How Far is Home (2020) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
seizing their opportunity
ferguson-630 March 2020
Greetings again from the darkness. It's a 21 minute documentary short film, yet director Apo W Bazidi (RESISTANCE IS LIFE, 2017) manages to put a face to President's Trump immigration policies and proposals, and those people trying to make the best of it. We immediately take a liking to Ahmed Mohammed, the same as most others who meet him.

Ahmed attends Thomas Jefferson School in Cleveland. It's an immigrant school and covers grades Pre-K through 12th for "newcomers." We learn Ohio receives the third most refugees of any state, and most are children. Ahmed is from Iraq and is 11th grade. He attends school, works as a busboy, has been selected for peer mediation, and acts as translator for new students. He sports a mop of wavy hair, loves acting class and soccer, and is bursting with charisma. Ahmed is everything we hope for our own kids. However, Ahmed has lost both parents, and now clings to his sister Ruba, a senior at the same school. They came to the US from Syria, after previously fleeing Iraq.

One of the best moments occurs when Ruba reads the paper she wrote recollecting her own experience ... an experience likely similar to many in her class. Each is learning a new language and culture, and the support system of the teachers and administrators is crucial. Many of the teachers have backgrounds similar to the students. The film is filled with folks making the best of their situation and seizing an opportunity to salvage a life, where once one was in doubt. One can view Bazidi's film as being critical of the current U.S. immigration policy, or as an exceptionally inspirational film about those who are working daily to take advantage of an opportunity. Ahmed and Ruba, and these educators leave quite a strong impression.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
How Far is Home
mollyedwards-8079420 April 2020
Apo W. Bazidi's documentary shines a light on young immigrants in the United States against the backdrop of Donald Trump's 2017 travel ban.

How Far is Home focuses mostly on Ahmed and Ruba, a brother and sister who attend the Thomas Jefferson school for immigrants in Ohio. Ahmed aspires to be an X-ray technician so he can help people, and Ruba is said by her brother to be smart, enjoying learning and drawing. We learn that they left Syria to escape the violence of the civil war, returned to Iraq, and eventually travelled to the US. The harsh reality of this violence is shown to us through Ruba's own words: she tells her classmates about her two closest friends, who were killed when a bomb hit their home in Syria. This is intercut with footage of wreckage, destroyed buildings (and with them, destroyed lives), and it's the first time in the documentary that we truly realise what these children and so many like them have experienced.

This is not a politically neutral documentary. The critique of Trump is subtle, but clear. A voice over news report about Trump's travel ban comes at the documentary's beginning, and then we're shown the school, introduced to Ahmed and Ruba, given an insight into them as people, their lives and experiences - and then the voice over returns. In this way, we see how these large scale government decisions interrupt and affect the lives of so many people. Trump makes his only appearance in footage displaying the kind of rhetoric this documentary aims to undermine: 'the United States will not be a migrant camp. And it will not be a refugee holding facility' Trump says, while we watch the children laughing and playing sport. They are not a nameless, faceless, homogenous group; How Far is Home humanises the immigrant and refugee experience and challenges the derogatory connotations of Trump's terminology. As one teacher tells us, the students 'could make this beautiful place even greater' - a subversion of Trump's much maligned make America great again slogan.

It's clear the documentary subjects are aware of the camera at all times, which only serves to bring their personality closer to the surface than a more fly on the wall approach. Ahmed is constantly smiling, playful, having fun with the camera and addressing it directly. We're invited and welcomed into the school - at the heart of this documentary is togetherness, a unity that crosses borders and connects people. One teacher speaks of the myth of American streets 'made of gold', that instead people work hard for what they have - this recalls the idea of the American dream, that anyone from anywhere can build a life in this land of opportunity.

How Far is Home reminds us that the President has made this difficult for countless people. Ruba herself encounters complications when the travel ban goes into effect while she is in Iraq - the school had a lawyer ready to help her, and this information is a jarring reminder of the obstacles these children have faced and will face.

How Far is Home could perhaps go further in grappling with the political situation not only in the US but around the world. As the closing text reminds us, anti-immigrant policies are on the rise. But How Far is Home very effectively humanises the very people some politicians try to demonise, and maybe that's enough to challenge prejudice. After all, these children are just trying to complete their education, not become ideological pawns in a debate over their humanity.

Overall, this is a quiet look at the ongoing struggle against anti-immigrant rhetoric and policies. Clocking in at just under 22 minutes, it has a lot to say in its short run time - but maybe pulls its punches just a little too much to be as effective as it could be.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed