Judge Denise Grobman is shot and seriously wounded when a man steals her car. Yet when investigation leads to a hired hit ordered by her husband, she vehemently refuses to believe in his guilt.



(created by), (teleplay by) | 1 more credit »


Add Image Add an image

Do you have any images for this title?



Episode cast overview, first billed only:
... Lennie Briscoe
... Ed Green
... Anita Van Buren
... Jack McCoy
... Abbie Carmichael
... Adam Schiff
... Judge Denise Grobman
... Dana Grobman
Sam Groom ... Claymore
... Mitchell Brizzard
Charlotte Colavin ... Judge Lisa Pongracic
... Dr. Emil Skoda
... Walter Grobman
... Detective Morris LaMotte
DeAnn Mears ... Judge Maria Gance


Detectives Lennie Briscoe and Ed Green investigate the attempted murder of a prominent and highly respected judge, Denise Grobman. She was shot in her car having come home early and the evidence quickly points to her husband Walter as the man behind the killing. He has an alibi but McCoy is convinced he hired someone to make the hit as he was the only person who knew she would be where she was at the time of the shooting. Judge Grobman proves to be the major stumbling block however refusing to believe that her architect husband could do such a thing. McCoy realizes that she is key to ever getting a conviction but has to face Judge Grobman's decision to refuse further medical treatment - both her kidneys have failed and she is in constant pain - meaning she would die before the case could be concluded. Written by garykmcd

Plot Summary | Add Synopsis





Release Date:

6 October 1999 (USA)  »

Filming Locations:

Company Credits

Show more on  »

Technical Specs


Sound Mix:


Aspect Ratio:

1.78 : 1
See  »

Did You Know?


[All trivia items for this title are spoilers.] See more »


Det. Lennie Briscoe: You got no record. Why do you want to do this the hard way?
Det. Ed Green: Nice leather upholstery. Cleans up pretty good, but not good enough.
Dr. Matthew Carton: What's that mean?
Det. Ed Green: Blood in the seams. You read the papers?
Det. Lennie Briscoe: A New York state judge was shot over this car. You can probably figure out what that means for you.
See more »


Remade as Law & Order: UK: Denial (2010) See more »

Frequently Asked Questions

This FAQ is empty. Add the first question.

User Reviews

The right to die, the right to lie ...
20 March 2016 | by See all my reviews

... to oneself, that is. Judge Denise Grobman (Lindsay Crouse) is shot when her car is stolen as she is returning from a weekend in the country. She is badly injured but not killed, plus she has a concealed carry permit and returns fire with the thief, who escapes but is presumed badly injured. But then detectives Lennie Briscoe and Ed Green begin their investigation and discover that a car thief could have easily lifted an expensive model in the same garage right next to the judge's car, because the owner always left the keys in it (he was always forgetting where he put them, so he left them in the ignition). Oh the eccentricity of the one percent, but that's another story.

Our able observant detectives follow the trail of the stolen car back to (eventually) the body of the car thief, dead from the judge's bullets. Large sums of money are found on him, showing that this might have been a hit. However, the judge came back early from her country house that Sunday, in response to a phone call from her assistant. Only three people knew about that call - the assistant, the judge, and the judge's husband of 27 years. More investigation is done. The husband (John Heard as Walter Grobman) doesn't play the field, doesn't gamble, in fact has no vices at all. But EVERYTHING points to him, including a half hour of time when he was out of the judge's company jogging, coinciding with a call made from a pay phone in the same town to the dead hit-man.

The judge will live - I guess I should say exist - through the shooting according to her doctors. However, she is in horrible pain, a paraplegic, on dialysis with one kidney removed and the other ruined. Plus she now needs a colostomy bag and will need round the clock nursing care for the rest of her life. When presented with all of the evidence, she still professes her husband's innocence and her willingness to testify on his behalf, but now she has a new request, she requests the right to discontinue dialysis and die.

So now the criminal justice system AND her husband are involved in a flurry of legal activity about this woman's right to die, none of it really being about her best interest. Did her husband do it, or was it somebody who had a grudge against the judge who happened to be watching her? Watch and find out. Sometimes Law and Order plays out just like you think it is going to, sometimes not, usually at the last minute.

6 of 7 people found this review helpful.  Was this review helpful to you? | Report this
Review this title | See all 3 user reviews »

Contribute to This Page

Stream Action and Adventure Titles With Prime Video

Explore popular action and adventure titles available to stream with Prime Video.

Start your free trial