(TV Series)

(1978)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
An interesting episode.
planktonrules14 April 2013
While Quincy and Sam are out driving in the desert, they notice a bike driven by some thug-type. Why did they notice? Well, the bike had a human skull attached to it! Even though it's not in his jurisdiction, Quincy is driven to figure out WHO this skull belonged to and how it got there. His path eventually brings it to the case of a missing union organizer--one who MIGHT have been killed by the mobster leaders of this organization. But, they wonder, is it REALLY him? After all, the dead man appears to have been a black man--and the missing man was white.

In addition to traditional forensic work you'd expect to see, this one also features a guest who is an expert at facial reconstruction. This aspect of the show makes this one very interesting--and a nice change of pace for the series.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Enjoyable classic Quincy.
poolandrews12 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: Passing starts in a desert roadside diner as Los Angeles coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) & his lab assistant Sam (Robert Ito) discuss the coroner's convention they have just attended & returning to LA from, a group of rowdy bikers enter the diner & Sam feels uneasy so he persuades Quincy to leave his hamburger & hit the highway. Outside Quincy notices one of the bikers motorbikes has a human skull mounted on the handlebars, instantly intrigued where it came from Quincy takes a look & sees that the teeth were knocked out to hamper identification & that the person who it belonged to probably died from a massive blow to the head. Quincy buy's the skull from the bikers & calls in facial reconstruction expert Lynn Peters (Zohra Lampert) to rebuild the persons face, after a bit of detective work Quincy becomes convinced the skull belonged to missing trade union president David Lockwood who mysteriously disappeared two years, three months & five days prior after supposedly stealing two & a half million dollars from a pension fund. Now Quincy has to find his killer...

Episode 15 from season 3 this Quincy story was directed by David Alexander this is a good solid Quincy episode. I liked the idea behind the facial reconstruction to identify a body & I would have thought this technique would have been pretty new back in '78, in fact you can tell how dated this episode is when Sam & Quincy are talking in the diner at the start & Quincy says that soon they will be able to identify someone from a single drop of their blood! We've been able to do that for years already. The mystery elements are good & it draws you in although there are one or two issues which I was less satisfied with. For instance Quincy ask's Monahan for a list of people who have gone missing during the past two years, well it turns out Lockwood went missing two years & three months prior so how did he end up on the list? Secondly as soon as Monahan says the name David Lockwood Quincy automatically assumes it's him even to extent where he visits his wife & friends at that point without any proof whatsoever, to be honest Quincy could have picked any name from Monahan's list & stood as much chance of being right so why did he assume it was Lockwood? The very fact he was right is surely a million to one shot? In a way that's like getting a list of the names of 100's of people you don't know or have never heard of, then being told one of them has won the lottery, randomly picking one & being absolutely right with your first guess! I suppose if you get over the huge leap of logic Passing is a fun enough episode with enough mystery, incident & some interesting detective work by Quincy using his medical skills to justify 50 odd minutes of your time.

This one is competently made as usual but rather bland to look at these days. I'm not happy about the plot point where David Lockwood was apparently a black man but was light skinned enough to pass himself off as white, the part of the story where the title Passing comes from. I'm sorry but by definition a black man has dark skin & I find it very hard to believe anyone of that origin could be light enough to pass themselves off as white, even back in '78 I doubt many people were convinced by this part of the plot. The acting is OK, Simon Oakland who played Sal Jarrett makes the first of his four guest appearances on Quincy where he played four different character's in four different episodes ranging from a US senator to a car mechanic!

Passing is a good Quincy episode, your going to have to get over a few plot holes & some rushed logic but overall I liked this one. A must for fans of the show.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Flawed murder mystery episode
rayoflite2430 August 2015
Passing begins with Quincy (Jack Klugman) and Sam (Robert Ito) eating at a roadside diner while traveling back to LA from a pathologists convention. A motorcycle gang enters the diner and an uneasy Sam rushes Quincy out the door, but as they walk to the car Quincy notices a human skull on the handlebar of one of the motorcycles and begins to examine it. Following a brief confrontation with the biker, Quincy buys the skull from him and returns to the lab to investigate who the skull belonged to and whether or not they were murdered.

A forensic artist (Zohra Lampert) is called in to assist in the case by doing a facial reconstruction, and the investigation leads them to believe that the skull may have belonged to a missing union leader. The only problem with that theory is that the skull is further determined to be of an African-American male, but the union leader was white. Meanwhile, a rival union leader tries to intimidate Quincy and the department into stopping the investigation into the disappearance through scare tactics.

To me this was just an OK episode with a few problems. First off, when Monahan (Garry Walberg) presents Quincy with a huge list of names of men missing from the area over the past two years early in the episode, somehow Quincy magically pinpoints the correct person out of hundreds of names with absolutely no evidence yet to narrow it down. How was this possible?? I also found the facial reconstruction part of the plot to be a complete rehash of the story from Season 2's "...The Thigh Bone's Connected to the Knee Bone..." episode which had a very similar premise. Furthermore, I found the idea of a man being blackmailed and embezzling huge sums of money to cover up his racial ancestry which was not even apparent to anyone to be completely ridiculous. Even in 1978 which is when this episode aired, would this have mattered or changed anything in his already established life??

On the positive side, there is a murder mystery featured, but it is not compelling or interesting enough to overcome other flaws.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed