The Miller's Daughter (1905) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Has Some Good Photography, With Interesting Backgrounds & Good Composition
Snow Leopard14 June 2005
The strongest aspect of this short drama is the photography, and that is what makes it worth seeing. There is a good variety of interesting backgrounds, and in most scenes the composition and use of the camera is pretty good for the time.

The story of "The Miller's Daughter" is only somewhat interesting in itself, in part because it is the kind of story that was extremely common in its era. It focuses on the consequences of the daughter's inappropriate choice of suitors, and while the plot is fairly involved for a 1905 movie, it's all familiar material. On the other hand, there are some stretches of the movie that are still missing, and it's possible that the film would work better if it were complete.

What still works is the cinematography. The majority of the film was shot outdoors, and it used backgrounds ranging from a meadow with cows grazing to a river with a waterfall to a city street. These are all interesting, and in most cases they do a good job of setting off the action, with composition that shows some good planning.

By contrast, the sets for the indoor scenes look plainer, and one dramatic scene that is supposed to take place outdoors was instead filmed against a stage background, which was no doubt out of practicality, but it diminishes the scene's impact. As a whole, the movie is not bad, and the good photography in particular makes it worth watching.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Edison Company comes up with snappy new title . . .
cricket3013 April 2013
Warning: Spoilers
. . . for HAZEL KIRKE, a well-known play of Turn of the Century Times (on a par with DEATH OF A SALESMAN or GLENGARRY GLEN ROSS today). The folks that thought burning the shrieking beloved Coney Island headlining elephant Topsy alive would make great family entertainment decided that replacing a title well-known to their target audience with the chapter heading from an obscure collection of dirty stories written five or six centuries earlier made good business sense (which may give you a tiny clue as to why the Edison Motion Picture Company folded up its tent a few years after THE MILLER'S DAUGHTER was released to a mystified public). The makers of this 13 minute 7 second short (not counting the running time of the most important scenes, which the DVD talking heads claim were "lost," a statement some might not take at face value) at least anticipated the sort of thing that OSHA shortly would concern itself with, by casting a well-insulated actress to play the title role, which involves her would-be suicide plunge into a wintry river. As far as I can tell, no one is killed for real here (at least on-screen in the segments the DVD producers have chosen to share with us), unlike the case with THE LONE FISHERMAN, THE INTERRUPTED BATHERS, or ELECTROCUTING AN ELEPHANT.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Run-of-the-Mill One-Reel Melodrama
Cineanalyst26 March 2010
"The Miller's Daughter" is an average one-reeler from early cinema--a typical melodrama touting country life as good and the city as sinful. The miller's daughter faces rival suitors and chooses the city slicker over the honest farmer and her father's wishes. After it's revealed that the man from the city is already married, the miller banishes his daughter. In the city, the daughter ends up attempting suicide. Anyhow, if you haven't heard this scenario before, you're, apparently, not very familiar with the genre.

The film has its moments, though. The first two scenes quickly establish the rival suitors. There's a nice painting scene by a waterfall. On the other hand, there's the generic melodrama, the convenient ending, and a poor set for the suicide scene. The film is missing a couple scenes, which on Kino's "Edison: the Invention of the Movies" DVD are replaced by explanatory title cards based on the Edison catalogue description.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4 from Edison
Michael_Elliott12 March 2008
Miller's Daughter, The (1905)

*** (out of 4)

Hazel is kicked out of her father's house when he learns she's involved with a married man and refuses to marry a good farmer who her father likes. Eventually Hazel finds herself on the streets, too poor to live anywhere and her father still hates her for her selection in men. This here was a pretty brutal and harsh film that deals with poverty, suicide and pretty much everything else in between. It's rather touching in the end as the girl gets one more chance at doing the right thing.

Watermelon Patch, The (1905)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

Several black men are stealing watermelon so the farmers put out scarecrow's with real men to scare them away. Here's another politically insensitive short that uses race to get laughs and while some of the stereotypes are so horribly over the top you can't help but roll your eyes and laugh.

Train Wreckers, The (1905)

*** (out of 4)

A group of men get their kicks by derailing trains but they meet their match in a feisty woman who will stop at nothing to protect the trains. This is a pretty intense action/thriller that has some wonderful stunt work including one scene where the woman is knocked out on the tracks and a man has to climb to the front of the train and pick her up moments before being ran over.

Life of an American Policeman (1905)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

Shows the everyday life of a policeman from waking up in the morning, having breakfast with his children and his duties on the job. Some nice stunt work but not nearly in the same league as Life of an American Firefighter.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed