(1904)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Primitive Origins of Film Grammar
boblipton11 July 2018
It's another film by Mr. Collins that seems pretty muddled. A man comes home to find an officer assaulting his wife. He is arrested -- the wronged man -- and returns home, but the police are on his trail. His wife and child are killed, but he flees. In the chase, he throws several officers over a cliff and finally tracks down the cause of his woes.

It's pretty heady stuff, carried out at such a breakneck pace that it's often hard to figure out what's going on. Director Alf Collins, during his decade of directing movies, was accounted an expert in chases, and that's what this movie largely consists of. Its melodramatic plot has been writ much larger and at greater length as movies have expanded to feature length, and his cutting from one scene to the next is poor to the modern eye. Quite clearly, he has no talent for the rhythms of such operations, or -- if I wish to be charitable -- his rhythms are alien to the modern eye, washed away in the sea changes established by D. W. Griffith's regularization of film grammar beginning four years later. Yet we can see their primitive origins here.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Action-Packed But Quite Muddled
Snow Leopard15 September 2005
There's quite a bit of action in this short drama, but much of it is muddled, and it's distracting to have to try to figure out what is going on while also keeping up with the action at the same time. It's watchable if you are interested in the techniques and material of early narrative features, but it mostly serves as something of an example of the ways that many early film-makers had to develop their story-telling techniques from hard-gained experience.

The story follows an involved altercation that starts between a husband and an interloper who is on affectionate terms with the first man's wife. This paramour is in uniform, and he has several uniformed friends who join in the conflict, but it's never quite made definite whether they are from the police or from a sanitarium of some kind. Some aspects of the situation become a little clearer after watching it two or three times, but even then there are some things that remain uncertain.

This is one of a group of British features of the era that were originally based on actual incidents that had aroused some degree of public concern, and there is probably a very interesting story behind the events in this short movie. It may have been much clearer to its original audiences, and it's also possible that someone very patient and observant might still be able to piece together even more of the details after some careful viewings.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed