The Hardy Boys (TV Series 2020–2023) Poster

(2020–2023)

User Reviews

Review this title
104 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A Good Update and Should be Watched: Overall an Enjoyable Mystery Series
pensman5 December 2020
I have been a Hardy Boys fan since I was ten and bought The Tower Treasure in 1956 at our local department store. In the first few Hardy Boy books, the boys rode motorcycles and carried 45's. As I continued to read the series, the boys became somewhat more wholesome. And younger, in the first few books Frank was 18 and Joe was 17; suddenly they were 16 and 15. Strangely, the age shift didn't bother me as the adventure kept me in thrall.

I like this version even though the city name is wrong, it should be Bayport; and I'm not happy with the age difference between Frank and Joe. The story here is good with some genuine mystery and menace. It's as much Hardy Boys as any and better than any of the other TV series that borrowed the name. I hope for a second series, but I fear a few of the actors will age out quickly.

I used to write fan letters to F.W.Dixon in care of the publisher. Someone always wrote back, and the letters were signed, F. W. Dixon. My son read my collection of books. And now I am hoping my grandchildren will read the books and become fans. Maybe watching the Hulu version of The Hardy Boys will spark an interest.

I do have few problems with this series. The story is good and the acting is fine. However, I have some casting issue. Rohan Campbell, who is 23, looks 30 and is too old for Frank Hardy. Alexander Elliot, Joe Hardy, looks 16 and not 12 and should be Frank. And Bea Santos, Aunt Trudy, who is 30 and looks 20 and should be dating Frank. Other than that, I do like the series. It has a nice noir quality to it that helps create just the right atmosphere.

And for the truly ancient, like me, watch for grandmother Gloria. She is played by Linda Thorson, who had the unenviable job of replacing Diana Rigg, Mrs.Emma Peel, on The Avengers. The TV show staring Rigg and Patrick Macnee as John Steed. "Mrs.Peel, we're needed."
58 out of 75 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Brings back memories
refordgarry5 December 2020
Growing up in 1960s Britain FW Dixon's (nom de plume) Hardy Boys books were not recommended by teachers, who considered them vulgar. Just the information we needed to secretly read them ALL, along with Blyton & WE Johns. So it's delightful to see the Hardy adventures at last dramatized for a more diffuse market, though these stories will always principally be for a younger audience - and correspondingly tactful in the portrayal of sensitive issues, which is commendable. Compared with 1960 Children's TV or Odeon/Gaumot Saturday Cinema Club (aka the flea pit) this production's not bad, but it'll probably not get an Oscar either.
31 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Fantastic mystery show not to be missed!!!!
nalindra-ferdinando5 December 2020
I have been a huge fan of hardy boys since age 10 and was thrilled to hear a tv show based on them. Whilst the age of characters have been changed the story is updated with a great sense of mystery and a 80s like setting that makes working in the mysteries even more enjoyable where now days people rely on tabs and phones for indie nation which really takes the fun out of mysteries. Overall love the feel and vibe and this show is off to a great start!!! 8/10
26 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Hardy boys
lee-756994 December 2020
It's a good show for what it is a thriller. But I've been a huge hardy boys fan my whole life. Read my first hardy boys in 3rd grade and got hooked on reading. Before that I hated books. As I said the show is good but it's not the hardy boys. EVERYTHING has been changed from the books. I've waited for so long for them to be on screen and as a fan im disappointed. Again I like the show but it should have been called something else
43 out of 64 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Kind of Stranger Things style. It was actually alright. Looking forward to seeing season two!
reb-warrior1 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Frank and Joe's mother dies, and later they believe she was murdered. This starts the whole premise of the first season as they investigate what happened.

Just have to say, right off the bat, that I am reminded a lot of Stranger Things(ST) in the way the style of the tale is told. First of all, it's the 80s. I think around the mid-80s. They play a lot of music from that time period. The story is told over 13 episodes, where everything converges near the end, just like ST. There is some similar music, a bit at times, especially when a major discovery is made or a major event happens. The story revolves around an "otherworldly" artifact. Kids are at the center of the story. There's a secret society. There's the whole smalltown scenario with mysterious going-ons. I mean it's kind of a cheap knock-off of ST, but the show is actually alright.

All the acting is ok. Frank seems so vanilla. The actor plays him with a lot of gravitas. I generally don't like vanilla characters, but I like Frank. Joe is very charismatic and likable. My favorite character was JB Cox. I think he was a take on D. B. Cooper. He made me laugh. I was totally rooting for him to get the entire artifact or at least a piece. Lol. I hope he's back in season two. He reminds me of Autolycus from Xena & Hercules. The thief with a heart of gold. I kept racking my brain trying to figure out where I'd seen Aunt Trudy before. Then it hit me in episode 8 that she's in Murdoch Mysteries, playing Louise Cherry. One of my favorite shows of all time.

A few things: Frank & Joe's dad didn't have a good look leaving his kids right after their mother was killed. Not to mention all of them moving right away to a new town. Joe and Frank's bicycles looked too small. Frank looks a little silly on it. Frank's folded-up jeans all the time seemed odd. I'm a kid of the 80s, that isn't a time-specific thing or a trend that surged. The show may be set in the 80s and they have the music and no cell phones or computer, but yet it doesn't really capture the 80s feeling like ST does.

The first episode, I think, is the weakest, yet compelling enough to make me watch the next episode. I think, coming from losing my mother this year, it all seemed too fast for the boys picking up and moving. They had no quiet time to reflect. People were expecting to come out and say goodbye right after the wake. I mean they're kids. They didn't go through their mother's things there in the house. There wasn't very much crying by Frank, Joe, and their dad. To be fair, this episode is set-up for the premise of season one. So they had to get a lot in and get Frank & Joe over to the small town all in one episode.

There's a quiet mysterious feel to the show that I like. I like the season-long mystery style. I hope they keep that format. I like the puzzle and clues journey. I actually like that not everything is moving fast, and prefer the slower pace of the show, which gives time for the characters to develop & interact and the story to be built. I prefer to watch not dark gritty things these days, so this fits the bill. It's not just for kids. If you like Stranger Things, you possibly... might like this. No, it's definitely not as excellent, but still, it's good, imo. 7/10.
11 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
NOT inspired or based off the book series at all..........yet!
lovettstough5 December 2020
I don't want to rate this show yet because I want to see more. I read at the very least half of the book series when I was young including well into my teenage years and beyond. When you go to HULU and you read the description it says inspired or based off the book series............it's NOT. Even beginning from the very first episode it is NOT inspired or based off the book series. Being somebody who has read the books if I had to give this show a rating based off the few episodes I've been watching so far it would NOT be a good rating at all. I don't want to rate it yet unless I'm forced to because I want to finish watching the rest of the episodes of this first season first.
23 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Not your parents Hardy Boys but an awesome show
dogma-5366815 December 2020
Okay so it's not like the books exactly. And it's not like the old TV shows. But these are modern times and this show is very very good, it has it all: mystery, suspense, and adventure that make The Hardy Boys a great watch. Hidden treasure and even more. It's worth a look give it a chance. Nuff said.
14 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
80's needs to be done correctly in order to sell the illusion.
FlixFan786 December 2020
So far I am enjoying the show but there are a few issues with the 80's set dressing that needs to be corrected. The story takes place in the 80's but there are pieces of technology in the set design that break the illusion. In episode 1, the boys and their dad move to their aunts home in Bridgeport. The TV in her living room is an early 2000's Samsung Dynaflat CRT TV. In her attic there's a early 2000's VHS-C camcorder in the background of one of the shots. Also in the attic the boys use an RCA VR546, silver, center loading VCR from 2002 to watch some old home videos. All CRT TV's from that era have a very distinctive bump in the front and flat CRT's didn't arrive until the early 2000's. All VCR's from the 80's (if front loading and not top loading) always loaded from the left side of the VCR and not the center. A simple google search by whoever is doing the set dressing could help them avoid these mistakes. Overall if you can overlook these and some other errors the show is entertaining.
25 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Fun. Entertaining. Mystical.
Orion_af_Solberga31 July 2023
I really enjoyed this series. Just finished season 3. It's got good characters, and the actors portraying them do a very good job doing so. The plot is intriguing and entertaining, and has some nice twist and turns. I could however be without all the magical and supernatural stuff, but it dosen't take way from the show, I just think it didn't need it and could have been just fine without it. It has got some funny moments as well as action ones. You finish it pretty quickly, at least I did. I did season 3 in two days. When I start, I just can't stop. I wanna know what happens next, so I am fast at play another episode. I find it sad it haven't got a renewal for a season 4, because it definitely got more adventures in it, with the Hardy Boys and their gang.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good, but not based on the book series
kenishaliyanage7 December 2020
The TV series is based on some of the characters while it is not like the book series. It similar to the Nancy Drew tv series where they have taken the names of the book but done a whole new spin. The tv series does contain suspense and flow, but can be a bit disconnected here and there.
11 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Hardy Boys WORTH THE WATCH
cdcxzvhtj29 July 2022
This show has an amazing full cast of characters. It does differ from the books where it's mostly just the two boys fighting through their adventures. This flushes out an entire town and multiple friends that help to solve all of the mysteries. I like how the first two seasons carried together throughout a similar storyline and it's not just two separate mysteries. There is action, detective work, explosives, magic, teen drama, and humor. I have thoroughly enjoyed watching the first two seasons and I strongly look forward to the next. If the show gets canceled it will be one of the saddest TV moments of my life just watch and you'll see. Please Hulu.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
How can season 1 be good and season 2 so bad?
spirit-386-50396017 July 2022
This rating is for season 1 only, as season 2 is just idiotic with a lot of scenes hammered into the screen, not making any sense. The plot is just stupid and even the actors that seemed ok in season 1, well, the ones that were not changed, now seem to be bad with the forced dialogues they have to say.

I just hope season 3 is as good as season 1, if there is going to be one after the complete failure of season 2.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Disappointed !
iamsreenath4 January 2021
When i started watching the show i had so many expectations but after watching few episodes my hopes went down. Bad performance, predictable story, there is nothing special worth mentioning except the performances by the gang of kids. The story and casting could have been better. if you are looking for similar - better series watch Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency, the outsider, Emergence etc.
22 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Up to ep two...
zenfrodo-970-9114694 December 2020
Warning: Spoilers
...and I'm trying NOT to binge-watch so I can make this last as long as possible. I've read all the rewritten blue spines & a good chunk of the original texts, along with many of the Casefiles & the current "Adventures" series; I loved the Disney serial & the 1990s Nelvana adaptation, and I'm a huge fan of the 1970s series.

I LOVE THIS NEW ADAPTATION.

This series is also done by Nelvana, and like the 1990s show, the writing is sharp, the mystery engrossing, and the casting is awesome. Frank & Joe act like real brothers; the Hardys, like a real family. The current eps feel like an origin story - how did two normal kids get into solving mysteries? In all the other TV adaptations, the Hardys' mother Laura is written out, or ignored, or mentioned only in passing; in the books, she's a non-entity, there just to bake cookies & occasionally worry over her boys. Here, she's an integral part of the Mystery, with her death kicking off the plot, as the brothers get pulled deeper & deeper into the whys.

There's also a lot of sly references to the books - ep 1 has Frank & Joe recreating the iconic cover of "Secret of the Old Mill" as they eavesdrop on their dad - with a mix of tech and styles that make the new series feel timeless. The Brothers ride bikes that look straight out of the 1950s, they play video games that look like first generation 1990s Nintendo, the local grocery doubles as an old-fashioned malt-shop, Fenton wears a by-gods trenchcoat & fedora right out of the 1940s pulp era, they use modern smartphones, the cars look torn from the 1970s, etc. Even better, they've brought back the diversity of cast/culture of the original texts, updated to 2010's standards.

In other words, this is a true "whole-family" show: aimed at the middle-schoolish & YA readers of the various book series, with plenty to engross & capture older fans of the Brothers. I hope this series sticks around!
11 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Nice edgy update
isagenixbeliever5 December 2020
In the more edgy style of Riverdale, this newest remake of the classic adventure book gives more back story to why the boys become sleuths. Also cashing in on the early 80s craze of that genre"s music and clothes. Great attraction for those of us in our 50s! Thanks for make the women more than throw-away characters!
14 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Love this show
secondsister22 February 2022
We just discovered this on Netflix a couple of weeks ago and have already finished it. I'm hoping the second season will be offered on Netflix too. It is a show with a really likeable cast. It's nice to find something to watch that keeps you coming back for more but isn't overly stressful to watch.
8 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Wholesome
thejefflewis-9222827 February 2022
Warning: Spoilers
The Hardy Boys has a great combination of mystery, small town charm, nostalgia (set in the 80s), supernatural, and teen romance. The first season revolves around the boys getting deeply involved in investigating their mother's murder while their father is out of town. This experience hones the boy's investigative skills. Season one's 13 episodes tells a single continuous story that wraps up in satisfying way.
11 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Simply Amazing!
shelbyjonas7 December 2020
I have to assume any bad reviews are people who did not stick with the show past the first episode or two! My husband and I LOVE it! It kind of gave me a mixture of Stranger Things / Outer Banks / Rivedale vibes! I didn't read the books, and my husband did. We both enjoyed this reboot of the Hardy Boys! Sure, as with anything it doesn't follow the books to the T, but I think that is actually what gives it an edge! If we read the books, this is still something nice and refreshed and different for us! Every episode had us on the edge of oir seats! We binged all episodes of seasonn1 in 2 days !
10 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The Hardy Boys
ameliawinter9322 April 2021
Neat fun, and modern twist to an old classic.

I know the show is still undecided at present, but I look forward to seeing what happens in season 2.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
How on earth can you call this Hardy Boys???????
wesleymichaelbrown10 January 2023
Maybe this could have been an ok TV-show if they had not used the Hardy Boys "brand". But as it is I found it absolutely absurd and unwatchable about halfway into the first episode.

This has absolutely no resemblance to the books (atleast not the original ones, which is the ones I've read) apart from some of the names used.

The age difference between the boys in this is obviously more than the year it is in the books, and to me the actor who plays Joe is/looks too young and with Frank it's the opposite which makes the difference seem even worse.

Also they've basically decided to kill off the boys mother to suit their story just to replace her with Aunt Trudy (Aunt Gertrude) and then add a grandmother (which in reality resembles Aunt Gertrude a lot more)

And of course "Biff" is suddenly a girl and Chet is definitely not fitting into his former description.

I mean if they hadn't used the Hardy name I probably wouldn't have guessed this series was supposed to be about them.
17 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Great storyline!
dobedobedo-431976 December 2020
A huge Hardy Boys fan in grade school and the story follows the quizzical kids of a detective. Currently on episode 10 and so far so good.
7 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A group of 20-somethings during the summer after 9th grade
professor_of_gamez9 June 2022
Wait, what??!! No, this is not a remake of Welcome Back Kotter with their "Sweathogs."

It's yet another instance of 20-something actors playing 13-14-15 year olds, for some reason (except for Joe and B-Rad (latter appears to be in her early to mid-30s). Is there a critical shortage of teen actors in Hollywood? One wouldn't think so.

That being said, the mysteries are not bad and keep you hooked.

Unfortunately, the show took a hard left turn when it ventured into sci-fi/fantasy.

I have to wonder what country the reviewer is from who said teachers didn't recommend these g-rated books for being too vulgar. Not here in the States.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Disappointed
quannacsking24 April 2022
I remember the announcement for this and I was so excited to see what they would make out of favorite childhood books but I was seriously whiplashed... I'm 17 and I know some people will say it's modernized or whatever....as a fan of the books I must disagree, it could be modernized yes but still with the basics of the hardy boys and what the books were actually about...I've been reading the hardy boys books since I was 5...those were the only books I would read at the time beside the Nancy drew ones so I think this show butchered the books so bad and spat in the face of the fans...they could've at least stuck to the source material...because the show is almost completely unrecognizable compared to the books...those who haven't read the books probably enjoy it but it's not for me.
19 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
If you're looking for a good family series... here it is!
DragonFireBreather23 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
This was actually quite pleasant to watch. I had read some other reviews saying it wasn't like the original but that is not entirely true. Yes although some characters were changed from boy to girl that did not change my opinion because overall this was a good clean family series. Which is rare these days. It reminded me of simpler times when I was younger. It is set in the 80's and was a treat not to see all these kids on their smart phones. I enjoyed the original Hardy Boys & Nancy Drew and this had remanence of those days. I liked it... I like it a lot.

The story of the entire series revolves around trying to figure out who murdered the Hardy boys mother. To some it maybe a little slow pace but to me that only gives greater detail to other things in the show which I enjoyed.

The brother relationship is good, there is a genuine bond between them, they meshed very well together. I also liked the relationship between Joe Hardy and JB the thief. It was fun, harmless and comical. I never worried about Joe's safety with JB. All the supporting characters worked here, and that's rare for me to say.

Overall I give it high marks because it was a really good clean family series without the cheesiness. No dirty scenes, violence or bad language. It's nice to enjoy these kinds of series in a world where we are swamped with inappropriate stuff. For that I say thank you for the much needed good old fashion entertainment.
6 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Stranger things is popular
nuffsaid-6357111 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
You tell this was made because strangers things was popular. However is pretty enjoyable. Interesting story and nicely shot and characters somewhat interesting.

There's no point for it been set in the 1980's as they don't even try to match the aesthetic of the time. It's so werid that they have these openly leabian couples when it was very homophobic in the 1980's. I keep forgetting it's not set now...make more sense if it was and they'd have to change almost nothing.

Overall enjoyable.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed