User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Nothing to Be Ashamed Of
boblipton27 October 2013
Robert leaves his mother's home and goes to New York. Six years later he writes he cannot spend Thanksgiving with her, so she goes to spend it with him. Feeling she would not fit in with his fancy friends, he sticks her in an upstairs room, where his elegant fiancée finds her and brings him to understand how badly he has behaved. He takes her downstairs, gives her the place of honor at the table and everything turns out well.

This Edwin S. Porter film is surprisingly heavy in titles for an Edison film for the era and for the modern audience, may be too broadly acted and title-heavy. For the era, when Griffith was still working on the subtler acting that would become standard, it is fine. The composition is excellent, as could be expected and there is a telling split-screen effect contrasting Robert's elegant house -- it looks cluttered to me -- and his mother's bare home.

In many ways this two-reel film is just made for a middle-class audience that has fought its way up from poverty. Films were still considered the theater for the poor and this movie, reminding the newly successful who they were, is a good effort.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Split-Screen Demographics
Cineanalyst28 November 2019
This early American Thanksgiving-themed short silent film, "His Mother's Thanksgiving," follows a hackneyed formula of the demographic dichotomy of the country life as good and the city's influence as sinful. Entire books could be written on this single throughline in silent cinema; the theme was that popular. Granted, in this particular variation, the story becomes unusually outrageous when the son welcomes his mother's surprise Thanksgiving visit to his city abode by becoming so embarrassed that he hides her upstairs while he continues a party downstairs. Regardless, the pictorial compositions supporting the narrative rural-urban divide here are worth mentioning.

The most remarkable scene begins as a superimposition--suggesting that the mother, while still in the country, is daydreaming about her son with his fiancée in the city--but, then, the doubled image slides into a split-screen configuration, which, instead, implies a simple parallel action. This isn't the only bit of confusing staging in this one, but it's the most interesting. Another scene is merely poorly framed. It involves the fiancée reading the mother's letter (there are a couple letters in this one, by the way, along with too many title cards in the tableau style), the contents of which imply that she has left the city, but then the fiancée stretches her arms out--in the theatrical acting style of the day relying heavily upon broad gesticulation--towards the bed in the room, which it turns out is where the mother was lying the entire scene--previously out of frame until she moves to meet her future daughter-in-law's embrace. There are also a couple interesting things about the decors. The Edison Company logo is prominent on the walls. Additionally, every room we see in the son's residence contains a mirror, in stark contrast to the hearth of his mother's rural home. Perhaps, the mirrors are merely there as part of his metropolitan decadence or the opulence of his newfound wealth, but they may also suggest the vanity of a son who has forsaken his backwater roots.

For those who enjoy a slice of sugary mush with their Thanksgiving dinner, bon appétit. Even if I don't, I'm thankful whenever preservationists make old films available to see. It's worth celebrating.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
It is, to say the least, quite unusual
deickemeyer4 October 2015
A touching Thanksgiving story, told in a way that appeals directly to the heart. It is of the different type and affects the emotions strongly. The action of the girl is surprising, but none the less attractive for that reason. The story is good. The details are worked out moderately well, but the question will arise how a young man like this can have such an elaborate home. City life is not like that. Thanksgivings are not eaten in homes of that type by young men. Further, while it is common enough for sweethearts to invite their lovers to Thanksgiving dinners in their homes, here is a distinct novelty. The young man has a home and he invites the young woman there. Perhaps the novelty justifies the innovation, but the feeling that here is something quite out of the ordinary cannot be overcome. Of course it is not impossible, but it is, to say the least, quite unusual. - The Moving Picture World, December 10, 1910
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed