"Great Performances" The Nutcracker (TV Episode 2001) Poster

(TV Series)

(2001)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A festive ballet treat!
TheLittleSongbird31 August 2012
The Nutcracker has always been one of my favourite ballets, the story is enthralling, magical and touching and Tchaikovsky's music is some of his most exquisite. This Royal Ballet production is a treat, whether it is as good as Kirov's production I am not sure but I put it on the same level as Baryschnikov's and leagues better than the self-indulgent Maurice Bejart Nutcracker. There are only two things that I personally would have done differently. Dance of the Snowflakes while beautifully danced would have been better without Clara and the Prince weaving in and out, and while having Clara joining in with the Act 2 dances worked well mostly, there was one dance that didn't for me, which was Dance of the Flutes, her inclusion as well as it was performed took away from the symmetry of the Flautists' dancing.

However, the production values are wonderful, one of the better-looking Nutcracker productions I've seen actually. The sets are colourful and the costumes likewise. The outstanding video directing also helps wonders, it captures the dancing bang on and the close-ups are at a good number and don't feel in-your-face. The story is timeless, and you do feel that sense of magic and Christmas spirit that you ought to. Musically, the production is also marvellous, the orchestral playing sparkles and the conducting while sometimes slow in tempo has a lot of nuances and poetry which the score does need. The dancing is intricate in choreography and graceful in how it is danced, especially in the Pas-De-Deux. Anthony Dowell is a commanding Drossemeyer, I liked how he flicks his cape like a matador and his magic tricks. Alina Cojocaru's Clara is positively charming and Miyako Yoshida dances the Sugar Plum Fairy with such poise and grace. Ivan Putrov and Jonathan Cope are appropriately masculine and handsome.

Overall, a real festive treat of a ballet production. 9/10 Bethany Cox
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Generally standard (some mild spoiler.)
standardmetal25 December 2002
I am not a real ballet fan and find classical ballets rather risible in general. But I do like the music of this one which I thought was not well served in this and many other cases. Dancers are notorious for complaining about the music being too fast with the result that it all moves along at a pedestrian pace. (It's even slower in some Russian versions I've seen and I think this was partly what Balanchine was fighting against in all his work.)

Anthony Dowell, the then-director of the Royal Ballet, really hams it up in his largely mime part of Drosselmeier and I thought the homo-erotic relationship (?) of Drosselmeier and his nephew Hans-Peter served no particular purpose aside from reflecting Tchaikovsky's with his nephew "Bob" (Vladimir Davydov.).

I think the Pacific Ballet's version is more interesting as is the Paris Opera Ballet's (Nureyev.). (I never particularly liked the Baryshnikov one.)

I found the dancing serviceable if uninspired, but way too slow!!!

Perhaps the dancers would have rather done another ballet as this one has perhaps been done too often.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Disappointed
peggy_0303725 December 2003
While I normally love this, and most ballets for that matter, I hated this production. The music was so slow that you just felt like putting it on fast-forward, and the dancing was only less ponderous. The scenery wasn't bad but it wouldn't make you want to see this again. Definitely don't recommend this one.
3 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed