Recluse (1981) Poster

(1981)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Downbeat and fascinating film about a tragic true event
Red-Barracuda9 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This short film is a about a true event that happened in 1975 known as the Luxton Tragedy. At an isolated farm one night three elderly people who had lived there for decades committed murder and suicide resulting in the deaths of all of them. They were a family compromising of two brothers and one sister. I am not sure how close the film stays to the factual evidence but it suggests that these were people whom time had left behind. Old age had made running the farm impractical, while the younger brother seemed to suffer from mental illness where he often saw and interacted with dead people from his past such as his stern father and a mysterious girl he was attracted to in his youth. His older brother and sister decide to sell the farm. The younger brother is aggressively against such a move but the older siblings also struggle with the idea of massive change at this stage in their lives. This ultimately leads to the tragic events.

Seemingly, this was actually shot on location at the Luxton farm itself which certainly is great authenticity and an additional layer of interest. The film also hints very strongly at an incestuous relationship between the older siblings which adds even further to the damaged nature of these individuals and the isolated life they have led up to this point. Although I have read elsewhere that there has been some strong debate as to the veracity of this claim. Whatever the case, the film was always going to be speculative to at least some extent, as all the participants died on the fateful night. The film itself is a fascinating low-key drama which tells its sad story very effectively in its short run-time.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Reclusive.
DoorsofDylan17 November 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Arriving home I was in the mood to watch a short film. Having seen the superb The Black Panther (also reviewed), I felt it was tine to play the bonus film.

View on the film:

Coming out after spending decades in the vault, the BFI present a great transfer, with the graininess of the film print being a fitting match to the rustic setting, and the soundtrack being clean.

Detailing in a commentary over behind the scenes footage that the film was shot where The Luxton tragedy had taken place, co-writer (with Paddy Fletcher) / director Bob Bentley & The Duke of Burgundy (2014-also reviewed) cinematographer Nicholas D. Knowland farm an errie True Crime atmosphere from icy, long lingering wide-shots gazing at the farm and listening in on the rustic sounds, with Bentley making the most of the real location, (filled with all the household items the Luxton's used in their daily lives) in jagged panning shots across the cramped, isolated farmland.

Refusing to give any easy answers to the Luxton murder case, (played by the terrific trio of Derek Smith, Maurice Denham and Ann Tirard, who each express in their understated body language, the tension the family shared, in being no longer able to run the family farm) the screenplay by Fletcher and Bentley explores the sinking feeling each family member feels, that the life they have known for decades, is fading away, with the reclusive state of the farmers being laced by the writers with possible incest, laying at the heart of the farm.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great movie
miclhole8 October 2005
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this film in the old days,when there was always a B movie before the main event. I live about 10 miles from the scene of the action,in Devon. It is a true story of murder and suicide,set in the hills north of Dartmoor.The plot centres on an isolated farming family,called the luxtons who time has left behind,with their problems in getting to grip with ageing,and mental illness. Filmed on location,on the actual farm where the three main characters really lived (and died)With a great cast It is a small Classic. See it when you can because it is rare. Spoiler . Two Brothers and a Sister live on an isolated farm,near Dartmoor. The elder brother and the sister seem to have a full relationship,while the younger brother tries to brake free,without success. When the Brother and Sister see that the old life can't go on forever,they decide on the change that the younger brother can't take. He kills himself,then the brother kills the Sister.

A gripping murder mystery
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
My family
jmehuws14 July 2021
I only found out about this movie yesterday. I was having a conversation with my auntie, and she tells me that this was our family. I had an uncle called Alan, he was famous for appearing in coronation street back in the 70s. I think alan died in 1975, a couple of years before thus tragic event. I'm so fascinated by all this. I really need to know more if anyone has any information. I've not watched the movie yet but I'm looking forward to it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed