Coïncidences (1947) Poster

(1947)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Love story
dbdumonteil25 April 2009
This is the only movie by Serge Debecque ,and against all odds,it's a really worthwhile effort;too bad he did not continue .

A rich girl (Suzanne Bara) is in love with her father-in-law 's (Pierre Renoir) librarian (Serge Reggiani) .The wealthy man wants her to marry a military man but she's not prepared to accept it.So,in some kind of "love story" in reverse ,she marries the poor guy. This young man has a cousin (Andrée Clement), who seems secretly in love with him but in fact we 'll never know what she feels.

The movie smartly combines melodrama with fantasy film elements :there are hints at Nostradamus ,fate ,coincidences (check the title) and a box which seems to be a bad luck charm.Suzanne Bara was not much of an actress and her part of a romantic girl who thinks that money cannot buy happiness suffers accordingly.Serge Reggiani is as excellent as ever ,but , for the first and last time in his career ,he is eclipsed by his other female co-star Andrée Clément,whose performance is absolutely mind-boggling.Clement died well before her time at 36,and considering the talent she displays in this movie,one can't help regretting she passed away at such an early age.The audience never knows whether she is good or evil,if she loves the hero or she hates him,if she gave him the mysterious box because she had sworn to ruin him.

The actress is cold ,often dressed in black ,she has disturbing lines such as "It never happens anything to me" or " there's not enough room for my grief in your house" ."Coincidences" is ,along Decoin's "La Fille Du Diable" (another must for French cinema connoisseurs),her best role.

The last pictures compare favorably with works such as "Peter Ibbetson" or "Portrait of Jennie" .Good depictions of the garden party and the farandole around "Le Feu De La Saint Jean" (bonfire lit to celebrate the summer solstice).

Like this?try these......

"Le Pays Sans Etoiles" Georges Lacombe 1945

"La Foire Aux Chimères" Pierre Chenal 1946

"La Fille Du Diable" Henry Decoin 1945

"Les Amants du Pont Saint Jean " Henry Decoin,1947
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
So noir
happytrigger-64-39051729 March 2019
Warning: Spoilers
"Coïencidences" is an unkown french drama from the 1947 noir genre top year, the only movie directed by Serge Debecque, but written by Pierre Laroche, the sceenwriter of "les Visiteurs du Soir" (one of the masterpieces directed by Marcel Carné) or "la Fille aux Yeux Gris" (another unknown masterpiece directed by Jean Faurez). His McGuffin use of that fate box is a fine idea, getting "Coïncidences" darkly confused, because it is the depressing story of a young man handsome but poor falling off the edge of the mind, losing eveything, love and money and at last his mind. As Serge Reggiani loses eveything, his presence turns off like some kind of ghost. His cousin, Andrée Clément, is faithful to help him, perhaps in love with him, but always sad and dressed in black, her attitude is a total mystery, just check her first meeting with Reggiani's love (who is always happy, smiling and singing), they exchange too much complicity about their dresses. Andrée Clément was the magnificent héroïne of "la Fille du Diable" (by Henri Decoin), played in only 13 movies, a bad luck number for her, she died at 36. Pierre Renoir is perfect as the rich hating the poor and who takes a superior pleasure to tell it to the poor Serge Reggiani. He really is the bad man of the movie. Only one reviewer for this unknown gem, still DD without whom ... Hanx again DD.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed