User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
"They tell me it's 1936"
ackstasis5 December 2008
It's really difficult to rate a film like this. While this earlier amateur sound film has no artistic aspirations whatsoever, it is nonetheless a genuinely fascinating time capsule. This 4-minute snippet of the life of an ordinary American family comes without the sparkle and artificiality of a Hollywood movie of the same era – though, of course, what goes on here in front of the camera is obviously staged for the camera's benefit. Archie Stewart (1902-1998), a New york car dealer, was one of the most enthusiastic amateur filmmakers of the early sound era, and he purchased his first sound home-movie camera around Christmas 1935, using it to periodically document the lives of his two young daughters, Mary and Anne. The technology to capture synchronised sound, which was optically recorded onto the edge of the film, was advanced for its time, and would remain rare among amateur filmmakers for decades. Stewart was an active member of the Amateur Cinema League, and in his lifetime amassed more than 70,000 feet of 16mm film.

'Early Amateur Sound Film (1937)' is just a brief selection of footage from Stewart's extensive archives at Northeast Historic Film. The first sequence takes place on January 26, 1935 (or so says Stewart; it's actually 1936), one week after a particularly heavy snowfall. He photographs his children playing in the snow (one is Mary, and the other is called George). In the next sequence, Stewart is surprised with a birthday cake by his daughters, and they sing him "Happy Birthday" in a manner sounds no different from every modern birthday party you've ever attended. Stewart's wife is probably the person filming; she remains unseen, but is apparently offered the privilege of cutting the cake. What follows is two reading lessons with the youngest daughter, Anne, filmed one year apart (the first story is called "The Little Brownie," but I didn't catch the second one). Then the two daughters amuse themselves, as many girls like to do, by dressing up the unfortunate dog, Pat, and treating him to a tea party.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A real early home SOUND movie.
planktonrules4 October 2011
This is a very ephemeral sort of film--the sort you'd never expect to see on a DVD. That's because it's part of a collection of films of its type from American Film Archives. Most are not of much interest to anyone but historians and cinemaniacs (like me).

This film consists of various clips strung together. They were from home movies made by Archie Stewart--some guy who got in EARLY in the home video game--getting a 16mm sound system back in 1935. Considering folks were generally using silent 8mm systems up through the 1960s and 70s, it really is amazing how early these clips of Stewart's family are. The only problem is that since the viewer has no idea who any of these folks are, it's only of historical interest--more so than most of the DVD collection. The sound quality is only fair. It's easy to hear Stewart (as he's holding the equipment) but the kids are often tough to fully understand. But, considering that professional sound was still rather new, this is an amazing film--but also one you can't really rate on IMDb due to the type of film it is.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed