"Murder, She Wrote" Family Doctor (TV Episode 1991) Poster

(TV Series)

(1991)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Brother, Can You Spare these Kidnapping Victims?
WeatherViolet31 January 2010
This episode marks the final appearance by Tige Andrews, actor, artist and singer, who began his film and television career in 1951, while continuing his stage performances, although here Tige appears somewhat unrecognizable from his "Mod Squad" (1968-73) days, he now portraying the patriarch of a crime syndicate family.

This also represents William Windom's only "MSW" Seventh Season appearance, as he takes leave from his Doctor Seth Hazlitt recurring role to star in the Sitcom "Parenthood" (1990) as Frank Buckman. As a result, Season Seven's five Cabot Cove episodes are presented without Seth. But here, in the first "MSW" episode broadcast of January of 1991, Jessica and Seth take a mid-season excursion into Boston....

In the frequent "MSW" stop-over city of Boston, Massachusetts, mobster Carmine Abruzzi (Tige Andrews) meets with two of his henchmen in a parking garage, before a rival syndicate clobbers his thugs and whisks Carmine to points unknown in a limousine, thus generating tabloid headlines, "Where Is Carmine Abruzzi?" These are seen on a Boston sidewalk, upon which Doctor Seth Hazlitt (William Windom) and Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury) during an afternoon outing.

Seth decides to make dinner reservations at "Clams & Claws," a mutually favorite dining spot, when Jessica challenges Seth to make the call. To her surprise, he manages reservations by announcing his "doctor" title, and off they go to face Maître d' Freddie (Robert Costanzo), who seats them, before turning to face prominent Attorney Andrew Gant (Monte Markham), who tells Freddie that his party is waiting in the rear dining room.

This series tends to flatter ethnic characters, by escalating those from many a background into successful role model types; however, on more than one occasion, "MSW" screenwriters seem to begrudge characters of Italian-American descent as stereotypical crime syndicate types, and "Family Doctor" presents itself into evidence as Defense exhibit "C" or "D" thus far into the series. But there are also other ethnic stereotypes perpetuated as manipulative along the way, such as characters of Russian and certain Oriental descents.

Anyhow, Andrew Gant serves as counselor for the Abruzzi family, as matriarch Rosa Abruzzi (Rose Gregorio) attends the gathering with her and Carmine's sons, the responsible Michael Abruzzi (Vincent Irizarry) and the irresponsible Salvatore Abruzzi (David Ciminello).

Salvatore attends with his fiancée, the fiery haired and fiery tempered Connie Canzinaro (Amy Yasbeck), while Michael attends with his expectant wife, Denise Abruzzi (Cynthia Bain), who pleads with him to leave the syndicate before the baby comes along.

Spoiled wealthy Phyllis Gant (Diane Franklin), daughter of Andrew, enters the restaurant in a drunken stupor to cause a scene with the waitress and Freddie, across from Jessica and Seth's table, when she vows revenge upon being bounced through the doorway.

Carmine Abruzzi enters through the alley to meet with his family, and to announce his plans to retire from the mob, and to take a long vacation in Italy with Rosa, and to hand the reigns of power over to Michael, this to the objections of Denise and Salvatore, as well as to Michael's goal of leaving crime behind to forge a legitimate operation, which also conflicts with Andrew's objectives to join forces with rival syndicates.

But outdoors in the darkened alley, as the family exits into the night, a perched assassin fires a shot, felling a victim, who cannot be treated in a hospital. So Freddie is summoned to abduct the proverbial "doctor in the house," who, of course, turns out to be Seth.

When Seth does not return to the table after forty minutes, Jessica demands an explanation from Freddie, who claims to know nothing, and so she turns to the Boston Police Department, at which she is given another run-around, until the self-assured Lieutenant Jerry Marino (Joseph Cortese) steps to the plate to make the rounds with Jessica.

When Jessica discovers blood upon the carpet near the rear office of "Clam & Claw" Restaurant, Lieutenant Marino tells Freddie to open the rear dining room. When Freddie tells Lieutenant Marino that he has no warrant, Jerry answers, "If I need a warrant, then you are really going to be in trouble, pal."

After police officers discover Seth along a Boston street hours later, and reunite him with Jessica back at the station, Jerry advises them to stay overnight, so that he would send for them in the morning, but Joey (uncredited actor) beats the police to the punch and abducts Jessica and Seth, delivering them to the Abruzzi hideaway at Gant's country estate, at which the patient has not survived the night, and so they blame Seth.

Jessica, demanding an explanation from Michael, who answers the door, surprised to see Seth again, informs the two that he has no intention of kidnapping them, but others in the house disagree, while screams are heard upstairs from Connie, who searches for a room for Denise, but discovers Phyllis in a compromising position with her Salvatore.

Lieutenant Marino joins forces with Agent Misch (William Utay) and Agent Zweiback (Newell Alexander) to piece together clues from Seth's interview the night before, while Jessica figures a way to contact them, after figuring who hired the assassin, injected the victim with an overdose, and then turned around and murdered the assassin for not doing it right the first time around, thereby necessitating the need for a "Family Doctor."

The cast is rounded out by Howard George as Desk Sergeant, Linda Larkin as Waitress, Randall James Jeffries as Bellhop, Michael Blue as Policeman #1, and Jay Hill as Policeman #2.

This episode reflects the first television role for Linda Larkin, as well as the most recent appearances by Michael Blue and Jay Hill.

This represents the first of two "MSW" roles each for David Ciminello and Randall James Jeffries, the second of two for Michael Blue, the second of three for Robert Costanzo, and the third of four "MSW" guest starring roles for Monte Markham.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
An offer she can't refuse.
Sleepin_Dragon27 November 2022
Jessica and Seth enjoy a fine meal at a restaurant, before Seth is called away to attend to a patient, a patient that is part of The Mob.

It has a definite Italian flavour, there is passion, there are gangsters, brown eyed beauties, and hunky, smouldering guys, yes Murder she wrote did an episode that seemed to be very loosely based on The Godfather.

It seems like an age since we last saw Seth, and for that reason I was really looking forward to this episode, sadly I was a little disappointed, the mystery itself was appealing enough, but elements of this one felt overdone, I didn't think Seth was given the best of returns, and some of the acting was a bit questionable to say the least, The Detective was way too over the top. They were guilty of over egging the pudding so to speak.

Watchable enough, but way too over the top, 6/10.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Jessica, Seth and the mob
TheLittleSongbird14 October 2017
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

"Family Doctor" is most notable for being the only Season 7 episode to feature fan favourite Seth Hazlitt, and while it is a perfectly watchable episode Seth deserved much better. He is one of the best recurring characters on 'Murder She Wrote', being one of the most entertaining and interesting, and has featured in good to classic episodes. While "Family Doctor" does nothing to disgrace Seth, it was a case of a great character (with another great character in Jessica) stuck in a less than great story.

The weakest part of "Family Doctor" is the ending. Neither the identity of the killer or the motive rang true or are shocking, very far-fetched and ordinary for a killing within a mob family. More of a problem was how they were caught and found out, too over-reliant on easy to disprove coincidence and through very clunky exposition. The story mostly is actually pretty entertaining and well-paced though ridiculously unrealistic, lifted by the cast and the ever sparkling chemistry between Jessica and Seth.

On the other hand, story-wise it's also somewhat unbalanced. A little too much time was devoted to Seth and Jessica's situation and the crime was not only not focused on enough in my view but it was also introduced too late. The easily offended will find that the less than flattering stereotypes won't bode well with them.

Conversely, Angela Lansbury and William Windom are both terrific and supported very well by particularly Monte Markham, fiery Amy Yasbeck and Diane Franklin. Joe Cortese also relishes one of the episode's best lines regarding a warrant.

Production values as always are slick and stylish with some nostalgia induced. The music has energy and has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune. The writing is thoughtful and amiable mostly apart from the clunkiness at the end.

Overall, above average episode but Seth and 'Murder She Wrote' deserved better with a more consistent story and a much better ending. 6/10 Bethany Cox
5 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Family doctor
coltras3517 August 2023
A quiet dinner out for Seth and Jessica ends abruptly when he is forced to care for injured Mafia kingpin Carmine Abruzzi. When the latter dies, his son holds Seth responsible and has he and Jessica kidnapped, although the Cabot Cove sleuth ultimately demonstrates who really is the culprit.

The denouement is a little too easy, the killer unravelling is based on coincidence and it's sort of weak reasoning, however the rest of the story is good, with enough drama, tantrums and passion running through the dysfunctional Mob family. It's well acted by all, and it's rarity to have Dr Seth and Jessica together outside Cabot Cove.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Godfather Wannabe episode fails miserably.
Somesweetkid17 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Usually any MSW episode featuring Jessica and Dr. Hazlitt is a pleasantly entertaining passage of 45-plus minutes. William Windom always added a touch of class and intelligence to the roles he played, whether in motion pictures or in television.

However, his and Jessica's camaraderie in this particular episode couldn't save this Godfather ripoff. Even the Don's two sons were named Michael (the level-headed married son who was going to take over the garment business upon his father leaving the country) and hot-tempered Salvador (similar to hot-headed Sonny played by James Caan), who has the red-headed floozy-ish girlfriend.

Additionally, as the Don is leaving the restaurant with his wife and two sons to get into his vehicle (to head out of the country), stereotypical Italian Mafia-type background music starts to play.

Finally, unlike the excellent Columbo series before this, many of the MSW episodes feature monumental overacting like the annoying Consiglieri's daughter causing an uproar in the restaurant as Jessica and Dr. Hazlitt chow down on their much-anticipated lobster feast.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
JB Fletcher meets The Godfather
bkoganbing30 January 2018
This Murder She Wrote story involves Angela Lansbury and William Windom in Boston for a weekend and Dr. Hazlitt insists on going to a favorite seafood restaurant he's patronized for decades. It's under new management though and when Tige Andrews the local Godfather who now indirectly runs the place is shot, they note that the reservations included a doctor. So William Windom is summoned to treat a shot Tige Andrews.

Unfortunately he leaves poor Angela Lansbury alone and she calls in the Boston PD. Later Andrews dies and the children blame William Windom for the demise.

I was not crazy about the ending at all. No way in the world would this have happened in real life.

Not one of the better stories.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Weak...really weak.
planktonrules18 January 2023
Jessica and her friend, the Doctor, are in Boston and go out for a nice dinner at one of the Doc's favorite restaurants. But the place has completely changed...and now it's run by mobsters! The pair don't know this but the Doc soon learns when he's kidnapped and forced to operate on a mob boss who has been shot. While the mobsters end up letting Dr. Hazlitt go, this isn't the end of their problems as the mob chief soon dies and they blame Hazlitt for this. Can Jessica sort this out before the pair are fitted for cement shoes?!

Apart from having the mobsters yelling all the time and with little provocation, the first 80% of the show is quite good. However, the solution as to who did it and why...well, it makes no sense...especially when the killer freely admits to the crime! This very weak ending really harms the show and I can't help but think it could have been much better.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Poor plot made worse with blatant Italian stereotypes
FlushingCaps10 March 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Jessica and Seth are visiting Boston and before going home, they want to dine at Clams and Claws, Seth's favorite Boston eatery, which he loves because they haven't changed anything in 75 years. Using his "doctor" title on the phone, Seth gets them a reservation.

When they get there, everything has changed-the wall paneling, the maitre d' and the owners. They have also hired a nitwit for a waitress, who had, I think, the only line in the episode designed to be funny. The food is still good but before dessert, Seth is told that he is wanted on the phone for some medical emergency.

Other scenes have introduced us to the Abruzzi crime family, where the head, Carmine (Mod Squad's Tige Andrews) is about to head for Italy to prevent a long prison term, and turns control over to his son Michael, much to the distress of his brother Sal. After dinner, while talking to his sons behind the restaurant, Carmine is gunned down by someone on a rooftop.

This led to Seth being called to the phone-of course, he was instead taken to a suburban mansion to treat the wounded Carmine. He is later released on the streets of Boston and not long after, we learn that Carmine has suddenly died and Sal blames Dr. Hazlitt and wants to go kill him.

The police insist that Jessica and Seth stay overnight instead of going home as planned, because the FBI wants to question them in the morning. They do, with arrangements to be picked up at 8:30 outside their hotel. They emerge from the hotel two minutes before they are to be picked up when Seth suddenly remembers leaving his medical bag in the coffee shop. He goes back to get it and a limo pulls up. The two men we have seen as heavies for Carmine are there. Jessica assumes they are the FBI men without them saying a thing, and she is getting into the car when Seth emerges, telling her that's the wrong car. At gunpoint, the pair are ordered into the car and taken back to the mansion, where Michael is stunned to learn that his brother had them kidnapped and brought there.

Sal explains but the brothers agree they pose a problem. Seth gets permission to examine the body to see what caused his death. Jessica, left alone briefly, phones 911 to report everything but is caught before she can tell all. This now means she and Seth are almost surely to be killed.

It seemed fairly obvious that most of the people in this episode could/would not have wanted Carmine dead, leaving such a tiny group of suspects that it would be hard to imagine many viewers claiming they did not figure out who the killer was-even though you wouldn't have suspected that person initially.

One IMDB reviewer incorrectly claimed that Carmine was meeting with henchmen when a rival syndicate clobbers his "thugs and whisks" him away. Not quite. He was clearly being questioned by police who were to transport him to a jail when Carmine's thugs rescued him.

I have one big beef with the shooting scene. Nobody knew Carmine was going to stand in the alley and talk for about two minutes before getting into his limo that night. Yet the hit man with his rifle poised, for reasons that make no sense, stood and watched as Carmine talked that long before finally taking a shot at the man-and wounding him instead of killing him, when a few quick shots from his "automatic" would likely have guaranteed success.

It also made no sense that Carmine didn't clear that private dining room and talk there, or in the hallway. Or get into the car with the sons and talk to them there. Standing in the alley for a couple of minutes after going to all the trouble to slip into the restaurant without being seen also makes no sense for a big-time mobster the police are seeking.

I thought it was a wonderfully lucky coincidence for the gangsters who kidnapped Seth and Jess that the FBI guys were not already there waiting when they emerged from the hotel. That limo with the bad guys only pulled up about two minutes before the FBI guys were to be there.

I don't even think it made sense for them to take Jessica along with them. That only involved someone else when they could have left her behind unable to prevent them from taking Seth away.

The "confession" at the end was also rather weak, with a rather weak reason for the killing, but I won't get into those details because it would totally spoil any fun a reader here might have with the story.

The biggest complaint is how EVERY Italian mafia stereotype you've ever seen is in this story. Now late last season there was an episode set in Italy that also featured mobster-types which was also full of stereotypes. If this series had two episodes featuring any other sort of ethnic or racial group that so heavily depicted everyone in a stereotypical fashion the howls of protests would have gotten it taken off the air before the season was over.

I think the same story without any stereotypes would not generate a score higher than 4 from me, but the total has to deduct for these offensive depictions, making it seem like all Italians are connected with organized crime. That leaves me with no choice but to give it a one.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed