My Dinner with Jimi (2003) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
11 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Unintentionally Sad
nafps19 March 2022
How sad that after being one of the better known groups of the time and having hits, the most interesting thing in your life was meeting other famous people.

Time has not been kind to the band. All the other bands in the film are well remembered, constantly played, numerous bios and documentaries, thought of as long lasting art. The Turtles get brief mentions, seem almost one hit wonders though they were not.

There were some amusing moments that are familiar from other films. The whole trope about young band overwhelmed by first taste of fame. But it's been done many times, and better.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Lightweight entertainment
vrbass-129 March 2006
Here's an entertaining little film with one small point to make (maybe one and a half). But it does it in a pleasant way, evoking a nostalgic image of '60s hippies trying to make music, have fun and find a new way in the world. The acting is competent, directing likewise, script is middling but everyone does a good job with it. It's too bad the actors who could portray the '60s attitude are too old for the parts - there's a lot of stereotyping and far-out mugging in attempting to convey the mood of the time. It just doesn't work very well, in my opinion.

I had to go to a bit of trouble to find this on DVD, but finally managed to get it from Germany. If you have a collection of music films from or about the 1960s, this one should definitely be in your collection. If you stumble across a copy, by all means get it. If you're just casually interested, I am not sure a great effort will seem worthwhile, however.

The soundtrack is, of course, completely groovy!
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Interesting to see British Pop stars portrayed by actors
lonzo95-940-30027225 July 2020
But the Jimi Hendrix actor absolutely steals the movie during the dinner scene. If you like 60s rock, and you like Hendrix, then just fast forward to that scene.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Entertaining, well directed, natural acting, genuine moments
jmtindall@hotmail.com16 July 2003
I just saw the film at a film festival in Hollywood. I thought THE TURTLES made a great subject, the time period and other musicians of the era were well represented. The budget is low, but the director (Bill Fishman) did a great job incorporating stock footage, animation, and a limited production schedule. Overall, if you like the song HAPPY TOGETHER, you will be entertained learning more about this group.

Also, Justin Henry, the child actor from Kramer vs. Kramer, turns out a great believable performance. Watch it.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
I thought it was made to sell more Jimi Hendrix product
sidewalksurfer6116 July 2009
Sorry this movie was a bad made for TV movie. Are the rest of you on drugs when you watched it? I thought the hair,make-up and characters were poor 2 dimensional types. The story is doubtful,especially since all of the main characters are dead,or nearly dead. I think it's not well acted either...what was up with that hair on the main guy in the Turtles? It looked glued on badly, and the sideburns looked like they were going to fall off at any moment. It didn't feel like anything new was revealed in the story of the band and how the members met other bands,and people. I laughed all the way through it,Frank Zappa looked stupid,so did Mama Cass, and so did the Beatles. They were made out to look stupid and ridiculous. Also the other band people like Jim Morrison,Donovan also took a big hit at looking stupid too. Kind of terrible,if this is how you remember these people. It's a poor history lesson on music,it's fictional the way it was made.
5 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I loved this film.
rawhitcomb15 July 2003
I smiled through the whole film. The music is great. The story-telling is great. It's a wonderful film. This picture is made with respect and a true love of the sixties.
13 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"My Dinner With Jimi" (2003) is a great "snap shot" of counterculture times .....much better than other "portraits of the 60's"
DavidAllenUSA1 January 2013
"My Dinner With Jimi" (2003) is a great "snap shot" of counterculture times much better than other "portraits of the 60's."

The 60's (which actually took place roughly from 1964 through 1974) were interesting, hopeful times. You had to be there (and the screenplay writer, Howard Kaylan, was there) to understand it, why it was good, important, worth remembering.

And how it worked.

A lot of good things were done, and done because young people wanted to have fun with their adult lives after formal education, and not be chained, tethered to wage slavery or equivalent slavery always part of the "entrepreneur" life.

Most people face wage slavery or the entrepreneur's life, and that was true both before and after the 60's....

Almost nobody is a pure inheritor guaranteed big money, undisputed property ownership, and an important, interesting occupation until he dies, except maybe Prince Charles of England and a small number of people in his same situation.

The 60's suggested that other possibilities might happen in the lives of people who came of age back then, and that included entertainer people like Howard Kaylan of the TURTLES pop music group, and later part of the Frank Zappa band called THE MOTHERS OF INVENTION (for part of the 1970's).

The Howard Kaylan "voice over" actor states at the start of this movie..."When high school graduation came and went, I decided to put college on hold....and do something different!" (I paraphrase).

Many decided to "do something different" or at least try it, and many had good results and times as a result.....

MY DINNER WITH JIMI (2003) is all about that, and for all it's shortcomings, is precious because of that, and worth getting and screening often.

The 60's were different, hopeful, and are worth remembering the way Kaylan has remembered it.....for all the technical and artistic shortcomings of this movie, the overall message and mentality shines through in a way other "memoirs" of various types of the 60's counterculture times and people mostly have failed to do.

BTW, this movie portrays the lives of two members of the 1960's pop music group called the TURTLES....Howard Kaylan and Mark Volman.

Actual movie/video footage of these two gifted comedians and vocal musicians performing astonishingly can be seen in two other videos about and part of the 1960's era.

One is titled THE TRUE STORY OF 200 MOTELS (1984) documentary by Frank Zappa about the making of his 1971 feature avant Gard movie which stars both Kaylan and Volman (they are more prominently shown than Zappa himself is...Zappa was behind the scenes most of the time).

The other movie starring Howard Kaylan and Mark Volman shown in their middle 20's is the actual 200 MOTELS (1971) movie itself.

Get both in addition to MY DINNER WITH JIMI (2003) to have the best portrait of the two TURTLES stars, one of whom wrote the screenplay for MY DINNER WITH JIMI (2003).

Well..........

I got a MY DINNER WITH JIMI (2005) 60's pop music nostalgia movie yesterday, and watched part of it before bedtime.

It's a docudrama memoir acted by modern (recent younger) actors about famous pop singers meeting each other during the 60's done by Howard Kaylan who was part of the TURTLES and later joined Frank Zappa's MOTHERS OF INVENTION.

Howard Kaylan (1947 - ) wrote an autobiographical screenplay produced in 2003....done on no money, promoted at minor film festivals, never a mainstream movie......

I liked it.

Obviously a very cheaply done movie (younger actors especially weren't ideal, and the direction wasn't wonderful, either), but the movie made it's points, and it made me remember the good old days I enjoyed so much, now long gone.

One had to think of the movie as sort of a Greek masked stage drama where the actors were sort of gross symbols of the people they were portraying.

The older actors (not many, since it was a movie about the "youth culture" of the 60's) were very good, few of them as there were.....shows how many old actors are out there willing to be in cheap, "indy" movies.

The TURTLES wrote the song titled "You, Baby, Nobody But You" which I heard the Mamas and the Papas sing, and the song is featured in the movie.

I got the lyrics for the song, and played it on my always handy and available ukulele before going to bed. GREAT SONG!

"A little bit of sunshine! A little bit of soul! And just a touch of magic! "It's the greatest thing since Rock and Roll!"

Same mentality as THE LOVIN SPOONFUL and it's "Good Time Music" ("Do You Believe In Magic?" etc.) Terrific, light, fun....brought back the good times, loud colors, etc.

One big problem presenting a movie about famous music and musicians of the 1960's is that copyright laws and claims make it almost impossible to include any of the music famous in the 1960's and mentioned in MY DINNER WITH JIMI (2003). Only the TURTLES music and hit songs are played, and other music is not presented, though clever ways are found to suggest such music.....

Movie titles were in the gaudy, noisy Peter Maxx style, which was great. Authentic for the times and re-visiting it.

The movie shows the protagonists meeting up with other famous pop singer types at nighttime food and after-hours joints in L.A. and London! A lot of banter light, air-headed, and fun, fun, fun, which was the main point of the times!

You had to be there to understand how great the 60's were, and it's important not to be bitter about how it all ended, promise unfulfilled......

Howard Kaylan's movie isn't bitter...it's fun...and so were the 60's at their best.

----------------
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Fantastic Voyage
olompali414 March 2010
Superb and charming. Justin Henry is beautiful as a blissed out and mischievous Howard Kaylan, lead singer for the top ten hit making band, The Turtles. The real magic is the titular sequence with an academy award worthy turn by Royale Watkins. A performance that completely captures the mystical and yet down to earth Jimi Hendrix. Not many films, unbelievably so, can find the essence of a special moment in a life and times. I'd like to see this available at any home video retail outlet without any hassle. Uh..what's the deal?

Thanks Eddie. A worthy addition to the history of the psychedelic sixties. A definite twinkle in the mind's eye.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Happy Together
valis194925 June 2009
MY DINNER WITH JIMI is a glimpse at Howard Kaylan's giddy and vertiginous ride to fame with his 60's Folk-Rock band, The Turtles. The Turtles were kind of a 'second tier' act during the sixties, but the film clearly demonstrates that they could eat, drink, and party with the Titans of Hippie Culture. And, not only that, they had the musical chops to back it up. Many of the stellar acts of the era are seen as they interact with the band at work and at play. This provides my only complaint about the film. Almost from the beginning of the movie, one sees that it is nearly impossible to find actors who can convincingly impersonate such recognizable stars. Too often during the film, I felt that I was watching an engaging exhibition of phony wigs and mustaches. But, if you are a fan of the music of The Turtles, or The Swinging 60's, in general-this might be the film for you. And, don't forget to view The Extras. There is a very funny (and informative) bit by band members, Mark Volman and Howard Kaylan, about their disastrous experiences with managers and agents.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
In my opinion, this is the best 60's movie ever made.
lindaz28 November 2014
I'm telling all my friends about this film cause I know they'll love it.

Maybe because I'm from the same generation, maybe because when I walked into my first really hip club in 1967, "Purple Haze" was blasting out. Dear Jimi helped ease my soul into a new dimension.

This movie will definitely appeal to anyone who lived through the rise of rock and roll. It's also a great historical record for younger generations to experience the world-changing music of the 60's.

The Turtles songs were part of my happier memories of the 60's era. Their songs never age.

Though this movie was not expensively made, the acting is very good, the look-a-likes that were chosen were phenomenal, the directing so unobtrusive and the camera work and lighting, in my opinion, were just superb.

If Howard Kaylan reads this THANK YOU for making this film. I know what it's like to try writing your story.

All the best to the Turtle's and thank you for the great music and this cool tribute to Jimi Hendrix whom many of us had the privilege to "experience". Rock on, guys.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A thoroughly entertaining view of a time and place by someone who was there.
rayal195011 December 2019
I had never heard of this movie until it came on Amazon Prime in 2019 and as someone who was alive during the 60's it was wonderful.

Howard Kaylan presents a very tongue in cheek look at his experiences with the Turtles at the point of their first "Big Hit" and tour of England in 1967. Meeting all the usual suspects and their British Invasion heros in 1967 London The Turtles were shocked to find feet of clay in meeting The Beatles, a musical group that were at the height of their power with the release of Sgt Pepper's lonely hearts club band coming the day after the events in the movie.

All the characters are played by actors with various degrees of success. Some come across as caricatures of their public personas. Then again it is all filtered through Howard Kaylan's memory and his well known degree of snark.

Partner Turtle, Mark Volman comes across as a buffoon and is relegated to the background mostly except when singing.

Donovan is a mystic hippie, John Lennon is an insufferable guy. Paul is polite and fun, George just tries to keep John from being an insufferable guy. Ringo is kind of drunk. Meeting Brian Jones (Rolling Stones) in an alley way leads to being introduced to Jimi Hendrix and the subsequent dinner with Jimi, really more of a way to many drinks before eating kind of gabfest for Jimi.

Jimi is a sympathetic and humble man in this portrait, beset by the same insecurities that Howard has about success and acceptance by the audience..

A wonderful filtered by time remembrance by one who was there.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed