"The West Wing" Freedonia (TV Episode 2005) Poster

(TV Series)

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Breathtaking!
Sonatine9718 April 2020
People criticise season 6 for being weak and not the West Wing of old since Sorkin left. But since the campaign arc began I would heartily disagree!

After 5 seasons of problems within the White House, it was literally a breath of fresh air to see the Democratic nomination campaign come to life in S6. Not only that but it introduced some new characters in Matt Santos and Arnie Vinnick, with some new ideas and dilemmas far removed from the introspection of Bartlet, CJ and Toby at long last.

This episode especially was a highlight, not least for Josh's frustration at trying to get his candidate, Santos, some air time on local and national TV. But also the growing intellectual awareness of Donna Moss, working for the Russell campaign, and how brilliant she was in taking a more objective view of why the Russell campaign was faltering at a resurgent Santos campaign.

I have always admired Donna in the early seasons - she may have been Josh's admin assistant, but she was also finely tuned to policy decisions that sometimes blinded Josh and later on, Russell. Josh underrated and derided her abilities, as did Russell to an extent, but she proved herself to be right on most of the decision-making processes.

As for Bradley Whitford's Josh - well, I have to say Whitford IS Josh! He plays the character brilliantly, and stands head and shoulders above most other characters in the West Wing albeit Leo and perhaps CJ. But I would have to say that 90% of the West Wing show seems to gravitate towards the Josh character, and I have loved every minute of it, along with his maturity & wisdom over the 7 seasons.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The perfect campaign episode
benfolds-129 October 2013
So I do not understand why people sometimes refer to the post-Sorkin seasons as weaker. This season really did it for me, especially the campaign arc which has been written and executed almost perfectly so far. It emotionally peaked for me here, at Santos' first little breakthrough making it this season's first ten point episode for me.

At its core it is what the whole series has always been about: Political utopia of what if politics could be done right. The best episodes of the series make us believe in that or at least they make us want to believe it could happen as depicted and as soon as Santos rips away the microphone after his one minute last shot of air time, you'll find yourself in that place again. The fact that this moment is not induced by Jed Bartlet but by someone who aspires to replace him convinced me for the first time that someone actually could fill his shoes. I found this so good it made me want to skip the next white house arc episode which I won't of course.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed