A woman turns in her outlaw husband she says "for the reward." When Troop finds out the real reason, it may be too late to save himself or the town from a bloodbath.
Donna Killmer is kidnapped by her brother-in-law's gang. Al Kilmer wants her to turn her severely wounded husband Joe in to the law for medical care and the reward which he wants for supplies. Donna dislikes Al but to save Joe goes along. Troop detects something is wrong and tries to persuade Donna to tell him the truth but Al's threats prevent her from talking. Lily persuades her to go see Joe before the trial which is when Al plans to break Joe free. After the meeting Donna tells Troop the truth and Joe decides to help Troop and McKay fight his brother as they walk Joe to the courthouse.—Anonymous