The Pinch Hitter (1917) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
1/10
Possibly the Worst Silent Movie I Have Ever Seen
boblipton17 November 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Charles Ray was a star of the silent era, having shot to fame in the Thomas Ince production of THE COWARD. He was thereafter cast for the next eight years as a country bumpkin who made good, until he got so tired of playing the same role that he went independent, made a famous flop called THE COURTSHIP OF MILES STANDISH and his starring career went into the tank. He ended it playing extras in the 1940s.

SPOILER: GIVES AWAY THE STORY

If he was tired of roles like this, good for him. Here he plays Joel Parker, the son of a farmer who despises him. His father sends him to college only because Joel's dead mother wanted him to go. At college there seems to be no classes. Instead, Joel is tormented by his snobbish fellow students, but befriended by a waitress, played adequately by Sylvia Breamer, who tries to get him to act like a man. He tries out for the college baseball team, where he is thought to be so awful that he is made the team mascot without telling him. Finally, in the big game, a run down at the bottom of the ninth with two outs, they need a pinch hitter, but they've used every player on the bench but Joel, so in desperation they send him in. Eventually he hits a home run, so now his father -- who has come to the game -- and all the students now respect him.

So what do we learn from this story? That success is having despicable people admire you. A heck of a life lesson.

Even worse, Charles Ray walks throughout the entire movie with a glum, vacant look on his face, probably the most boring and annoying characterization in the history of Hollywood.

The print I saw was 48 minutes in length, clearly cut down. At 48 minutes it's far too long. About 48 minutes too long. Avoid this one at all costs.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One for Charles Ray's legion of fans!
JohnHowardReid17 December 2014
Warning: Spoilers
What a wonderful film! Let me confess at once that I'm both a Charles Ray and a Sylvia Breamer fan, so if you don't appreciate Ray's brand of humor and Breamer's wonderful charisma (this is her first movie, would you believe?), you will not enjoy producer Thomas H. Ince's The Pinch Hitter which is now available on a very good Grapevine DVD. The movie was extraordinarily successful with contemporary audiences (and I'm solidly with them), and was actually re-made in 1925 with Glenn Hunter and Constance Bennett in the leads. The remake has disappeared, but it was directed by Joseph Henabery who was noted for his speed rather than his directorial acumen. This one, however, was directed by songwriter Victor Schertzinger. This was his first film, but he followed up with 89 credits as a director and around 120 as a songwriter. Here Schertzinger is already at the top of his form and has produced fine performances from the entire cast. Even minor roles such as that of the baseball coach played here by Louis Durham stay in the memory – and if you're on your toes, you can catch Aggie Herring in an early role as the waitress in the ice cream parlor. All in all, The Pinch Hitter is a most enjoyable experience – especially for baseball fans and those who enjoy Charles Ray and Sylvia Breamer at their best!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed