Series)

(2008)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Teal'c vs Ronon vs Wraith
XweAponX9 September 2014
What do ya do with the two Big Guys from the Stargate Franchise? Well, ya have them beat the crap out of each other, then you sic em loose on The Bad Guys. And then there's cake.

Chris Judge returns as the now well-aged "Teal'c" - Remember that in the SG-1 Series Finale, he lived for many years while the Asgard-Equipped ship "Odyssey" was in a Time-Bubble, he was the only one to live through the whole thing and return to a previous time, with memory (and age) intact.

So now we have an image of a very much older and wiser Teal'c, but one who is very much as virile as he ever has been - It is as if Teal'c has finally become his surrogate father "Bra'Tac", Save the Armored Skullcap. Instead, Teal'c sports a fine set of Grey-Streaked Dreadlocks.

Ronon Dex (Jason "Conan" Momoa) however is still very much like the younger Teal'c from the early years of SGC, and like Teal'c, must needs be questioned by the powers that be. For Ronin, this is the relatively new "IOA" agency, which has a new member which makes Woolsey appear friendly: "Coolidge" (played by Rob LaBelle, "Crazy Eddie" of "First Wave").

A Routine trip through the "McKay-Carter Bridge" (The series of Stargates which link the Pegasus galaxy to the Milky Way Galaxy) becomes not-so routine, and instead of getting to watch The Three Stooges with Ronon, Teal'c has to team up with him and kill Wraith. Not that Teal'c would not enjoy both activities.

As helpful as our Wraith friend "Todd" (Christopher Heyerdahl, sometimes Brendan Penny) has been, he is not immune to sabotage from his own Wraith crew or allies - He may have decided to keep all he had learned about Atlantis to himself, but he had other Wraith on his ship which did not like the idea of Wraith allying with Atlantis - So Todd was attacked and all of his Atlantis data stolen by a quisling - played here by Scott Heindl, who was the male form of the evil Lucy Butler in the series "MillenniuM". He is just as insidious here, playing one of the Long Haired Wraith "Captains".

The main point of attack is the "Midway" station, which is in free space in between the Pegasus and Milky Way Galaxies- Where Dr. Lee (Bill Dow) is trying to teach "Kavenaugh" (Ben Cotton) how to run the place.

Basically The Wraith have hacked into the Bridge system, and since there is no Iris or need to approve Inbound-Gate codes, they can just walk right in - Next stop, Earth and the SGC. Leaving only Teal'c and Ronon the only ones who can do anything about it.

Maybe it sounds like the whole plot is given away here, but it hasn't. This episode explores the similarities - And differences between Teal'c and Ronon, they are not simply two huge guys cast to make fight scenes look better, even though that is the result. These are two guys who have deep aspects. Indeed.

This is the second to last appearance of Kavanagh, and again he is just as stupid as he always is. Ironically, he had proved he can provide useful day-saving ideas, early in the series - But any series must needs have at least one total jerk. Usually, they are given an opportunity to acquit themselves, but here, he is his usual impatient self, the one who does not listen to McKay's urgency about not touching anything- Even though the immediate effect of his action here was positive. If McKay is left to "figure it out", the entire Milky Way would have been overrun while he was figuring it out. Kavanagh however, would simply press a button immediately and damn the consequences. It might have been great to have more appearances of this guy, but there is just so much you can take when dealing with meat-heads. Plus, the guy had been taken over by a Goa'Uld - Maybe Goa'Uld's thrive best in his personality type.

One thing I have noticed is that although Carter is one of the main stars of Season 4, Amanda Tapping was absent from a few episodes. In Atlantis as the Commander of the base, she is never given the opportunity to do what she does best, which is figure things out. But her appearance in this series after the "death" of Dr. Weir was a good choice.

The reason why I love this show and 'Stargate Universe" is the continuity between all of the series, and this episode seamlessly blends the universe of Atlantis and the Wraith with the universe of the Goa'Uld, the Ori, the Asgard and The Ancients- But the difference in Atlantis being, the Ancients are not seen as mystical beings who were always good, and correct- Many of their Mistakes can be found in The Pegasus Galaxy: From Wraith to Replicators.
21 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Stargate is back to quality writing here
jasonemartin-759274 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I was delighted to see this episode for one thing because I was getting sick of all the replicator episodes. Finally, a quality Stargate episode that brings together some people from SG-1 to some of the characters from Atlantis. It was interesting seeing Teal'c and Ronan clash in this episode, and how they didn't seem to come to respect each other until they fought together against the wraith. I suppose it makes sense in a way as the two are essentially coming from warrior cultures. One other reviewer complained a little in saying it wasn't realistic that the two were evenly matched or nearly evenly matched. I suspect this is probably true considering Teal'c has the healing powers of either tritonin or a symbiote, which I would think would give him an edge. In a way it was nice to see the two of them together in one episode because I had written them both off as the strong silent type, thinking of both being a similar character type. And I guess they are, but seeing them come together made me realize how different the two characters really are: Teal'c has a certain civility and civilized disposition to him that Ronan lacks.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
good script return in Atlantis
bigphantom16 February 2008
Warning: Spoilers
never thought Stargate Atlantis would return in such a cool way. After several episodes that, in my opinion were written and aired just for publicity, money, audience - with disregard to general viewer - this episode tries and almost does what a sci-fi series would need to do.

It brings mystery, action, cool SF action, not just regular walks on Earth like planet, and possible (the cool) return of the Teal'c Jaffa in action.

This episode is full of action, like in the old SG1 days, possible prefiguring a good season finale (which is not as far as you may think). The appearance of Teal'c in a new trendy outfit, with a never unseen look and without his "spear" led me to think that the script of the show has been modified to meet the demands of the audience.

A new team seems to arise inside the Stargate Atlantis, now with the departing of pregnant Teyla
18 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Classic Stargate all the way through
cottavia31 May 2022
This episode should be much higher rated! For hard-core stargate fans this episode resonates very closely to the likes of Wormhole Extreme, 200 and Window of Opportunity in its humour. Sure, the storyline is pretty loose and there's obvious plot holes but I enjoyed seeing Tealc and Carter at Atlantis together much like when SG1 travelled to Atlantis in The Pegasus Project.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Dumb it down and just fight
n-middleton-1177 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This episode seems to have been summed up very well by other users, providing clear and succinct summaries of what happens. I tend to concur with their sentiments about how the plot of pitting Teal'c and Ronon against each other, before having to work together in isolation from the rest of the team, to defeat the wraith is a great plot line.

My only gripe with the episode, and to be fair is a gripe more so with the character than the episode itself, is how idiotic and immature they portray Ronon to be. This is an inconsistency that has frustrated me since his introduction to the show. For someone who is meant to be a seasoned special ops veteran, who has survived for years on his own, he seems incredibly immature, completely unbefitting for someone with his history.

If he were a minor character, I'd understand a need to exaggerate his characteristics to convey a feeling for his persona in a short period of time, but he's not; he's a lead role. Ronon's character is one that the writers just never do justice. They could just as easily demonstrate his aggression and impulsivity, without making seem like a baby with dreadlocks, throwing a tantrum. It also would have been nice to see Teal'c maturity and tactical awareness come to light in the fight between the two, perhaps by coaxing Ronon into a brazen attack, exposing a weakness, which Teal'c can then exploit, despite being older and likely slower (still not bad for someone supposedly over 100 years old though).
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I'm years behind but it doesn't matter!
rcsipe13 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
When I saw Tael'c come through the Stargate, it made my day! And when THIS happened...

Teal'c: "Indeed" Ronon: "You say that a lot." Teal'c: "What?" Ronon: "Indeed" Teal'c: "Do I?" Ronon: "Yeah." Teal'c: "I had not noticed."

LolOloLOLOL

I about fell off the couch laughing. Absolutely hilarious if you know both shows
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Ronan is Teal'c's equal??
chiguy176 April 2019
This was one of the worst episodes in the SG universe. Teal'c, a Stargate legend, is pitted against Ronan. Although Teal'c is clearly in better shape and Ronan's superior physically, mentally, strategically, etc. they make them equals and a formidable match for each other. I have no idea why they did this, as it's not the least bit believable. Just a horrible decision on the part or the writers and producers.
4 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Goof wraith weapons
starfury-5264710 April 2022
In the scene where the wraith are shooting the door they would never have an effect there hand held weapons only effect organic material aka people. I know these wraith Drones arent the brightness & at times the writers but comon....
1 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed