"Robert Montgomery Presents" The Sheffield Story (TV Episode 1952) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Could have been made into a full movie
HotToastyRag22 February 2018
As part of the television series Robert Montgomery Presents, David Niven starred in an hour-long filmed play called "The Sheffield Story". It takes place during WW2, and in the beginning, Niven is seen talking strategy with heads of the British army. In the next scene, German bigwigs are discussing their own strategy. A man enters the meeting, gives the Nazi salute, and then presents his information-information about what he knows the British are planning. Then we see his face: it's David Niven!

Despite the heavy amount of makeup applied to transfer over the television, it's not obvious that this is a tv special. Had the running time been expanded a bit with a couple of side plots, it could have been released in the theaters to rave reviews! While it's difficult to believe David Niven would do anything bad, it's fascinating to see him act as a double agent, reporting British secrets back to Nazi headquarters. If I didn't love him so much, I might think he was equally convincing in the British and German scenes, but I just refuse to see The Niv as a bad guy. Even when I watched him in Eye of the Devil, when he belonged to a Satanic cult, I still didn't think he was the bad guy!

If you like double-agent spy films, or strategy-heavy WWII flicks, or David Niven, check out "The Sheffield Story". Pair it with Court Martial to see even more of Niven's acting chops!
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Is that the best episode of this old TV show?
searchanddestroy-128 September 2015
I admit that TV series from the early fifties is rather hard to watch, to follow. Very static and talkative, I am glad not to have to view the whole package. I comment this one only because it has not any comment yet. But I can't ask the audiences to fight to get this one. Now, I really don't know how are the others. The previous episode of this show I saw today, starring Vincent Price - THE RING MASTER - was quite interesting but also so boring, sleepy in the shape. This one should have been more exciting one decade later, I ma sure of this. The Young David Niven is exactly at his place here, more British as ever.

I don't think many episodes of this series emerge now, after all those years, but if you can get any of them, try. You may find some gems, you never know.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed