"Gunsmoke" Love of a Good Woman (TV Episode 1959) Poster

(TV Series)

(1959)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Even with a bizarre gunfight scene, Matt plays a softy in this nice episode
kfo94941 August 2013
In this episode we get a nice story about the love of a woman and a man finding that there is more to life than revenge. But then we also get some downright confusing scene that was just placed in the show to get the viewers some action to tie them over for another week. This story was strong enough without resorting to useless action that had nothing to do with the nicely written script.

Two visitors comes to Dodge. Abbie Twilling, a woman that use to be Doc Adams' nurse in the war and Coney Thorne that has just been release from an Arizona Territorial Jail and wants vengeance on the man who arrested him which happens to be Marshal Dillon. The two are strangers but when Thorne comes down with a 'brain fever', Doc suggest that Abbie move to a nearby room to keep a check on the ailing and feverish Thorne.

Matt has even been told by Thorne that he is in Dodge to kill him so the Marshal is on his toes. But everything seems settled when Marshal get a telegram from Arizona advising that Thorne has violated his parole. Now Matt has reason to arrest and send Thorne back to jail. But something has happened. Abbie and Thorne have developed a relationship that just may change the entire mindset of all parties involved.

As a person that is not fond of this type of tale, this episode proved to be strong enough, on its own merit, to support a well crafted story into a nice show. Even with the ridiculous violence thrown in for unknown reasons, the story was still uplifting to make for entertaining program. Good watch.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Good Deed
darbski8 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** A nice episode with an unexplained gunfight thrown in (probably to keep us bloodthirsty kiddies satisfied); supposedly the punk wanted to "Get" a lawman. Well, we know how far that goes with Matt Dillon, who isn't bothered a bit by it. The guy who was gonna gun him down? Matt lets him and his new lady get off and away when the fellow says he no longer hates Matt.

Now, about the Chauvinism and women. This is an issue that can occupy volumes in an already overloaded library. Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman aside, and Doc would've surely known this; the ONLY woman ever to be awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor was one Mary Edwards Walker, for her bravery and service in our Civil War. SHE was a doctor of medicine, (Syracuse Medical College), and a surgeon. Tough as they come.
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Average Entry
dougdoepke17 June 2012
Dissatisfied with her life in the east, Doc's former nurse Abby (Scott) shows up in Dodge, renewing her friendship with Doc. Okay. But then a vengeance-seeking ex-con Konie (Hagen) arrives looking for Matt who sent him up five years earlier. Now Matt has to watch his back, that is, until he gets a telegram stating that Konie's broken parole. Now there's going to be a showdown, or is there.

Good involving plot, except the gunman (Fancher) episode seems an awkward action device that intrudes on an otherwise interesting dilemma for Matt. The story comes from series inspiration John Meston and carries two of his earmarks. Note the subtext having to do with the plight of women in the chauvinistic male world of the frontier. It's implied by both Abby and Kitty. Also, Meston works in a number of references to his hometown of Pueblo, CO, which is not far mileage-wise from Dodge, which may help explain his exceptional feel for the series material.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
When Does A Woman in Love Make Sense
jamdifo25 August 2013
Warning: Spoilers
That was the best quote in the episode said by Dillon when he realized nurse Abbie (played by Jacqueline Scott) was in love with Coney Thorne (played by Kevin Fagen, best known as Doc Baker on Little House on the Prairie). The episode had its twists and turns. At first you find out Abbie comes to see Doc, since they worked so well together back in the Civil War. Doc highly respects her and it looks like they might get together, but it never happens. Then Coney comes to town after being released from prison to get revenge against Dillon. So you feel this will end in a gunfight between the 2, but that never happens.

What does happen is very bizarre. Dillon and Chester go to the stable because Chester said he saw Coney lurking around there. Sure enough, Dillon with his gun smartly already drawn searching the stable gets shot at. Dillon kills the shooter, but its not Coney, its some unknown person that no one in Dodge knows played by Hampton Fancher. Its Dillon's 74th confirmed kill.

The gunman stated he was just looking for a lawman. What I don't get is why Dillon never suspected Coney hiring someone to shoot him. Chester did swear he saw Coney around the stable. Instead, Dillon wishes Abbie and Coney well as they go back to Arizona to get married (at Pueblo Springs). Dillon can be so smart noticing love but clueless to think someone could hire to kill him. Very strange ending.
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed