"The Transformers" Carnage in C-Minor (TV Episode 1986) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
1/10
Masterpiece of 'hackness' by AKOM animation
adler_elfooscuro4 November 2008
Warning: Spoilers
This is actually one of my favorite episodes. Honestly!!! I can't get enough of it!! As much as I enjoy watching 'Microbots','Atlantis Arise' or 'Call of the Primitives (to give some examples) for their truly splendid animation (courtesy of TOEI Animation, I believe),.......

.....that experience is nothing next to the exact opposite, 'Carnage in C-minor'... one of those masterpieces of AKOM hack jobs, that just has to be seen to be believed. AKOM is a Korean animation studio that was already responsible for the atrocious animation in 'City of Steel', 'The Autobot Run', 'The Core', and 'Five Faces of Darkness', and would be responsible for much of season 3's animation, and later on, S4's three-parter 'Headmasters'(their finest effort, though). They were apparently a lot cheaper, and boy, does it show!!! The assessment that this episode has the same number of errors as other episodes can't be correct.The whole episode is an animation error. The artwork/animation is so ugly and lazy that it becomes hysterical. Add to the animation inconsistencies a dreadful, absurd script, and you've got pure gold..

The poor constructicons get the worst part here. They appear everywhere, change sizes, change sides, merge into Devastator several times and always get defeated in the most absurd ways. Once he gets crushed by a jet carrier (Broadside) that falls from nowhere, and the other he's blasted apart by a single shot by Perceptor, the weakest autobot ever. Grimlock grows a mouth, Hotspot appears next to Defensor (When Hotspot is supposed to be Hotspot's chest)... One has to wonder what Nelson Shin's motivations were to unleash this on us poor unsuspecting children of the time. But we do remember you, Mr. Shin!! thanks for accelerating the series cancellation with your cheap-minded decisions. Much similar to Hasbro's own cheap and greedy tendency to produce gradually inferior toys that culminated with pretenders, micromasters and actionmasters.('let's spend less on product, but keep prices the same, that means more money!!!')DUH! Really, this episode is so bad that it deserves a cult status. It's the lowest of all underdogs and that's why it must be loved. It should be revisited now and then for endless laughter. It's the Ed Wood of animation. Even the voice acting is hilariously bad and over the top. It's as if this episode was an intentional effort on everyone's part to deliver the worst possible product. Well, if that was their aim, they created a masterpiece
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
You only have to know this to not watch this
gacsogergely27 December 2019
They are singing. Pure and simple. And not the good way, like in thatepisode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, but the "this series is too tired to eject the abomination of the musical-episode" way. The story is basicaly that the decepticons record some alien voice, some annoying singing thing. The whole thing is not just a lazy and bad episode, but if it'd have any merrit, the decepticons from now on would be unbeatable with their newfound weapon of mass destruction. Which actualy works, unlike the transformers' weapons. This is the second alien weapon which WON'T be utilized by the bots.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed