ÉVALUATION IMDb
6,3/10
55 k
MA NOTE
Un étudiant en droit devient lieutenant pendant la 2eme Guerre Mondiale, est capturé et doit défendre un prisonnier noir accusé à tort de meurtre.Un étudiant en droit devient lieutenant pendant la 2eme Guerre Mondiale, est capturé et doit défendre un prisonnier noir accusé à tort de meurtre.Un étudiant en droit devient lieutenant pendant la 2eme Guerre Mondiale, est capturé et doit défendre un prisonnier noir accusé à tort de meurtre.
- Prix
- 1 victoire et 1 nomination
Jonathan Brandis
- Pvt. Lewis P. Wakely
- (scenes deleted)
Histoire
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesFormer teen hearthrob Jonathan Brandis hoped to revive his stalled career after being cast in a serious, dramatic role in the film. He was reportedly devastated when almost all of his scenes were removed in the final cut. He fell into a deep depression, began drinking heavily, and killed himself the next year.
- GaffesThere is no way that Col.McNamara could allocate which hut men went into. The Germans controlled this. Also there is no way he could just turn up at the Camp Kommandant's office unannounced and talk to him.
- Citations
Col. Werner Visser: Strange thing about war wounds- the older you get, the less proud of them you become.
- Bandes originalesDeutschland Uber Alles
Music by Joseph Haydn (uncredited)
Performed by The Musikkorps Liebstandarte-SS 'Adolf Hitler'
Courtesy of the Tomahawk Films WW-II German Archive
Commentaire en vedette
The director has done better, but you could do worse
This takes place in a POW camp during WWII, and follows the events that transpire after a few black enlisted men are captured and put among the white prisoners. This has a well-written script, lines are great and well-delivered, the plot is interesting, engaging and develops quite nicely throughout. The editing and cinematography have some inspired moments, and are always marvelous. This is rather exciting and entertaining.
I haven't read the novel, nor did I realize that this was based upon one until I watched it. This is the third of Hoblit's films I've seen, the other two being Frequency and Primal Fear, both of which I find to be excellent. Thus, in comparison, this is a little less impressive. I wouldn't call it poor, however. It certainly has a point to it, something to say, and it communicates it fairly well. The message is good, too.
The performances are impeccable, Willis does as well as we expect, Farrell makes reasonable use of his chance at doing a role that can prove he can do more than project his "bad boy" persona onto the screen, and Howard shines. This meeting and conflict between the experienced master and the up-and-coming student is further infused with the clever juxtaposition of that relationship being not only of their characters – but of the actors, as well.
The DVD comes with two informational, compelling and amusing commentaries: one by Gregory Hoblit, writer Billy Ray and Bruce Willis, and one by producer David Foster, 10 minutes of good deleted scenes with or without director commentary and several photo galleries. There is relatively infrequent strong violence and language. I recommend this to any fan of dramas, and who enjoy movies that deal with history. 7/10
I haven't read the novel, nor did I realize that this was based upon one until I watched it. This is the third of Hoblit's films I've seen, the other two being Frequency and Primal Fear, both of which I find to be excellent. Thus, in comparison, this is a little less impressive. I wouldn't call it poor, however. It certainly has a point to it, something to say, and it communicates it fairly well. The message is good, too.
The performances are impeccable, Willis does as well as we expect, Farrell makes reasonable use of his chance at doing a role that can prove he can do more than project his "bad boy" persona onto the screen, and Howard shines. This meeting and conflict between the experienced master and the up-and-coming student is further infused with the clever juxtaposition of that relationship being not only of their characters – but of the actors, as well.
The DVD comes with two informational, compelling and amusing commentaries: one by Gregory Hoblit, writer Billy Ray and Bruce Willis, and one by producer David Foster, 10 minutes of good deleted scenes with or without director commentary and several photo galleries. There is relatively infrequent strong violence and language. I recommend this to any fan of dramas, and who enjoy movies that deal with history. 7/10
utile•50
- TBJCSKCNRRQTreviews
- 6 déc. 2013
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et surveiller les recommandations personnalisées
- How long is Hart's War?Propulsé par Alexa
Détails
Box-office
- Budget
- 70 000 000 $ US (estimation)
- Brut – États-Unis et Canada
- 19 077 641 $ US
- Fin de semaine d'ouverture – États-Unis et Canada
- 7 771 753 $ US
- 17 févr. 2002
- Brut – à l'échelle mondiale
- 32 287 044 $ US
- Durée2 heures 5 minutes
- Couleur
- Mixage
- Rapport de forme
- 2.35 : 1
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant
Lacune principale
What is the Japanese language plot outline for Le combat du lieutenant Hart (2002)?
Répondre