"Murder, She Wrote" The Perfect Foil (TV Episode 1986) Poster

(TV Series)

(1986)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Who Is that Masked Suspect with the Sword of Damsels in Distress?
WeatherViolet19 December 2009
This episode marks the last live-action television acting role by Penny Singleton, who has been acting in film since 1930, and on television since 1950, and continued in voice-over animation for several years to follow.

Cesare Danova, acting since 1945, and Hank Rolike, acting since 1973, have also unfortunately since passed.

After Calhoun "Cal" Fletcher (Peter Bonerz) relocates to New Orleans, Louisiana, he faithfully corresponds with his Aunt Mildred (Penny Singleton), who remains alone with her pet terrier in her comfortable surroundings, but one day realizes that she hasn't heard from Cal in some three or four months.

Aunt Mildred, therefore, notifies Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury) to report her fears that Calhoun may be in some sort of danger. After explaining his relationship as a cousin to Jessica's late husband, Frank, Mildred requests that Jessica swing around to New Orleans to check in on Calhoun during her forthcoming book tour to Houston.

Jesssica arrives in New Orleans amid the hustle and bustle of its celebration of its last evening Mardi Gras Week, or "Fat Tuesday," as costumed revelers fill the streets and halls, as well as hotels at which no reservations are available for her to stay. And so, with the able assistance of Taxi Driver (Hank Rolike), who guides her around the city, she locates the address of a club known as Lafitte Mansion, at which Cal reportedly celebrates the festivities.

Johnny Blaze (George DiCenzo) operates the club given as Calhoun Fletcher's address although he rents a small apartment nearby, which Jessica initially doesn't learn about, as she sorts through costumers, some amicable, some distant, who ignore her requests to point out her cousin-in-law, who is said to be disguised at Cyrano de Bergerac, with the cap, cape and pale mask sporting a protruding proboscis.

Before spotting any such Cyrano de Bergerac, Jessica meets partiers, such as a Costumed Harem Dancer, a Madame Dracula, a Napoleon, a Sir Walter Raleigh, a Roman Catholic Cardinal and a Lady MacBeth, the latter of whom, Rosaline Gardner (Barbara Babcock) sneaks into a drawing room office, and returns passing Jessica, without speaking to her.

After spotting a Cyrano de Bergerac, she call for his attention amid the commotion of the evening, but he ignores her, draws a sword, and enters the office drawing room, as others often begin to notice once the pings of a sword fight escalate from within.

But once the room is unlocked, Jessica enters with a few of the others, to discover a body lying upon its floor, an open window, and no sign of Cyrano de Bergerac.

NOPD Lieutenant Edmund Cavette (Cesare Danova) and NOPD Sergeant Baxter (Morgan Jones) are assigned to the case, as they try to track down Calhoun Fletcher as primary suspect. Lieutenant Cavette's son had previously been murdered by someone obviously associated with this outfit at Lafitte Mansion, which turns out to be a secret gambling operation, and so he is bent upon finding any killers.

Jessica manages to track down Calhoun at his humble apartment by morning light, as he attempts to recover from a hangover and denies staying at the party by the time of Jessica's arrival. She believes him but informs him that he must speak to the police, which proves unfortunate for Calhoun, as Lieutenant Cavette considers him the prime suspect, based upon the testimony of witnesses who report that Cal, as Cyrano, has done it.

Kitty Manette (Lisa Langlois), the fiancée of Calhoun Fletcher, had been in attendance at the party, but offers conflicting testimony, as she has been unfaithful with him, by running around with gambler Gilbert Gaston (Robert Forster), who helps to operate the club.

Attorney Mitch Payne (David Hedison), who has secret dealings with the gambling operation and has previously won a court case to acquit Johnny Blaze of charges in the murder of Eric Cavette, agrees to defend Calhoun Fletcher in similar fashion, or at least to work with Jessica in the process of posting bail.

Jessica tracks down Rosaline Gardner and her husband, Congressman Brad Gardner (Granville Van Dusen), who's up for re-election and has been involved in the gambling operation, a fact which could damage his chances in the polls. She initially denies entering the locked room on the night of the murder, but eventually reveals that she has done so in order to attempt to purchase Brad's gambling IOU's.

Jessica then tries to tie together all of the conflicting testimony to prove Calhoun's innocence, by snooping around the gambling house for additional clues, before gathering the suspects to stage a final showdown for the costumed Cyrano de Bergerac, who has made the hapless Calhoun Fletcher "The Perfect Foil."

The cast is rounded out by Wendy Oates as Costumed Madame Dracula, Raf Mauro as Costumed Napoleon, Guerin Barry as Costumed Sir Walter Raleigh, Richard Brose as Headsman, Sherry McFarland as Receptionist, and Joe Ross as Desk Clerk.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A locked room mystery.
Sleepin_Dragon14 November 2017
Jessica returns to New Orleans, she arrives right in the middle of Mardi Gras, only to discover an error in her hotel booking. With nowhere to stay she goes in search of distant cousin Cal. She arrives at his place to find a fancy dress Party, Cal is said to be in the costume of Cyrano de Bergerac, who is seen entering a room where Johnny Blaze is. Johnny is discovered dead, with the name Cal written in blood beside him, giving Lieutenant Edmund Cavette enough evidence to arrest Cal. Jessica is convinced Cyrano de Bergerac was not Cal.

The story is pretty good, feels similar to the first episode of Murder she wrote 'The Murder of Sherlock Holmes,' death at a fancy dress party, although the format is very different. The episode certainly looks good, some of the costumes are superb, particularly the skeleton, that's fabulous. I loved the ending, it's a very cleverly formed conclusion. The performances on the whole are good, although I found Lisa Langlois (Kitty) a little wooden. A shame the charismatic George DiCenzo (Johnny) got bumped off so soon.

At least they had the decency to make Cal a distant relative, as that family tree is going to get enormous.

Pretty good. 7/10
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Murder during Mardi Gras
TheLittleSongbird1 August 2017
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

While not one of the best episodes of Season 2 or of 'Murder She Wrote', "The Perfect Foil" is still a very solid effort and lots of fun to watch and definitely one of the better New Orleans-set episodes. Certainly not as strange as the still decent previous episode "Menace, Anyone" and the final solution is much easier to follow here and is nowhere near as bizarre.

The supporting cast do fare well and play their parts more than competently and add a good deal of local colour, at the same time only Barbara Babcock and particularly Peter Bonerz stand out. Occasionally the pacing could have been tighter, but actually "The Perfect Foil" has little wrong with it, it just didn't quite bowl me over.

Especially good about "The Perfect Foil" is the Mardi Gras setting and the ending. New Orleans proves to be an attractive setting and is made great use of, even better was the whole Mardi Gras atmosphere, which had so much colour and excitement, and the sheer delight of seeing all those costumes and recognising all the famous characters such as Cyrano De Bergerac and Cardinal Richelieu.

As for the ending, it is a total delight. It's a fairly complicated one, but is also one of the most ingenious and cleverly executed ones of the season.

Production values are high in quality as to be expected, with slick photography. The music has energy and has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune.

The writing is tight, thought-provoking and typically amiable and the characters and chemistry are good fun. The story is very engaging with a great atmosphere.

Can't say enough good about Angela Lansbury, she is always dependable and there is a reason as to why Jessica Fletcher is one of her best-remembered roles.

In conclusion, solid and lots of fun, despite not completely blowing me away. 8/10 Bethany Cox
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Why the rush?
mytwopence9 June 2021
Murder She Wrote should have had two-parters, this episode definitely should've been one - Gorgeous costumes, camera work, lighting and sets - good character work and actors - but rushed and unfinished.

It was an amazing time in television that gave us so many wonderful shows with just the right mix of drama and light heartedness, and with such high production values, but if only they could've known how lacking that sort of thing would be today, they'd have valued it more, given episodes like this one more time, given the story and the characters more time to breathe and develop, and given the audience more time to bathe in the gorgeousness of this episode.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Jessica returns to New Orleans.
planktonrules1 November 2022
In season one of "Murder, She Wrote", Jessica Fletcher spent time in New Orleans and surprisingly (sarcasm intended) someone is murdered. Now, she's returned to the city and guess what? Someone else is murdered!

When the story begins, Jessica's Aunt (Penny Singleton) asks her to stop by New Orleans on her way to Texas. When she arrives, however, it's Mardi Gras AND the hotel has lost her reservation...so she goes to visit one of her husband's relatives to perhaps spend the night there. However, it turns out Cal Fletcher (Peter Bonerz) is having a huge costume party at his house and Jessica is having a hard time finding him. Later, she thinks she sees him, though nearly everyone is wearing masks, and then this person enters a room and ends up killing someone...someone who Cal would have plenty of motives for killing. But Calhoun insists he wasn't at the party and didn't kill anyone. What's really happening?

The big twist is easy to figure out...as anyone could have pretended to be Cal since they were masked at the party. But who and why? That's for Jessica to determine.

This is a decent episode and is enjoyable to watch. However, like the previous New Orleans episode, it was filmed no where near Louisiana. A few times it's easy to tell...other times it looks much like the actual French Quarter of New Orleans. Not a great episode but worth seeing.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Perfect Foil
coltras3522 August 2023
Jessica goes to New Orleans to check on a distant cousin during Mardi Gras. Upon arriving at Cal's rooming house to fulfil the aunt's request, she finds a party in full swing, a party-goer (a crooked gambler) murdered, and Cal being the prime suspect, mainly because he had accused the victim of cheating and in front of fellow poker players said he will kill him. Despite not knowing her distant cousin that well, Jessica sets out to prove the man's innocence and find the real killer.

New Orleans, Mardi Gras, a costume party, a locked room and a dead body inside equals an excellent episode. It's very focused with a fine milieu of suspects, which includes the detective whose son had died at the hands of the victim and the victim had got away with it. The gathering of the suspects at the end, Jessica explaining what really happened is a classic mystery touch.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Way Down Yonder in New Orleans
bkoganbing29 March 2018
Whether on her side or on her husband's side widow Jessica Fletcher never seems to run out of relatives. When one of the late Frank Fletcher's cousins reports that another cousin has not been heard from in a bit, Angela Lansbury goes to New Orleans to investigate why no one has heard from Peter Bonerz.

She arrives just as Mardi Gras in full swing and among a crowd of revelers is there when someone in a Cyrano DeBergerac costume murders gambling kingpin George DiCenzo.

Given his profession DiCenzo could and did make enemies. Even the New Orleans homicide cop Cesare Danova is suspect.

A slight slip up in a gather the suspects scene makes the case for Jessica Fletcher. I think you'll enjoy this one.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed