"Carnets d'ado" Grosse bêtise (TV Episode 2001) Poster

(TV Series)

(2001)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Filial Love and Adolescent Obsession
gradyharp4 June 2005
Warning: Spoilers
'Grosse bêtise' or BREAKIN' OUT is another example of how well French films deal with intimate subjects, taking the time to explore emotional attitudes that so often are ignored by Hollywood films. In this case the extent that true filial love can lead to dangerous consequences is played out in a story that is well written (Stanislas Carré de Malberg and Pascal Dupont), well directed (Olivier Péray), and well acted by a fine cast.

Nicolas Guérin (Erwan Demaure) is 13-year-old happy son of Laetitia (Isabelle Habiague) and Thierry Guérin who make their living selling drugs. In the first moments of the film the mother and father are in a car accident, killing the father and resulting in the arrest and imprisonment of the mother for drug trafficking. Nicolas is devastated and immediately begins to think of ways to restore his mother. He is placed in a warm and loving foster home of the Delmas (Christian Crahay and Nathalie Willame) and their adolescent daughter Elodie (Stéphane Caillard). He is treated well until he enters school where he encounters pier mocking about his mother being a jailbird. One young friend Tanker (Ouassini Embarek), whose own father in jailed for a history of being a gangster, befriends him and quickly becomes a caring confidant and facilitator.

The two lads form a warm friendship and begin to devise ways for Nicolas' mother's escape. Eventually Elodie becomes involved and the three plan a fake funeral for Nicolas because that is the only way his mother could be temporarily released from prison - to attend her son's funeral! The plans are complex and the results of the scheme are driven to the extreme with a surprise ending that involves a fruitless run for the border. The manner in which filial devotion affects each of the film's characters draws some touching conclusions.

Though the film at first appears to condone some anti-social behavior, the sensitivity of the director keeps realistic reins on the story. In the end this is a fine little film about family and friendship and the benefits and obligations of both. Grady Harp
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An original and quirky drama
KobusAdAstra9 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Nicholas Guérin's parents are involved with small-scale drug dealing. During a police chase his father crashes his car, killing himself and landing his wife in jail. Thirteen year old Nicholas (Erwan Demaure) gets placed with foster parents, the Delmas family (Christian Crahay and Nathalie Willame), a really nice couple who go out of their way to accommodate the boy. Their daughter Elodie (Stéphane Caillard) is unfortunately the opposite, and quite bitchy.

Nicholas visits his mother Laetitia (Isabelle Habiague) in jail and learns that she may be sentenced to 5 years imprisonment. A very long time by the boy's reckoning. He starts to think of ways to get his mother out of jail. At the jail he meets an older lad, Tanker (Ouassini Embarek), whose father, a gangster, is also imprisoned. The two boys become friends. It looks as if Tanker is a bad influence on Nicholas; they go shop-lifting, although Nicholas has enough money to buy the items. At school Nicholas gets taunted for his mother being in jail and even assaulted by a bully. Tanker comes to his rescue. Nicholas invites Tanker to his 'new' home, where Tanker seems to take a liking to Elodie.

Nicholas is seriously hatching a plan to get his mother escape jail. He decides he will fake his death and at his 'funeral' overwhelm the prison guards who are with his mother, and make a run for it. For 'his' body he will unearth the corpse of another person who died recently, and burn it unrecognizable. He shares his plan with an enthusiastic Tanker. Elodie, who fortunately has become more friendly, hears about their plans and asks to join them. Nicholas reluctantly agrees. They don't have much choice; either that or she spills the beans. She turns out to be quite valuable with practical suggestions. There are a lot to be arranged: a corpse, a get-away car, a gun…

'Breakin' Out' is a delightful film full of unexpected twists and turns. The acting by Nicholas, Tanker and Elodie is quite good, but unfortunately the casting of Nicholas is somewhat off the mark. Instead of a vulnerable thirteen year old, we get a streetwise guy who looks sixteen, and that reduces the impact of the film. The script is lively and that is one of the film's strong points. The sound track and cinematography are above average too. There are a few minor plot-holes which the observant viewer may pick up, but they are pretty insignificant. I still score this entertaining film a very good 7.5/10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed